Who is one Giant that you wish won a Championship/Super Bowl

But really that whole crew of Sehorn, Hilliard, Hamilton, etc.— which is why it sucks they lost XXXV (the only super bowl I’ve ever been to, ugh). That said— Toomer and Strahan getting theirs in ‘07 made that one all that much sweeter. So happy to be able to say Toomer won a SB with us and not only that but he had a lot of key receptions/plays on route to that title in the playoffs. Look at all the big plays, tight rope catches, and great snags he made in traffic /tight coverage he made in that run (link below)
Every Amani Toomer catch 2007 playoffs - ( New Window )

is one of my favorite Giants. Excellent, underrated player. 60+ sacks for a DT is very good production.

Jones Jack Gregory

for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up.


Simms his 2nd -- where he PLAYED. So he'd be in the HOF now.

In comment 15378059 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

.

+1

In comment 15378273 David B. said:

Quote:

for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up.

totally with you on Eli winning a 3rd to shut everyone up

In comment 15378340 Debaser said:

Quote:

In comment 15378273 David B. said: Quote: for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up. totally with you on Eli winning a 3rd to shut everyone up

also agree

Kerry Collins is my choice, dude really turned his life around as a NYG. Still not sure why he got cut for Kurt Warner.

In comment 15378059 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

.

My God, yes, how the hell did I mention Del Shofner and forget Y.A. Tittle.

Sehorn.

came oh so close against the Bears in 1963. Keep seeing that dropped TD pass in the end zone.....

In comment 15378346 Rory said:

Quote:

In comment 15378340 Debaser said: Quote: In comment 15378273 David B. said: Quote: for his 3rd. To shut everyone else the fuck, up. totally with you on Eli winning a 3rd to shut everyone up also agree Kerry Collins is my choice, dude really turned his life around as a NYG. Still not sure why he got cut for Kurt Warner.

he didn't get cut. he asked out because he wanted to be the starter and not the guy keeping the seat warm for Eli so the Giants accommodated him and gave him his release

Loved those guy. Barrow is a good one too.

Chris Calloway
Ike Hilliard
Phillippi Sparks
Jason Sehorn
Keith Hamilton

In comment 15378077 Bill2 said:

Quote:

Ron Johnson Rodney Hampton John Mendenhall Spider Lockhart Troy Archer Bob Tucker

Hampton was a rookie on the '90 team. He got hurt and missed playoffs, but he's got a ring.

Yes. Understood that mistake based on a post yesterday from Angel Eyes. (730pm above).

Thanks for setting the record straight

7:18pm

...

Brad Van Pelt.
Rob Carpenter.

Mendenhall
Ron Johnson
Rob Carpenter
Brad Van Pelt