for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Favoritism is Dead?

Anakim : 5/2/2021 11:34 pm
Couldn't think of a better thread title :P, but I was re-reading Yankee28's thread about our coaching connections to the 2021 class (phenomenal work by him, BTW) and of the 9 players we acquired in the last few days, none were under the watchful eye of any of our assistant coaches....

Well, Aaron Robinson spent his freshman year at Alabama so it's possible that Burton Burns, Jody Wright and Jeremy Pruitt are somewhat familiar with him. Kevin Sherrer probably helped recruit Ojulari to Georgia, but Sherrer left Georgia in 2017 and Ojulari's redshirted in 2018.

But I found it quite interesting. We've brought in a lot of coaches from the college ranks and many of them hailed from big-time programs, especially from the best conference in CFB: the SEC. Burton Burns was recently with Alabama - no players taken or signed from there (granted we were reportedly hot and heavy for DeVonta Smith and Landon Dickerson, but still). Derek Dooley was recently with Missouri - no players taken or signed from there. Rob Sale was recently with Arizona State and ULL - no players taken or signed from either school. Pat Flaherty and Sean Spence were recently with Penn State - no players taken or signed from there. Russ Callaway was recently with LSU - no players taken or signed from there. Jeremy Pruitt was recently with UTenn (as was Kevin Sherrer, Craig Fitzgerald and Carter Blount) and 'Bama - no players taken or signed from either place. Sam Coad was recently with Texas A& M - no players taken or signed from there.

Joe Judge mentioned in an interview with Bob Papa that he relied on his assistants (especially Jeremy Pruitt and Jody Wright) for intel on a lot of these players as they were part of the recruiting process for many of these players, but I find it interesting that none of our coaches have any direct connections (again, you can say Ojulari and Robinson, but if anything, the relationship wasn't recent) to any of our 9 new players...at least not since high school. Of course coaches talk, but as far as first-hand knowledge goes? Nope.
Not really accurate  
Eric on Li : 5/2/2021 11:43 pm : link
Not only was Kevin Sherrer Ojulari's primary recruiter to UGA but Jeremy Pruitt was his primary recruiter trying to get him to UT. How many teams have multiple coaches on staffs who were in their potential draft picks living rooms with their families when they were 15-16-17 years old?

Robinson may not have played but he was on the Bama team while a bunch of coaches were there, who also had similar insights to his recruiting process even if they weren't the primary recruiters.

And while there may not be a direct connection w/ Toney he's an SEC prospect who was originally recruited out of Alabama. Saban may not have signed him but you can bet he knew everything there is to know about him (including how difficult he was to defend last December).
The only counterpoint I would make  
mfsd : 5/2/2021 11:47 pm : link
is they once again seemed to place high value on guys they met with and liked at the senior bowl
I think it was overstated not dead  
Mike in NY : 5/2/2021 11:47 pm : link
It is possible we had guys ranked higher than they should have been because of connections, but that doesn’t mean the draft fell out to where those guys were BPA. It looked like there was added emphasis on Senior Bowl and those they got to meet face to face with.
Also this isn't really that different than last year  
Eric on Li : 5/2/2021 11:48 pm : link
Kevin Sherrer was the only direct link to Thomas last year.
Burton Burns was the direct link to McKinney but playing/coaching on different sides of the ball there wasn't any direct coaching.
I don't recall any connections to Peart & Holmes (or Williamson/Coughlin/Brunson).
Pratik Patel would have been the only link to Lemiuex.

So I think Cam Brown was really the only player in 2 years whose direct CFB position coach was also on this staff.
RE: I think it was overstated not dead  
Anakim : 5/3/2021 12:08 am : link
In comment 15250995 Mike in NY said:
Quote:
It is possible we had guys ranked higher than they should have been because of connections, but that doesn’t mean the draft fell out to where those guys were BPA. It looked like there was added emphasis on Senior Bowl and those they got to meet face to face with.


Yeah, that seems to be a better way to phrase it.
RE: Not really accurate  
Anakim : 5/3/2021 12:09 am : link
In comment 15250993 Eric on Li said:
Quote:
Not only was Kevin Sherrer Ojulari's primary recruiter to UGA but Jeremy Pruitt was his primary recruiter trying to get him to UT. How many teams have multiple coaches on staffs who were in their potential draft picks living rooms with their families when they were 15-16-17 years old?

Robinson may not have played but he was on the Bama team while a bunch of coaches were there, who also had similar insights to his recruiting process even if they weren't the primary recruiters.

And while there may not be a direct connection w/ Toney he's an SEC prospect who was originally recruited out of Alabama. Saban may not have signed him but you can bet he knew everything there is to know about him (including how difficult he was to defend last December).


Right, but that was at least 3-4 years ago. I mean how you are as a senior in high school is much different than how you were in college, both as a player and as a person.
RE: RE: Not really accurate  
Eric on Li : 5/3/2021 12:20 am : link
In comment 15251003 Anakim said:
Quote:
In comment 15250993 Eric on Li said:


Quote:


Not only was Kevin Sherrer Ojulari's primary recruiter to UGA but Jeremy Pruitt was his primary recruiter trying to get him to UT. How many teams have multiple coaches on staffs who were in their potential draft picks living rooms with their families when they were 15-16-17 years old?

Robinson may not have played but he was on the Bama team while a bunch of coaches were there, who also had similar insights to his recruiting process even if they weren't the primary recruiters.

And while there may not be a direct connection w/ Toney he's an SEC prospect who was originally recruited out of Alabama. Saban may not have signed him but you can bet he knew everything there is to know about him (including how difficult he was to defend last December).



Right, but that was at least 3-4 years ago. I mean how you are as a senior in high school is much different than how you were in college, both as a player and as a person.


right but the point is how is that different from last year? There were 2 players/coaches who were on staffs with draft picks last year (out of almost twice as many draft picks) and 1 such player this year (robinson at bama pre transfer). Isn't it notable that they have selected multiple players each year who played for or been recruited by Saban/Smart?

Judge has routinely cited direct knowledge/relationships with the players dating back to when they were recruits. I don't think he thinks of it as useless info from several years ago. I think they view it as direct insight into what these guys were like before they took athlete PR training classes and got coached up by agents for the predraft process.
RE: RE: RE: Not really accurate  
Anakim : 5/3/2021 12:41 am : link
In comment 15251011 Eric on Li said:
Quote:
In comment 15251003 Anakim said:


Quote:


In comment 15250993 Eric on Li said:


Quote:


Not only was Kevin Sherrer Ojulari's primary recruiter to UGA but Jeremy Pruitt was his primary recruiter trying to get him to UT. How many teams have multiple coaches on staffs who were in their potential draft picks living rooms with their families when they were 15-16-17 years old?

Robinson may not have played but he was on the Bama team while a bunch of coaches were there, who also had similar insights to his recruiting process even if they weren't the primary recruiters.

And while there may not be a direct connection w/ Toney he's an SEC prospect who was originally recruited out of Alabama. Saban may not have signed him but you can bet he knew everything there is to know about him (including how difficult he was to defend last December).



Right, but that was at least 3-4 years ago. I mean how you are as a senior in high school is much different than how you were in college, both as a player and as a person.



right but the point is how is that different from last year? There were 2 players/coaches who were on staffs with draft picks last year (out of almost twice as many draft picks) and 1 such player this year (robinson at bama pre transfer). Isn't it notable that they have selected multiple players each year who played for or been recruited by Saban/Smart?


Sure, and that's my point. We were able to see it more last year than this year. I'm not sure what to make of it, if anything. I mean every coach has his personal favorites and I'm sure our assistants have theirs, but it doesn't appear that it's enough for us to draft or sign those players.
Adding to what Mike in NY said ...  
Spider56 : 5/3/2021 8:29 am : link
Input from these contacts is only part of the equation and it appears the Giants held true to their value board ... otherwise we would have seen them take an .OL at some point. Also, don’t always assume input is positive. The Giants passed on Micah and several others with close ties who had questions relating to either character or skill. ...Also possible feedback wasn’t consistent with the culture JJ is looking for. Good subject for discussion.
Even if these coaches didn't overlap with the players at a school  
Mike from Ohio : 5/3/2021 8:45 am : link
that doesn't mean they don't know them. If a big time recruit plays for Georgia, what are the odds someone from Alabama didn't spend a bunch of time recruiting the kid?

It's nice to draw these direct lines between where someone coached and who they coached, but they know a much larger swatch of players than that.
The connections continue  
k2tampa : 5/3/2021 8:58 am : link
with the coaching staffs at some of these schools. It is important to know who you can believe and whose comments you should take with a grain of salt. The colleges coaches will all share the basics, 'he is a good kid, works hard, etc.' But they may not share all the negatives. Remember, these college coaches want their kids to be drafted high. It's good for recruiting. So knowing who you can really trust with sharing all the info can help.
Remember JoeJudge still has connections at Georgia and Alabama....  
Simms11 : 5/3/2021 9:45 am : link
as well. I’m sure he’s picked up the phone quite a few times to talk with Saban or a Kirby Smart about their players too.
Intel cuts both ways - positive and negative.  
Big Blue Blogger : 5/3/2021 10:08 am : link
Personal familiarity adds detail and confidence to the evaluation of a player. The grade doesn't necessarily get higher, and it might even get lower. All else being equal, you pick the player who is the more known quantity; but the value still needs to be there.
This may be a bit of a side note but  
SleepyOwl : 5/3/2021 11:03 am : link
i found it very interesting that the Giants for the most part selected players that either played during the 2020 season or they met with in-person. Coach Judge mentioned that being able to look at a player in the eye was a huge part of the drafting process. They also seemed to take the in-person approach during free agency, having guys come in and meet with everyone. In the same breadth he added that being able to meet with players personally was something that he looked forward to doing during the 2022 draft process. Not surprisingly it seemed almost as if the Giants wisely punted this draft to 2022 adding 3 picks in a draft where they will be able to fully evaluate players.
All around amazing job by this front office and coaches. How good is this Judge guy?
Back to the Corner