All Threads
Football Threads
Non Football Threads
Forum Archives
Old Forum Archives
Forum Stats
Terms of Use
Code Of Conduct
Privacy Policy
FAQ
About Us
Contact Us
Amazon.com
Roster
Depth Chart
Scouting Reports
Transactions
Player Salaries
Contact Info
Administration
Coaching Staff
Coaching History
Annual Records
Hall Of Fame
Retired Jerseys
Ring Of Honor
Schedule
Previews/Reviews
Standings (NFL.com)
Statistics (Giants.com)
Historical Stats
Free Agency
The Draft
Training Camp
Important Dates
Giant Of The Year Award
Articles
Glossary
Links
Login
Register
Activate User
Forgot Login Info
Home
Corner Forum
Gameday
Team
Team Building
Giants Info & History
Info/Links
Log In
Archived Thread
Cast your HOF vote
gogiants
: 9/22/2021 4:57 pm
Eight former Giants on the list
https://www.profootballhof.com/fanvote/
- (
New Window
)
I think Hester
theold5j
: 9/22/2021 5:10 pm :
link
Should be in
How
Toth029
: 9/22/2021 5:23 pm :
link
The hell is Boselli not in there yet?
RE: How
Angel Eyes
: 9/22/2021 5:29 pm :
link
In comment
15379681
Toth029 said:
Quote:
The hell is Boselli not in there yet?
Two words: short career.
If John Lynch is is Rondae should as well
shadow_spinner0
: 9/22/2021 5:33 pm :
link
I voted for Boselli, both Barbers, Allen, Hester, O'Neal, Mangold, Mills Z Thomas and Watters
That's a long list...
bw in dc
: 9/22/2021 5:40 pm :
link
How the hell is Pat Swilling not in?? What a great player...
I would definitely say Watters, both Barbers, Seymour, Boselli, EWilliams...
Eight Giants, and not one of them in named
truebluelarry
: 9/22/2021 6:28 pm :
link
Jimmy Patton.
Of the eight, I'd say Landetta is most deserving. Most fans dismiss him because of that fluke in Chicago in 1985, but he was a tremendous player for a long time and very dependable. His performance in the 1986 NFCCG alone atoned for that whiff.
RE: That's a long list...
Bobby Humphrey's Earpad
: 9/22/2021 7:03 pm :
link
In comment
15379694
bw in dc said:
Quote:
How the hell is Pat Swilling not in?? What a great player...
I would definitely say Watters, both Barbers, Seymour, Boselli, EWilliams...
Swilling was an athletic freak and a great pass rusher who benefited from HOF Rickey Jackson on the other side. Sam Mills was a better overall player.
...
SFGFNCGiantsFan
: 9/22/2021 7:07 pm :
link
I must be still drunk from Saturday, but Jake Freaking Delhomme is on that list? WTF?
Not a fan of his, but Rodney Harrison was a HOFer to me. Woodson too.
Why?
David B.
: 9/22/2021 7:11 pm :
link
Fan votes don't matter AT ALL.
RE: RE: How
Toth029
: 9/22/2021 7:13 pm :
link
In comment
15379685
Angel Eyes said:
Quote:
In comment 15379681 Toth029 said:
Quote:
The hell is Boselli not in there yet?
Two words: short career.
Six seasons, 5x PB and 3x AP. His impact was huge and he was a big reason why the Jags were perennial contenders.
...
SFGFNCGiantsFan
: 9/22/2021 7:18 pm :
link
GTFO with this 'Short career' nonsense re. Boselli. Look @ Terrell Davis.
RE: ...
FStubbs
: 9/22/2021 7:19 pm :
link
In comment
15379752
SFGFNCGiantsFan said:
Quote:
I must be still drunk from Saturday, but Jake Freaking Delhomme is on that list? WTF?
Not a fan of his, but Rodney Harrison was a HOFer to me. Woodson too.
If Rodney Harrison goes in, Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens should go in in baseball.
FStubbs
SFGFNCGiantsFan
: 9/22/2021 7:21 pm :
link
I'd argue both Bonds & Clemens should be in the HOF. Enough of this moral high ground stuff. Both were HOFers before they started juicing.
The only way Delhomme gets in
jmdvm
: 9/22/2021 10:42 pm :
link
is if he buys a ticket. And where is Phil Simms?
RE: The only way Delhomme gets in
gogiants
: 9/23/2021 8:03 am :
link
In comment
15379956
jmdvm said:
Quote:
is if he buys a ticket. And where is Phil Simms?
👍
RE: RE: ...
DannyDimes
: 9/23/2021 8:09 am :
link
In comment
15379765
FStubbs said:
Quote:
In comment 15379752 SFGFNCGiantsFan said:
Quote:
I must be still drunk from Saturday, but Jake Freaking Delhomme is on that list? WTF?
Not a fan of his, but Rodney Harrison was a HOFer to me. Woodson too.
If Rodney Harrison goes in, Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens should go in in baseball.
baseball and football have completely different criterion. Off field is considered in baseball and is NOT considered in football.
Two words: short career.
I would definitely say Watters, both Barbers, Seymour, Boselli, EWilliams...
Of the eight, I'd say Landetta is most deserving. Most fans dismiss him because of that fluke in Chicago in 1985, but he was a tremendous player for a long time and very dependable. His performance in the 1986 NFCCG alone atoned for that whiff.
I would definitely say Watters, both Barbers, Seymour, Boselli, EWilliams...
Swilling was an athletic freak and a great pass rusher who benefited from HOF Rickey Jackson on the other side. Sam Mills was a better overall player.
Not a fan of his, but Rodney Harrison was a HOFer to me. Woodson too.
Quote:
The hell is Boselli not in there yet?
Two words: short career.
Six seasons, 5x PB and 3x AP. His impact was huge and he was a big reason why the Jags were perennial contenders.
Not a fan of his, but Rodney Harrison was a HOFer to me. Woodson too.
If Rodney Harrison goes in, Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens should go in in baseball.
👍
Quote:
I must be still drunk from Saturday, but Jake Freaking Delhomme is on that list? WTF?
Not a fan of his, but Rodney Harrison was a HOFer to me. Woodson too.
If Rodney Harrison goes in, Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens should go in in baseball.
baseball and football have completely different criterion. Off field is considered in baseball and is NOT considered in football.