NFT: Ranking pies

Pumpkin/Yam

Boston Cream

others.....

FWIW, Good Key Lime is good, most are way, way too sweet.

Between tart and sweet is key! Key lime is my fave too. A nice warm apple pie ala mode is not far behind.

Rhubarb
Pecan
Peach

called Weavers.

They make a cherry pie to die for.

Amazing! I try to go there once a week for my apples, veggies and other stuff.

But my true passion is their pies. So based on their pies:

1. Cherry

2. Apple

3. Blueberry

4. Strawberry-Rhubarb

5. Raspberry

If you are every by the Morgantown exit of the PA Turnpike, get off and take Rt 10 North about three miles.

There is a big sign for the orchard.

Cherry
Choc mousse
apple

If done properly, nothing beats pretty much any fruit pie. Just as with Key Lime Pie, bad Cherry Pie can be really bad. Usually I find them too cloyingly sweet. I like Blueberry, Key Lime, Peach, Pecan, Pumpkin, and Strawberry-Rhubarb to put them in alphabetical order.

2. Apple Crumb
3. Blueberry
4. Cherry

Then whatever else, I'm not picky

1. by far, Pecan Pie
2. Apple Crumb
3. Pumpkin

Coconut Custard.
Stop

Had some last night.

(mic drop)

In comment 15026073 NoPeanutz said:

Quote:

Had some last night.

Yes! Ah, no. Love me Shepard's Pie for supper with apple pie desert...

banana cream is pretty excellent

Giants game.

Apple
Pecan
Blueberry

Clear 1) Blueberry
Distant 2) Apple
3) Everything else

with a large scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream on top.

Boston Cream

Scooter Pie (a.k.a. Moon Pie)/Ring Dings/Devil Dogs

Key Lime takes the #1, Lemon Meringue also up there ( I live tart and sweet, also prefer lighter citrusy deserts that are more on the refreshing side).

Next I’d go apple/peach combo cobbler, best of both.

3rd Pecan followed up by Blueberry

is hard to beat

.

a lot. But my brother went to Syracuse and on our way home I would always stop at Bingham's in PA. They've got great pie.
My preference from there:
Chocolate peanut butter, caramel apple crumb, pecan, Strawberry Rhubarb

In comment 15026084 Del Shofner said:

Quote:

Giants game.

lol yep

My Wife's Chocolate Peanut Butter cheesecake
Buttermilk Pie
Key Lime
Banana Cream.

But I do like most any pies:
Apple
Peach
Key Lime
Banana cream
Coconut cream
Chocolate cream
Pumpkin
Pumpkin mousse

Yummy!!

Awesome memories of my Mom’s Lemon Meringue pie. It was the best. After that Apple and Cherry pies.

no order

Apple (regular or lattice crust or crumbletop it doesn't matter)
Cherry
Blueberry
Peach
Peach cobbler
Pumpkin
Sweet potato
Key lime
Lemon meringue
Chocolate mousse
Banana cream

chocolate cream pie is absolutely number 1. No chocolate cream pie I've gotten from any other source is worth a second bite. A good apple pie is next, and I emphasize "good".

Absolutely worst is pecan just ahead of pumpkin.

If so, my favorite "pies" are berry tarts with a vanilla creme patissiere holding the berries onto a classic buttery and crispy short pastry shell.

Strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, blackberry doesn't matter which. Had to be made within the past 4 hours, otherwise the pastry cream ruins the tart shell.

After those, tarte tatin.

in the same crispy butter short pastry crust.

Sweet Potato
Chocolate Chess
Apple
Peach Raspberry



Savory?

A place n Kennett Square, PA makes a Red Thai Chicken Curry pot pie which is the best pot pie I've ever had in my life. (The Chocolate Chess and Peach Raspberry above are also from the same shop)

Pecan
Strawberry Rhubarb
Key Lime
Blueberry

.

My girl can't cook but she can make my banana cream. Guess that was his favorite pie.

In comment 15026068 Sec 103 said:

Quote:

Coconut Custard. Stop

I was going to comment on this thread but now I don't have to. Nailed it.

Amazing!

.

Apple pie (only homemade)

coconut cream pie

fruit tarts count?

But my wife does a Strawberry Rhubarb crisp for larger gatherings that is out of this world (especially with a chunk of French Vanilla Ice cream on top while it's still warm)

Nesselrode
Peach
Strawberry rhubarb
Coconut custard

Raspberry Cream from Briermere Farms on Long Island is the GOAT.

pecan
pecan

blueberry
cherry
coconut cream
key lime
apple crumb

In comment 15026783 Danny Kanell said:

Quote:

Raspberry Cream from Briermere Farms on Long Island is the GOAT.

Briermere farms is pretty amazing, but homemade is still better imo.

Butter Scotch cream
Banana cream
Peach
Apple
Lemon meringue

What can I say, I'm a simple man. A great Apple Pie is just good for the soul.

Give a try to pies at Joe's Craft Pies in Westwood.

Had a delicious apple with a pecan praline topping last night. Excellent quality.