This thread is solely for everyone who is disgusted at the embarrassment the NY Giants have become under the leadership of John Mara. John’s latest disgrace is deciding to keep Coach Joe Judge before hiring a new GM.
Mara, this thread is to give all Giants faithful a chance to vent about how horrific a job you are doing.
They are even worse than bad - they are boring.
Mara needs to step aside and let a football guy run the football ops... top to bottom.
The on-field disaster is one thing. The management disaster is completely avoidable.
So you've got that going for you.
Not a huge baseball fan like I was when I was a kid
But born in Astoria, my beloved Ukrainian grandmother loved them
Starting in 1969, would watch with her as she drank her piels beer and smoked benson and hedges.
So they are ingrained in me.
That being said, unless giants are competent ( not even good, just not eliminated in October) it’s a waste of my energy living and dying with them
I used to live for sundays. Now I usually turn the crap off, tape it or whatever
I love offseason more than regular season, that says it all
I was right then and I’m still right. One of the worst owners in the NFL.
His "process" and culture-building isn't working.
I honestly think at this point that Mara does not care how the fans feel about anything. He'd rather run the franchise into the ground as long as he's still the one in charge.
But there aren't many other reasonable explanations one can come up with for the complete and utter disconnect with his fanbase and reality.
I was right then and I’m still right. One of the worst owners in the NFL.
Disagree. Doing what the mob wants is the easy way. Going with your gut against all the noise takes balls.
This is the bottom. Can't you see John? We are the Matt Millen-era Lions. We are the current version of the 2010's Cleveland Browns. Remember that Browns team that won a single game in 2 seasons? 1-31 was their record in 2016 & 2017 under Hue Jackson. And that team would beat us today. The record book may say we're a 4-13 team, but everyone knows we are worse than that.
You have been trusting people whose heyday in football was 20 and 30 years ago. Time to start getting people in the building that knows how to build a team that can win in TODAY's NFL.
Abrams will be the GM.
Because Mara seems to care more about being right and his own ego,than anything that happens out on the field.
Their heads are spinning so advice from within the NFL circles can only be good, no?
We can blame Joe Judge, and we should for 2021 but the blame goes deeper than the Head Coach. You chose to replace Jerry Reese with an old school GM with ties to Giants past but with a very spotty record as GM. For all the talk, all the bluster, Dave Gettleman's time here will be viewed as one mistake after another. From the condescending tone towards media (specifically female members) to the we hired an "Adult" for HC- ie a shot a McAdoo and then followed up by the idiotic worship of a RB in the 2018 draft that absolutely handicapped this franchise moving forward from then.
You then replaced the Adult with a guy you thought was a BB clone, a guy who had escaped the Giants years ago and you felt you could grab the next young BB. Instead we get all the arrogance and bravado of BB with NONE of the demonstrated success.
John, to hold a coach who basically has told the fanbase that they don't know what success is, they don't know what to use as a measuring stick for success because they are tied to much to the won loss record. This team is now considered a laughing stock in the NFL. Do not kid yourselves, our 4 win record is a mirage, we easily could have been 2-15. We have a QB who clearly isn't the guy and yet you are still trying to "see" what you have in him and are now keeping a coach who called two QB sneaks off our own 3 yard line.. Is that a leader of men or a coward who wants to use injuries and Oline play as an excuse for this type of garbage. David Culley in Houston was given a job that not many wanted and that was most definitely being done with at least one hand tied behind his back and yet that lowly Houston was a far better product than our beloved NY Giants.
Do not be stubborn and stick to your "patience" stance and realize that now, while getting a new GM (outside of the Organization, not ABRAMS who has been part of years of losing already) and get a new coach that the GM wants..
This is your George Young moment. No half assed toss a chair, losing won't be tolerated moments, make a true statement that you WANT to win and you know that you and your choices have led us to where we are now. It is time to change and you need to see it, feel it and do something with it.
The Giants are a chaotic failure due to weak leadership. Today's decision to continue to employ Joe Judge will do nothing more than continue this cycle of nothingness.
We are about to try as hard we possibly can.
Of all the things to be pissed off about, you are pissed that DG isn’t getting publicly shamed on his way out? I hope you are never in a managerial position.
Please don't tell us you are upset by losing. You clearly aren't. If I was making tens of millions off the Giants I would probably not be as upset as I am now. But the Giants are an escape for many, and right now that escape is a depressing bore.
It's your franchise and you can run it however you like. But don't be surprised when the next generation of football fan in the New York area are increasingly choosing to root for the Cowboys.
Sincerely,
Winoguy
I may be done with this team if they promote abrams and keep judge.
this team needs a fresh GM and coach with a fresh mindset
Judge: Yup!
Mara: Are you on board with signing Barkley to a 2nd
contract?
Judge: Yup!
Mara: Are you on board with exercising Jones's 5th year option?
Judge: Yup!
Mara: Great, keep up the good work!
Fans have hit their breaking point and Judge has proven to be utterly incompetent.
There will not be another time where we can gut it completely like we can now. Now is the time to finally do what should have been done in the past.
You can blame bad injury luck for a season here or there, but a decade? It’s one thing to believe in The Giants Way if there is one. But, it has to adapt to the current times. Even the great George Young was too slow to adapt to free agency. You’ve been to slow bringing the team into modern offensive football. You must be frustrated paying and overpaying unproductive players and coaches. Think hard about this next GM pick. It’s going to make or break you with a lot of fans. Not current ones, future fans.
Good Luck.
Daniel
I'll keep it simple. IF Judge is back i am not spending a cent on this team nor wasting my time watching games next season watching this shitty product
I'm the president of a medium sized medical practice, and most docs are that way, which is why most of my partners would be terrible as president of the group, which is why I'm stuck doing it. :-(