would be really exciting too...have heard great things about Ryans and he stifled a cowboys offense which was impressive with a lot of the game without Nick Bosa too.
If Adam Peters gets the Giants GM job, 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans will surely be on his coach list. One scout told me in 30-plus years of visiting campuses, he never heard more people rave about a prospect's leadership, intelligence & character than he heard about Alabama's Ryans.
Horitz and Schoen were my favorite two options but the more I learn about Peters the more I like. If I had to choose between the options today I would probably go with Peters.
would be really exciting too...have heard great things about Ryans and he stifled a cowboys offense which was impressive with a lot of the game without Nick Bosa too.
Also lost Fred Warner later in the game for a good number of snaps.
would be really exciting too...have heard great things about Ryans and he stifled a cowboys offense which was impressive with a lot of the game without Nick Bosa too.
Also lost Fred Warner later in the game for a good number of snaps.
indeed....with not many known corners he really had an amazing plan against Lamb and Cooper and frustrated Dak all game.
Then explain why he is getting on the plane to come interview? Does he just want to see what NJ looks like in January? If he is offered the position of course he is coming east.
Has a connection with Josh McDaniels during his time with the Patriots. This is of course in addition to the obvious connection with the current 49ers OC Mike McDaniel.
That Peters is just using us for negotiating leverage with the 49ers to get the job he really wants: 49ers GM. My concern is we offer to Peters, who wasn't really serious, and Schoen takes the Bears job bc he feels jilted.
But every single candidate comes with red flags or is a complete unknown. I'm open to him but really have now idea how flaky he actually is. If him and Peters are close professionally, they came up around the same time in NE, then that should alleviate some of those concerns.
RE: DeMeco Ryans would be a very interesting candidate
These guys are vying for top jobs in their very limited industry. I don’t think physical location matters all that much. And I know plenty of people in the NY metro area that are from the west coast. If he doesn’t get the job or want to come here, being from CA likely has nothing to do with it.
There was a time I would relocate for a job, and now I'm much less inclined to do so. Some want warm weather, some want to be close to home, and some have the cv to give them the ability to choose based on their personal wants.
Once again, no one's turning down a chance to be an NFL GM
He is California-proof because of the money he makes. I lived in LA for 11 years and left 9 years ago. People are leaving because they cant afford to buy a house, cant afford the high taxes/gas prices, and the covid protocols/ political climate
But with the money Peters makes, he doesnt have to leave
This is true for some people (especially Socal). Northern California is a completely different story. Due to the nature of my job, I work with a lot of people (many of which are very wealthy) who lived in the bay area and have left in the past two years for non financial reasons.
Thats why I said he doesnt HAVE to leave, like so many do. Also why I listed the other reasons people are leaving, including covid protocols/political climate (which could be the reasons the people you know are leaving)
I feel he is the reason Lynch is sucsessful in San Fran. He was the first hire Lynch made.
I don't have a super-strong preference because none of us have a clue exactly what these guys have done or what soft skills they possess but he would be my slight lean for that reason. Lynch had zero front office experience but was able to surround himself with a lot of bright minds in both the front office and coaching. That's a skill. Not the worst idea to lean on his judgement there with Peters being his first hire.
who would be best of the group, but based on what I've read I wouldn't be upset with any of these three finalists. With preference towards Peters and Schoen and the coaches they could potentially poach from their current organizations.
I'm getting the sense that Hortiz may have withdrawn. Hard to believe he's fourth in the current rankings, and he's the only one with no gameday conflicts to work around.
RE: Interesting how far off the Giants reservation Peters is
If Adam Peters gets the Giants GM job, 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans will surely be on his coach list. One scout told me in 30-plus years of visiting campuses, he never heard more people rave about a prospect's leadership, intelligence & character than he heard about Alabama's Ryans.
The guy who failed to have his defense protect the boundaries on the final drive against Dallas and let them walk down the field unchecked until Dak and company stopped themselves?
If Adam Peters gets the Giants GM job, 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans will surely be on his coach list. One scout told me in 30-plus years of visiting campuses, he never heard more people rave about a prospect's leadership, intelligence & character than he heard about Alabama's Ryans.
The guy who failed to have his defense protect the boundaries on the final drive against Dallas and let them walk down the field unchecked until Dak and company stopped themselves?
Color me less than impressed.
No Bosa and Warner. Also he had a top 10 defense in points, top 3 defense in yards allowed and top 10 in dvoa. It's legit. Dallas scored 17 points with all those injuries on defense for SF.
If Adam Peters gets the Giants GM job, 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans will surely be on his coach list. One scout told me in 30-plus years of visiting campuses, he never heard more people rave about a prospect's leadership, intelligence & character than he heard about Alabama's Ryans.
The guy who failed to have his defense protect the boundaries on the final drive against Dallas and let them walk down the field unchecked until Dak and company stopped themselves?
Color me less than impressed.
No Bosa and Warner. Also he had a top 10 defense in points, top 3 defense in yards allowed and top 10 in dvoa. It's legit. Dallas scored 17 points with all those injuries on defense for SF.
The Packers beat the 49ers this year in part because Ryans allowed a big throw by Rodgers to Adams to quickly get into FG range.
One could say that it takes a Rodgers to make that kind of throw (more or less true, only a few QBs could've done it), but seems like it could've been stopped.
Frustrating stuff, but correctable. Can't teach the rest.
Peters + Ryan
would be really exciting too...have heard great things about Ryans and he stifled a cowboys offense which was impressive with a lot of the game without Nick Bosa too.
Quote:
would be very exciting
Peters + Ryan
would be really exciting too...have heard great things about Ryans and he stifled a cowboys offense which was impressive with a lot of the game without Nick Bosa too.
Also lost Fred Warner later in the game for a good number of snaps.
Quote:
In comment 15560852 Ben in Tampa said:
Quote:
would be very exciting
Peters + Ryan
would be really exciting too...have heard great things about Ryans and he stifled a cowboys offense which was impressive with a lot of the game without Nick Bosa too.
Also lost Fred Warner later in the game for a good number of snaps.
indeed....with not many known corners he really had an amazing plan against Lamb and Cooper and frustrated Dak all game.
Is a Californian.
May not want to come East.
Then explain why he is getting on the plane to come interview? Does he just want to see what NJ looks like in January? If he is offered the position of course he is coming east.
Peters+Ryans would be so refreshing. Idk if it would work, but would feel modern for once.
Is a Californian.
May not want to come East.
These guys are vying for top jobs in their very limited industry. I don’t think physical location matters all that much. And I know plenty of people in the NY metro area that are from the west coast. If he doesn’t get the job or want to come here, being from CA likely has nothing to do with it.
Do you mean Josh McDaniels or the current 49ers OC, Mike McDaniel?
Quote:
He is California-proof because of the money he makes. I lived in LA for 11 years and left 9 years ago. People are leaving because they cant afford to buy a house, cant afford the high taxes/gas prices, and the covid protocols/ political climate
But with the money Peters makes, he doesnt have to leave
This is true for some people (especially Socal). Northern California is a completely different story. Due to the nature of my job, I work with a lot of people (many of which are very wealthy) who lived in the bay area and have left in the past two years for non financial reasons.
Thats why I said he doesnt HAVE to leave, like so many do. Also why I listed the other reasons people are leaving, including covid protocols/political climate (which could be the reasons the people you know are leaving)
I don't have a super-strong preference because none of us have a clue exactly what these guys have done or what soft skills they possess but he would be my slight lean for that reason. Lynch had zero front office experience but was able to surround himself with a lot of bright minds in both the front office and coaching. That's a skill. Not the worst idea to lean on his judgement there with Peters being his first hire.
Ryan Poles is doing an in person today.
Yeah I wasn't fully believing Peters wouldn't leave but since he is getting to a 2nd interview it opens up so many possibilities I wasn't considering.
Ryans jumps to the top of the list for me.
Agreed. Damn this is exciting. And at the same time... terrifying... lol
Quote:
would be very exciting
Do you mean Josh McDaniels or the current 49ers OC, Mike McDaniel?
Mike McDaneils, want no part of Josh
I'd love to get a defensive HC, although it probably makes sense to get a former OC. Ryans sounds great.
I’m very encouraged by how the search is being conducted.
I'm getting the sense that Hortiz may have withdrawn. Hard to believe he's fourth in the current rankings, and he's the only one with no gameday conflicts to work around.
I’m very encouraged by how the search is being conducted.
That's a big draw for me, too.
Time for Mara to get out of his comfort zone.
But big major question mark is who he fills as his OC.
The guy who failed to have his defense protect the boundaries on the final drive against Dallas and let them walk down the field unchecked until Dak and company stopped themselves?
Color me less than impressed.
I like Poles/Pederson combo the most still.
Quote:
If Adam Peters gets the Giants GM job, 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans will surely be on his coach list. One scout told me in 30-plus years of visiting campuses, he never heard more people rave about a prospect's leadership, intelligence & character than he heard about Alabama's Ryans.
The guy who failed to have his defense protect the boundaries on the final drive against Dallas and let them walk down the field unchecked until Dak and company stopped themselves?
Color me less than impressed.
No Bosa and Warner. Also he had a top 10 defense in points, top 3 defense in yards allowed and top 10 in dvoa. It's legit. Dallas scored 17 points with all those injuries on defense for SF.
this counters peppers thoughts in another thread re pederson I think, but perhaps just his opinions rather than inside info.
you hearing anything juicy about the gm/hc search overall jonc?
Quote:
In comment 15560876 arniefez said:
Quote:
If Adam Peters gets the Giants GM job, 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans will surely be on his coach list. One scout told me in 30-plus years of visiting campuses, he never heard more people rave about a prospect's leadership, intelligence & character than he heard about Alabama's Ryans.
The guy who failed to have his defense protect the boundaries on the final drive against Dallas and let them walk down the field unchecked until Dak and company stopped themselves?
Color me less than impressed.
No Bosa and Warner. Also he had a top 10 defense in points, top 3 defense in yards allowed and top 10 in dvoa. It's legit. Dallas scored 17 points with all those injuries on defense for SF.
The Packers beat the 49ers this year in part because Ryans allowed a big throw by Rodgers to Adams to quickly get into FG range.
One could say that it takes a Rodgers to make that kind of throw (more or less true, only a few QBs could've done it), but seems like it could've been stopped.
Frustrating stuff, but correctable. Can't teach the rest.