Is Golladay or Robinson really THAT good?

I think he's better than KG but I worry about his desire to stay focused after payday. Rumors were that he was milking the hand injury this season but got kicked into gear by AB's presence. If there's any validity to that its a huge red flag. He's also had these lingering injuries the past 2 years that are very Beckham like.

In comment 15153425 bw in dc said:

Quote:

but I don't think it's going to be an easy sell to say go from Trubisky to Daniel Jones. Seriously, why should he do that?

Because Chicago can't afford to re-sign him.

He's going to have to be a biggest offer signing; there isn't any other way he lands here. But biggest offer isn't unrealistic.

Julio and Tyreek Hill can have his production replaced by (checks notes)... Nico Collins? Footballoutsiders.com has Golladay’s two full seasons as the 9th out of 80 qualifiers and 15th out of 83 qualifiers.

I get it. You like Allen Robinson A LOT. That’s fine. But stop acting like Golladay is a replacement level bum receiver.

In comment 15154474 Gatorade Dunk said:

Quote:

In comment 15153425 bw in dc said: Quote: but I don't think it's going to be an easy sell to say go from Trubisky to Daniel Jones. Seriously, why should he do that? Because Chicago can't afford to re-sign him. He's going to have to be a biggest offer signing; there isn't any other way he lands here. But biggest offer isn't unrealistic.

What I mean is if Robinson decides to leave - forget the tag for a second - why would he want to leave one shaky QB for another?

I don't doubt money will be the driver, but if Robinson gets multiple high offers from different teams, I don't think it's unrealistic to think Jones is a deal-breaker.

In comment 15154521 shockeyisthebest8056 said:

Quote:

Julio and Tyreek Hill can have his production replaced by (checks notes)... Nico Collins? Footballoutsiders.com has Golladay’s two full seasons as the 9th out of 80 qualifiers and 15th out of 83 qualifiers. I get it. You like Allen Robinson A LOT. That’s fine. But stop acting like Golladay is a replacement level bum receiver.

Scotty Miller has the best playoff y/c of any receiver who ever played with Tom Brady. Should we give him Randy's gold jacket?

Or can we use our brains and connect one metric with the rest of them?

Kenny Golladay is overrated, IMO, based on one good season and a body type that reminds Giants fans of Plaxico Burress. It is that latter point - the big-bodied WR resembling Plax - that I was suggesting could be replaced by Nico Collins, et al. My apologies for not making that more clear.

In comment 15154558 bw in dc said:

Quote:

In comment 15154474 Gatorade Dunk said: Quote: In comment 15153425 bw in dc said: Quote: but I don't think it's going to be an easy sell to say go from Trubisky to Daniel Jones. Seriously, why should he do that? Because Chicago can't afford to re-sign him. He's going to have to be a biggest offer signing; there isn't any other way he lands here. But biggest offer isn't unrealistic. What I mean is if Robinson decides to leave - forget the tag for a second - why would he want to leave one shaky QB for another? I don't doubt money will be the driver, but if Robinson gets multiple high offers from different teams, I don't think it's unrealistic to think Jones is a deal-breaker.

We know, you keep repeating it over and over. What are you looking for going on 2 straight days of the same posts?