1. Hired a fossil for a GM who has no idea what he is doing
2. Hired a ST coach for HC after two HC failures of two years each
3. Saddled aforementioned HC with oft criticized but familiar Jason Garrett
4. Has family members inside the football operations and not only Chris Mara but the nephew who is supposedly the next great Mara (whatever that means). They own the team they could do whatever they want, but we are fans and we can criticize when they put family members who seem to be unqualified.
Just very demoralizing. Being bad in the league is cyclical, this cycle has lasted way, way too long. Everyone needs to go (I realize the owners aren’t going anywhere so everyone else needs to go)
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
Seriously. BB was a successful coordinator when he got the Browns job. He made the playoffs with the Browns and wasn’t a terrible coach. Joe Judge is 7-15
And keep Ernie Accorsi as far away from advising on replacements as possible.
Well then I definitely hope for your sake that JJ is the next BB.
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
Well, except for the fact that Belichick schemed a brilliant Super Bowl victory against one of the best offenses of all time before he became a head coach.
But that’s just a small resume point after all.
Quote:
Joe Judge is to Giants
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
Seriously. BB was a successful coordinator when he got the Browns job. He made the playoffs with the Browns and wasn’t a terrible coach. Joe Judge is 7-15
This is the stupidest comment I have seen today.
Belichick was
6-10
7-9
7-9
11-5
5-11
And building
I’d rather not go the retread route. I’d prefer a Joe Brady type hire.
Mike Zimmer is ten times the HC Judge is. I'd take Mike Zimmer in a heartbeat if you get the right QB for him
Quote:
In comment 15417703 Chocco said:
Quote:
Joe Judge is to Giants
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
Seriously. BB was a successful coordinator when he got the Browns job. He made the playoffs with the Browns and wasn’t a terrible coach. Joe Judge is 7-15
This is the stupidest comment I have seen today.
Belichick was
6-10
7-9
7-9
11-5
5-11
And building
My fault I should have clarified.
I think Judge could be a successful head coach one day. I just don't think it will be for the giants
LOL!
Seriously, she's a smoke show.
Worst part of a family business?
Being able to give high paying jobs to family members who have no credentials for such jobs.
Quote:
Joe Judge is to Giants
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
Well, except for the fact that Belichick schemed a brilliant Super Bowl victory against one of the best offenses of all time before he became a head coach.
But that’s just a small resume point after all.
LOL!
Mara's are incompetent and its not like the NFL didn't need to force George Young once upon a time. They have a history of incompetence.
If they want sustained success, they need to hire an outsider to run the football ops. The most successful business people & corporations not only hire the right people but also give them the freedom to flourish.
If picking the next QB needed to ok'd by John Mara, that tells you everything you need to know.
No one worthwhile will want to come here if they need John to sign off on roster moves. And i'm not saying that happens every time but i am saying it should never happen.
If they hire retread GM & HC i'll probably just check out on the team. The answer is in front of everyone's face.
That said, I don't see how they can move forward with him. The first order of business has to be fire Gettleman. I would do it now, just so everyone around the league is 100% aware we are in the market. I would NOT hire from within and I would NOT consult Accorsi. The new GM should have a few days to make a couple of key decisions. One is Judge and the other is Jones. The new GM should be the one to decide the direction of both, and to a lesser degree Barkley. Then, it's up to that person to either replace them or build a team with them. But, it is their team and their decision.
Quote:
They took a chance on him. Be careful stating things like that because that’s the shit that will get us Mike Zimmer or Doug Pederson in January.
Mike Zimmer is ten times the HC Judge is. I'd take Mike Zimmer in a heartbeat if you get the right QB for him
With Zimmer you are getting a defense oriented coach who is run first. he is a dinosaur. the game has past him by. Why would you want him? I have a buddy who is a big Vikings fan and he is praying they fire Zim.
Hire someone who has no fucking clue what they’re doing, because they’re cheap. I have zero doubt the Giants could’ve gotten some good coaches in here over the last 7 years. They never wanted to spend.
This is what you get. Look at yhis ridiculous college coaching staff Judge put together. Its like a bad joke. And they get bent over a barrel every week.
Quote:
Joe Judge is to Giants
As
Bill Belichick is to Browns
Well, except for the fact that Belichick schemed a brilliant Super Bowl victory against one of the best offenses of all time before he became a head coach.
But that’s just a small resume point after all.
Spags did too where did that get him?
Going by winning percentage, we are literally the worst team since 3017. There are no counterfactuals.
Quote:
In comment 15417747 Sean said:
Quote:
They took a chance on him. Be careful stating things like that because that’s the shit that will get us Mike Zimmer or Doug Pederson in January.
Mike Zimmer is ten times the HC Judge is. I'd take Mike Zimmer in a heartbeat if you get the right QB for him
With Zimmer you are getting a defense oriented coach who is run first. he is a dinosaur. the game has past him by. Why would you want him? I have a buddy who is a big Vikings fan and he is praying they fire Zim.
How good is Zimmer as a defensive coordinator?
Hire someone who has no fucking clue what they’re doing, because they’re cheap. I have zero doubt the Giants could’ve gotten some good coaches in here over the last 7 years. They never wanted to spend.
This is what you get. Look at yhis ridiculous college coaching staff Judge put together. Its like a bad joke. And they get bent over a barrel every week.
I don’t think they hired Judge because he was cheap, I think they hired him because he blew them away in the interview. Same way he won us over with his presser. I was really rooting for the guy because I did, like many Giants fans, believe in him at first. I hope he finds a way to turn it around but it seems less likely each passing week.
Every single one of those teams at least has a direction and a plan. The Giants right now are down with the Texans.