that SB is not 100 percent. Peterson's recovery from his ACL was an extreme outlier. The idea that SB was going to come out and be as explosive as he was before this year is just foolish. We probably won't know what he actually is post ACL until 2022
& we'd be insane-INSANE-to give Saquon a second contract. And Lord knows Gettleman would if given the chance.
No question about that.
But when we see an OP like this that swings the pendulum too far, it's counterproductive.
Barkley is extremely flawed. You can even make a case that Booker, with consistency, is the better option at RB. But when you go so far as to say that Booker is "statistically better than Barkley in every area" when that's untrue on its face, it begs the question of whether the OP is here for discussion or here to troll. I suspect it might be the latter.
Has it occurred to you when is the last time Barkley been 100%? Or when will he be 100% in the future? The answer to the latter may be never with his track record. What good is a player that can’t stay healthy? Look at OBJ his injuries impacted his ability to perform even today.
Possibly having David Carritis Variant.
Just starts dancing , expecting the hole not to be there, looking for a possible alternate open are, and there general is none.
that SB is not 100 percent. Peterson's recovery from his ACL was an extreme outlier. The idea that SB was going to come out and be as explosive as he was before this year is just foolish. We probably won't know what he actually is post ACL until 2022
He got hurt in like Week 2 last year. It's been well over a year. We are also well within the window in which people recover from ACLs these days.
I mean if you had only added “almost” it would retain a modicum of credibility
Curious… did You(OP) create that awesome graphic or did you find it?
You should delete and repost with almost in the header. So the whole afternoons work isn’t wasted.
A lot of the numbers are close to each other. For instance ypc. 3.6 to 3.7. Both deplorably paltry, I might add. I would make those numbers smaller so they are almost illegible. People might wonder why both backs are so bad (gettlemen picked them both. Amiright!!)
Looking forward to more insights
that SB is not 100 percent. Peterson's recovery from his ACL was an extreme outlier. The idea that SB was going to come out and be as explosive as he was before this year is just foolish. We probably won't know what he actually is post ACL until 2022
He got hurt in like Week 2 last year. It's been well over a year. We are also well within the window in which people recover from ACLs these days.
Not really. It takes the 2nd year to get back completely
Bet it is not Booker.
Booker is doing a nice job at RB, yes.
People on here go to great lengths to defend the guy, but he's not far from being a bust.
No question about that.
But when we see an OP like this that swings the pendulum too far, it's counterproductive.
Barkley is extremely flawed. You can even make a case that Booker, with consistency, is the better option at RB. But when you go so far as to say that Booker is "statistically better than Barkley in every area" when that's untrue on its face, it begs the question of whether the OP is here for discussion or here to troll. I suspect it might be the latter.
Gettleman or the mealy mouth owner?
Just starts dancing , expecting the hole not to be there, looking for a possible alternate open are, and there general is none.
Next year If the Giants pull their head out of their ass and remake the line … what then?
Cool thread though.
And that would be cool...
Curious… did You(OP) create that awesome graphic or did you find it?
You should delete and repost with almost in the header. So the whole afternoons work isn’t wasted.
A lot of the numbers are close to each other. For instance ypc. 3.6 to 3.7. Both deplorably paltry, I might add. I would make those numbers smaller so they are almost illegible. People might wonder why both backs are so bad (gettlemen picked them both. Amiright!!)
Looking forward to more insights
Quote:
that SB is not 100 percent. Peterson's recovery from his ACL was an extreme outlier. The idea that SB was going to come out and be as explosive as he was before this year is just foolish. We probably won't know what he actually is post ACL until 2022
He got hurt in like Week 2 last year. It's been well over a year. We are also well within the window in which people recover from ACLs these days.
Not really. It takes the 2nd year to get back completely
Injury prone. Availability is important.
Great dancer behind the line before losing 2 yards.
Has "one" great run per game.
Can't block.
Please trade him!
Cool thread though.
Booker can't help win games if he is on the bench.
If one thing has become clear this season, it's that there is a highlight-reel BBI contingent, for better or worse.
It tracks with those posters' aversion to aggregated data.
Sad