Who is one Giant that you wish won a Championship/Super Bowl

Agree with all the other names mentioned too. Especially Brad Van Pelt.

I’m out on Tiki. In on LP

as also a dave in hoboken, i second jason sehorn.

.

.

In comment 15377985 Jerry in_DC said:

Quote:

I just wish his career had worked out differently. He was so damn good and really the only interesting thing about this team in almost 10 years. But he handled himself poorly. And, like so many Giants in the past 15 years, long term injuries prematurely eroded his ability. There is a world in which he is an absolute Giants legend. Not this world unfortunately.

I had a similar thought. It's sad how that turned out.

Ron Johnson

Rodney Hampton

John Mendenhall

Spider Lockhart

Troy Archer

Bob Tucker

In comment 15378077 Bill2 said:

Quote:

Ron Johnson Rodney Hampton John Mendenhall Spider Lockhart Troy Archer Bob Tucker

Rodney won a Ring with the 1990 Giants.

A Ron Johnson/Fran Tarkenton team wining a Super Bowl around 1970 or so would have probably changed my whole attitude about sports, and maybe about life in general. Seriously, growing up with my favorite teams ALWAYS sucking really shaped some of my whole outlook.

only played with the Giants and Vikings. Destined to be without a trophy.

He did himself no favors by trashing Eli on day one of his broadcasting career. But he was really a great player and had a great career

.

-

really...

Jessie Armstead would be a close second.

I wish Simms was the starting - and winning - QB against the Bills in SB25 so he would now be in the HoF.

I know this doesn't answer this specific question, but I have always been irritated the Simms isn't in Canton.

*

Joe Morris
many others...

In comment 15378130 bw in dc said:

Quote:

I wish Simms was the starting - and winning - QB against the Bills in SB25 so he would now be in the HoF. I know this doesn't answer this specific question, but I have always been irritated the Simms isn't in Canton.

He should be. And I think he's a lock if he's the starter & we win XXV.

In comment 15377960 mpinmaine said:

Quote:

K Hamilton Hilliard

Agree with this and I'll add Charles Way, Jason Sehorn, and Tiki Barber.

I don't agree with the Tiki adds, but to each their own. He was a helluva Giant, but the off the field stuff still sticks in my craw.

.

Angel. I Forgot about that

and John Mendenhall.

In comment 15378147 mvftw said:

Quote:

Joe Morris many others...

Morris has a ring from the 86 team, he was a monster that year

In comment 15377955 Chris684 said:

Quote:

Not only because a pretty well distinguished NYG WR, but also, anyone who was ever at Training Camp up in Albany knows that Ike Hilliard accommodated every last fan that wanted to interact with him. Even if it meant standing out in the sun and heat after practice for an hour. He is just a great guy.

Great summation of Ike as a Giant Chris684, my son wore #88 on his youth football team and I went up to Albany and Ike did as you said. He signed an autograph to my son who was in camp that day so I did not bring him. The next year I brought my son to Albany and we got Matt Bryant's autograph. He had a long career and was very nice to us. My son has passed on but those moments bring back happy memories.
My mind went right to Tiki and Hamilton on the original question. Those 2 players kept us in the hunt and were tough as well as fun to watch.

Ike was a great Giant. And fuck Dawkins for that cheap shot that ended his '02 season.

In comment 15378207 SFGFNCGiantsFan said:

Quote:

Ike was a great Giant. And fuck Dawkins for that cheap shot that ended his '02 season.

That still makes me angry to this day. He was a dirty fucker

Sort of doesn’t answer the question but seeing Sterling Shepard win a ring would be a thrill for me

glad tiki didn't get it actually.

Joe morris on the team when they won in 86

Armstead was the first who came to mind. Then Jennings, Van Pelt, Hamilton, Tiki

But really that whole crew of Sehorn, Hilliard, Hamilton, etc.— which is why it sucks they lost XXXV (the only super bowl I’ve ever been to, ugh). That said— Toomer and Strahan getting theirs in ‘07 made that one all that much sweeter. So happy to be able to say Toomer won a SB with us and not only that but he had a lot of key receptions/plays on route to that title in the playoffs. Look at all the big plays, tight rope catches, and great snags he made in traffic /tight coverage he made in that run (link below)
Every Amani Toomer catch 2007 playoffs - ( New Window )

is one of my favorite Giants. Excellent, underrated player. 60+ sacks for a DT is very good production.

Jones Jack Gregory

for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up.


Simms his 2nd -- where he PLAYED. So he'd be in the HOF now.

In comment 15378059 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

.

+1

In comment 15378273 David B. said:

Quote:

for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up.

totally with you on Eli winning a 3rd to shut everyone up

In comment 15378340 Debaser said:

Quote:

In comment 15378273 David B. said: Quote: for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up. totally with you on Eli winning a 3rd to shut everyone up

also agree

Kerry Collins is my choice, dude really turned his life around as a NYG. Still not sure why he got cut for Kurt Warner.

In comment 15378059 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

.

My God, yes, how the hell did I mention Del Shofner and forget Y.A. Tittle.

Sehorn.

came oh so close against the Bears in 1963. Keep seeing that dropped TD pass in the end zone.....

In comment 15378346 Rory said:

Quote:

In comment 15378340 Debaser said: Quote: In comment 15378273 David B. said: Quote: for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up. totally with you on Eli winning a 3rd to shut everyone up also agree Kerry Collins is my choice, dude really turned his life around as a NYG. Still not sure why he got cut for Kurt Warner.

he didn't get cut. he asked out because he wanted to be the starter and not the guy keeping the seat warm for Eli so the Giants accommodated him and gave him his release

Loved those guy. Barrow is a good one too.

Chris Calloway
Ike Hilliard
Phillippi Sparks
Jason Sehorn
Keith Hamilton

In comment 15378077 Bill2 said:

Quote:

Ron Johnson Rodney Hampton John Mendenhall Spider Lockhart Troy Archer Bob Tucker

Hampton was a rookie on the '90 team. He got hurt and missed playoffs, but he's got a ring.

Yes. Understood that mistake based on a post yesterday from Angel Eyes. (730pm above).

Thanks for setting the record straight

7:18pm

...

Brad Van Pelt.
Rob Carpenter.

Mendenhall
Ron Johnson
Rob Carpenter
Brad Van Pelt