Colombo and Garret came together... and Jones has regressed. Not really a stretch to think that with Judge firing Colombo there isn't at least some tension between Judge and Garrett.
Jones plays mistake free football for 2 weeks in a row. Philly win was the best game of his career.
BBI donkey sqaud: “Jones has regressed!”
Sometimes I forget how many stupid Giants fans exist out there
And we're now supposed to think that ten games into the season, Judge thinks he made a mistake? Doesn't say much for Judge if Judge is now reversing his judgment.
That's never been clear. I could see a strong suggestion by Mara that Judge should hire Garrett because:
1. He's an experience play caller with HC experience.
2. He understand the NFCE.
3. He could help Judge navigate HC duties.
4. Mara has apparently always been fond of Garrett.
5. Garrett did good with Dak.
And we're now supposed to think that ten games into the season, Judge thinks he made a mistake? Doesn't say much for Judge if Judge is now reversing his judgment.
That's never been clear. I could see a strong suggestion by Mara that Judge should hire Garrett because:
1. He's an experience play caller with HC experience.
2. He understand the NFCE.
3. He could help Judge navigate HC duties.
4. Mara has apparently always been fond of Garrett.
5. Garrett did good with Dak.
So, from what you posted above, is there any reason you would not hire Garrett?
IMO. I think the offense is definitely coming around and I see Garrett trying to utilize the skill sets of the personnel on offense. He’s also seeing what works and continues to use it until it’s stopped. With that said, there’s been a few calls inside the Redzone that I was not good with. Bringing in the FB on short yardage and handing him the ball, which got stuffed. The jet sweeps to Engram or reverses inside the Redzone.....not going to succeed given the short field defenses have to cover. Anyway, you can see the offense gaining more confidence and with an improved Oline, will only get better IMO. Lastly, as others already mentioned, probably not a very good idea to give DJ his third OC and offensive scheme in last three years. Talk about stunting development.
That’s available to the public that its easy for knowledgeable people to explain and show their critiques. Do some homework and some googling and you’ll see where articles like this are coming from. One guy on this thread talked about Garrett’s “schemes” being a strength. It’s actually 100% the opposite and there’s evidence that Judge has stepped in and changed what Garrett was a doing. If Garrett is the OC next year it will be because Mara won’t let Judge fire him.
Not necessarily. If Garrett is open minded, he could stick,
Colombo and Garret came together... and Jones has regressed. Not really a stretch to think that with Judge firing Colombo there isn't at least some tension between Judge and Garrett.
Jones plays mistake free football for 2 weeks in a row. Philly win was the best game of his career.
BBI donkey sqaud: “Jones has regressed!”
He has had two good games in a row but before that you could easily say he regressed from last year.
No one can be excited with the offense this year and some of that has to be on Garrett. However he lost his best offensive weapon in Game 2, a starting LT before the season began, Shepard was out for several weeks and Andrew Thomas came in anything but ready for the NFL. He inherited an overrated Hernandez, a center who never played the position before, a suddenly aging RG and was forced to use a journeyman RT. The TE free agents have done nothing to fill a void. Did Jones regress because of Garrett, or is he simply not as good as some hoped? It took some time but the OC has adapted. Like some of the diversity we are starting to see in the offensive gameplan, but you can only do so much when the line cannot protect the QB.
If that's the case, it's hard to keep him around even now. What's the point?
Judge tried to pry Brian Daboll away from the Bills. It will be interesting to see if there's anything he can do to get it done, this time around.
Huh?? Hard to keep him around? Over "rumblings"?? That's a terrible take. You let a guy go because some hack is trying to stir the pot? That's not the way teams are run
I have to believe that Judge talked to Garrett about Colombo
likely a few times. I certainly would expect he talked to Garrett, who is his direct employee, before the whole DD thing. I believe Garrett has been in the loop.
In general Garrett probably recommended Colombo and it didn't work out, a fact that Garrett probably acknowledges too. I know I have been in positions where I had an employee who wasn't working out, and my boss wanted to do something else. Eventually you give in because it just isn't worth the effort.
Yea, I agree. I want Jones to get more comfortable with the system and add some weapons. I dont want yet another coach fired.
Jones plays mistake free football for 2 weeks in a row. Philly win was the best game of his career.
BBI donkey sqaud: “Jones has regressed!”
That's never been clear. I could see a strong suggestion by Mara that Judge should hire Garrett because:
1. He's an experience play caller with HC experience.
2. He understand the NFCE.
3. He could help Judge navigate HC duties.
4. Mara has apparently always been fond of Garrett.
5. Garrett did good with Dak.
Quote:
And we're now supposed to think that ten games into the season, Judge thinks he made a mistake? Doesn't say much for Judge if Judge is now reversing his judgment.
That's never been clear. I could see a strong suggestion by Mara that Judge should hire Garrett because:
1. He's an experience play caller with HC experience.
2. He understand the NFCE.
3. He could help Judge navigate HC duties.
4. Mara has apparently always been fond of Garrett.
5. Garrett did good with Dak.
So, from what you posted above, is there any reason you would not hire Garrett?
So, from what you posted above, is there any reason you would not hire Garrett?
I didn't have an issue with it.
Can you provide an example of Garrett being a snake?
Quote:
So, from what you posted above, is there any reason you would not hire Garrett?
I didn't have an issue with it.
He is who I hoped they took as OC and I have not lost faith at all.
He is who I hoped they took as OC and I have not lost faith at all.
I actually think he's done a nice job. He called a brilliant game against the Bucs. Jones just couldn't deliver.
I'm fine if we bring him back as of now. Let's see how the rest of the year plays out.
Quote:
He is who I hoped they took as OC and I have not lost faith at all.
I actually think he's done a nice job. He called a brilliant game against the Bucs. Jones just couldn't deliver.
I'm fine if we bring him back as of now. Let's see how the rest of the year plays out.
I still think he will opens it up a bit now that the line is better and the running game looks viable.
There's talk of Garrett stepping down at the end of the season but it's all speculation for now.
Quote:
Colombo and Garret came together... and Jones has regressed. Not really a stretch to think that with Judge firing Colombo there isn't at least some tension between Judge and Garrett.
Jones plays mistake free football for 2 weeks in a row. Philly win was the best game of his career.
BBI donkey sqaud: “Jones has regressed!”
He has had two good games in a row but before that you could easily say he regressed from last year.
And what's a sqaud?
I take everything with a grain of salt.
If that's the case, it's hard to keep him around even now. What's the point?
Judge tried to pry Brian Daboll away from the Bills. It will be interesting to see if there's anything he can do to get it done, this time around.
If that's the case, it's hard to keep him around even now. What's the point?
Judge tried to pry Brian Daboll away from the Bills. It will be interesting to see if there's anything he can do to get it done, this time around.
Huh?? Hard to keep him around? Over "rumblings"?? That's a terrible take. You let a guy go because some hack is trying to stir the pot? That's not the way teams are run
In general Garrett probably recommended Colombo and it didn't work out, a fact that Garrett probably acknowledges too. I know I have been in positions where I had an employee who wasn't working out, and my boss wanted to do something else. Eventually you give in because it just isn't worth the effort.