Archived Thread

Eli vs. his QB Contemporaries in SB performances

No Where Man : 1/10/2021 9:25 pm

Tom Brady 6 SB wins, 4 SB MVP Awards
Eli 2 wins 2 MVPs
Peyton 2 wins 1 MVP
Big Ben 2 wins 0 MVP
Kurt Warner 1 win 1 MVP
Drew Brees 1 win 1 MVP
Joe Flacco 1 win 1 MVP
Brett Favre 1 win 0 MVP
Russell Wilson 1 win 0 MVP
Carson Wentz 1 win 0 MVP
Philip Rivers 0 and 0
Donovan McNabb 0 and 0

Sigh

jlukes : 1/10/2021 9:29 pm : link

Wentz didn't play in the SB

jvm52106 : 1/10/2021 9:54 pm : link

that was Foles.

I'm well aware about Wentz.....

No Where Man : 1/11/2021 2:14 am : link

So by your thinking, I guess Phil Simms only won 1 SB. And btw, add Aaron Rodgers to the list, 1 SB win & 1 MVP

Perform?

MOOPS : 1/11/2021 3:03 am : link

Wentz didn't PERFORM in any SBs, Simms only PERFORMED in one.

So by your way of thinking, you should probably add David Carr and Jared Lorenzen to your list :-)

RE: Perform?

Mike in NY : 1/11/2021 6:05 am : link

In comment 15118196 MOOPS said:

Quote:

Wentz didn't PERFORM in any SBs, Simms only PERFORMED in one.

So by your way of thinking, you should probably add David Carr and Jared Lorenzen to your list :-)

Wentz was the primary starter in a Super Bowl season. Carr and Lorenzen were backups. That being said, I am not sure if Philly makes Super Bowl if Wentz didn’t get injured as offense was stagnating.

Eli is a Hall of Fame QB

Giantimistic : 1/11/2021 8:06 am : link

Not so sure what the post is getting at but Eli is a HOF QB because of his playoff runs, super bowls, SB MVPs, ironman streak, and stat accumulation and a good amount of 4th quarter comebacks.

Eli was who you want in the 4th quarter and playoffs.

Rivers on the other hand is a Hall of Famer because of his regular season play.