The good news is the Giants are still getting bombarded by execs & their reps trying to get added to the GM interview list of 9. It's already a strong list...And word is Joe Schoen, among the presumptive favorites, certainly didn't hurt himself yesterday.
Depends how the candidate views Fields. If they see an elite QB then it's no contest, the Bears job is better than both.
I really believe that Mara thought that things weren't that bad and he had Gettleman sitting in his pocket as a guy that could quickly right the ship using the "Giant's Way" This was by far the worst decision he has ever made!
Quote:
are probably more coveted than the Bears for sure.
Depends how the candidate views Fields. If they see an elite QB then it's no contest, the Bears job is better than both.
Elite?
Hahahahahahahaha. Riiiiiight.
This is an interesting thread from the archives of what BBI was thinking at that time back in Dec 2017. Some were seeing right thru the GM search nonsense...and many were not
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=562090&show_all=1
Quote:
In comment 15551391 Sammo85 said:
Quote:
are probably more coveted than the Bears for sure.
Depends how the candidate views Fields. If they see an elite QB then it's no contest, the Bears job is better than both.
Elite?
Hahahahahahahaha. Riiiiiight.
You may have closed the book on Fields but many have not. He had some decent moments in what was an up and down rookie season.
The bears are blowing out the coaching staff and front office. The whole situation was in upheaval and Nagy was a buffoon.
Quote:
only makes their limited search 4 years ago look even worse. What were they thinking?
This is an interesting thread from the archives of what BBI was thinking at that time back in Dec 2017. Some were seeing right thru the GM search nonsense...and many were not
https://corner.bigblueinteractive.com/index.php?mode=2&thread=562090&show_all=1
too good not to share
is it because we can't handle the truth?
too good not to share
ron that was great...
Quote:
In comment 15551416 Producer said:
Quote:
In comment 15551391 Sammo85 said:
Quote:
are probably more coveted than the Bears for sure.
Depends how the candidate views Fields. If they see an elite QB then it's no contest, the Bears job is better than both.
Elite?
Hahahahahahahaha. Riiiiiight.
You may have closed the book on Fields but many have not. He had some decent moments in what was an up and down rookie season.
There is an enormous gap between “elite” and closing the book on him.
Until proven otherwise, Fields isn’t in the stratosphere of being considered elite.
The bears are blowing out the coaching staff and front office. The whole situation was in upheaval and Nagy was a buffoon.
Completely agree, I've seen Fields make some throws this year that made me take a 2nd look. WAY too early to close the book on him.
I just think that a GM candidate might rather have his own choice at QB. A new GM in Chicago is going to have to give Fields next year at least, where here he can start fresh. I think that is appealing to most candidates.
Quote:
In comment 15551422 BigBlueShock said:
Quote:
In comment 15551416 Producer said:
Quote:
In comment 15551391 Sammo85 said:
Quote:
are probably more coveted than the Bears for sure.
Depends how the candidate views Fields. If they see an elite QB then it's no contest, the Bears job is better than both.
Elite?
Hahahahahahahaha. Riiiiiight.
You may have closed the book on Fields but many have not. He had some decent moments in what was an up and down rookie season.
There is an enormous gap between “elite” and closing the book on him.
Until proven otherwise, Fields isn’t in the stratosphere of being considered elite.
You're just being argumentative. Fields obviously still has a high ceiling. it's why Chicago traded an extra first to get him. I don't really get your point.
He was drafted a franchise QB. Many still feel he has that upside. If a candidate sees that in him - then for that candidate Chicago is the better situation.
Quote:
In comment 15551416 Producer said:
Quote:
In comment 15551391 Sammo85 said:
Quote:
are probably more coveted than the Bears for sure.
Depends how the candidate views Fields. If they see an elite QB then it's no contest, the Bears job is better than both.
Elite?
Hahahahahahahaha. Riiiiiight.
You may have closed the book on Fields but many have not. He had some decent moments in what was an up and down rookie season.
You just described Daniel Jone's rookie year
I know there are those who believe this team is mostly void of talent. But IMHO, this team in spite of its performance and record in 2021,has a number of good pieces in place (particularly at the skilled positions) to the point if they draft properly (in key positions) they could show significant improvement next year.
As a GM looking to make a name for their-self, its not as bad a situation as some might believe. I would rather inherit this team than the one DG inherited.