“ Still more meetings expected between Joe Judge + ownership later today or tomorrow. Everything remains in limbo. Outside GM candidates are under impression the coach is not set in stone. So seems as if ownership will listen before deciding ultimate direction of organization.”
Judge - (
New Window )
I guess we are just going to ignore virtually every report that says the Giants will let the GM decide Judge's fate.
Worst comes to worst, they get answers in depth on whether there's a future with him and some generality for themselves on what's gone on this season that they can't have repeated with another candidate.
It sounds like it's at least a possibility that they could be telling GM candidates that they (the candidates) will have the final say on Judge.
In the meantime they can have Judge earn his salary by deep cleaning the MetLife urinals.
Well no shit sherlock.
Well no shit sherlock.
I don't think thats quite right. It sounds like the GM chosen will have a big say and they will probably weigh in all the feedback they receive.
One can hope anyway.
A possibility
A possibility
Very plausible. And you can only imagine the 200+ page PowerPoint presentation The Fillibuster has to show off his football acumen. Littered with supporting quotes from BB, Saban, McDaniel, etc.
I am in favor of such an approach, but it does have a downside. I want the new GM to be heavily involved. However, by the time a new GM is identified, other teams will have been doing their HC search for a week, or two. It may lend weight to keeping Judge if the preferred alternatives have gone elsewhere. The only way around this is to fire Judge now and let the Maras search for a replacement. While most all of us want Judge out, most all of us don't want the second part.
I am in favor of such an approach, but it does have a downside. I want the new GM to be heavily involved. However, by the time a new GM is identified, other teams will have been doing their HC search for a week, or two. It may lend weight to keeping Judge if the preferred alternatives have gone elsewhere. The only way around this is to fire Judge now and let the Maras search for a replacement. While most all of us want Judge out, most all of us don't want the second part.
Or this. *grin*
The paperwork is still being held up at the league office.
I am in favor of such an approach, but it does have a downside. I want the new GM to be heavily involved. However, by the time a new GM is identified, other teams will have been doing their HC search for a week, or two. It may lend weight to keeping Judge if the preferred alternatives have gone elsewhere. The only way around this is to fire Judge now and let the Maras search for a replacement. While most all of us want Judge out, most all of us don't want the second part.
I've been on this track too. The problem with this though is that it's not clean, you're introducing variables that make it difficult for a GM to get his best HC option in there Year 1. There's the element of telling your future employer what they want to hear during interviews and your future employer handing you a free year removed from the crosshairs. What could be in the GMs best interest isn't necessarily going to align with what's best for the Giants. Firing Judge yesterday and letting the GM pick his guy from the available pool of candidates would have been better. However, I'll take this over Mara playing matchmaker any idea, so it could be worse.
As someone who paid his dues in Corporate America, anytime a new CEO came aboard, 3 times in my career, they didn't give a fuck, it was there way or the highway.
Believe me everyone snapped to attention
If you were the bosses and you had an employee who was as bad at his job as Joe Judge is would you keep him on? A coach who can't manage any game situation and a coach that gives up with QB sneaks from his own 4 yardline. A coach who tries to talk tough out of every situation. He is an abject failure he is in way way way over his head. He only loses games for us. Yet they keep this bozo on and have these meaningless ridiculous meetings. Its all so pathetic. Why would you need a meeting. The guy has been in your building every day for 2 years. You've seen every play of every game and you still think you need meetings?
Its all so the wealthy and supposedly powerful can still feel that way. Joe Judge is good at covering for the mistakes of his bosses, that to them is loyalty and all they care about. I guaranty we fuck this up, as well as the draft.
As someone who paid his dues in Corporate America, anytime a new CEO came aboard, 3 times in my career, they didn't give a fuck, it was there way or the highway.
Believe me everyone snapped to attention
Except the new GM isn't the CEO- thats John Mara. He needs to sack up and fire this coach and give his new GM a clean deck.
It will not be difficult once the process is over to know which way that was presented. Just like it wasn't difficult to know why Gettleman and Shumur were hired 2018.
Quote:
and will have no problem passing on him if he wants to go in a different direction.
As someone who paid his dues in Corporate America, anytime a new CEO came aboard, 3 times in my career, they didn't give a fuck, it was there way or the highway.
Believe me everyone snapped to attention
Except the new GM isn't the CEO- thats John Mara. He needs to sack up and fire this coach and give his new GM a clean deck.
But as the Giants "CEO" he can give the keys over to the new GM to make all football decisions and not intervene