Paul Schwartz - NY Post posts his Mock for the Giants...

That would be a HR.

Zaven Collins is not making it to round 2.

Paul remains out of touch.

that long....

but I can't see how they go OL, OL. 3-4 seems like a good spot for an Edge.

You might need to leave me alone for a few minutes if that happens.

that people label their mocks as 1.0, 2.0, etc

Covering all bases by Mock 18.4

And there are always surprises/reaches that push others down, I wouldn't rule it out. There's a glut of Edge guys in that range for teams looking at pass rush potential and people are gassing up Jamin Davis at LB now, so who knows. Every year the first round ends and there are 4-5 guys out there that nobody thought would be available in the 2nd. He's absolutely perfect for Graham's defense so he's a run to the podium guy for sure.

so while I agree the guy is unlikely to be there, it isn't on the writer

As I said before, I would sub in Michael Carter (RB) if available at the 3 spot.

With Collins at 11.

But as others have mentioned, the likelihood of Collins reaching our pick in the 2nd round is next to nil.

In comment 15211639 Peter from NH (formerly CT) said:

Quote:

so while I agree the guy is unlikely to be there, it isn't on the writer

PFF has their bias embedded in that simulator - players like Zaven Collins and Dyami Brown are always available later than expected, while players like Jamar Johnson (S, Indiana) start getting propped up as best available by the middle of the second round.

Fanspeak is wonky in its own way, but avoids a bit of the PFF oddities and would have have been a good way to run a second mock to sanity-check his PFF output.

In comment 15211616 GIANTS128 said:

Quote:

that long....

weird things happen in the draft.

In comment 15211636 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

that people label their mocks as 1.0, 2.0, etc Covering all bases by Mock 18.4

That made me laugh.

In comment 15211636 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

that people label their mocks as 1.0, 2.0, etc Covering all bases by Mock 18.4

Can you really blame them though? As we see this time of year on BBI, mock drafts get the clicks.

I just wish some of them would be a bit more creative in their format.

They have Giants listed with fewest areas of need among all the NFC East teams.

.

If Collins somehow drops is he a candidate for a Giants trade up?

....this roster is in need of O-Line, Edge, ILB and more O-Line talent.

shows that he knows that the Giants need and want a lot better than the national writers.