Can Peart be a good starting guard?

Yes

Nasty for one.

In comment 15560822 Jim in Forest Hills said:

Quote:

Yes

I laughed. 👍🏿👍

He might be a little tall for a guard IMO.

Swing tackle is his best position next year.

he will be a swing tackle and i still believe he will be a good one.

Bad year last year, still young and developing, had COVID, etc. jst a lot working against him. I think this year, pressure is off, he isnt expected to start or contribute more than just a depth piece. id be shocked if one of 5 or 7 wasnt an OT so peart will be the swing tackle.

I don't see how that translates well to any position on our starting line.

The Giants plan for next year cannot rely on this player.

If he shows up, can play, and makes the team, great.

But the team's plan must not depend on him playing.

There should be zero reliance on this guy for several reasons now

Peart needs to want to play. The coaches dont trust him right now. For him to not beat out Solder is very telling. Unless he changes his mindset he may not be in the league very long.

Peart's problems seemed to be that he was lazy and not motivated. If that's the case, he won't make a good starting anything.

But I honestly don't think he has the mentality to play OL (last two OL coaches couldn't get him to beat out Soldier, who's awful, or get him to play mean). Nobody should be surprised if he's cut, outright by a new regime. Buf if not, sure, try him at OG. WTF? What's the worst that could happen? Even Flowers found a home at OG. Doesn't work, you can still cut him.


Security Guard -- WELL PLAYED! Perfect!

Peart tore his ACL in late December. We likely won't see him - if at all - until 2023.

That is the book on Peart IMO

due to the torn ACL. There is a chance he misses the entire year so the Giants will proceed as if he isn't on the roster.

Peart has been disappointing especially after a promising start to his rookie season. I haven't completely given up on him developing into a dependable player but the Giants need to bring in a starting RT and OT depth.

I actually hope that the Giants draft three offensive linemen preferably an OT, a G, and a G/C. As of now the only locks to be on the roster next season are Andrew Thomas, Shane Lemieux, and Ben Bredeson. Thomas is the only one who is a proven starter while Bredeson will likely serve as depth at guard and center. Shane Lemieux will compete for one starting guard spot and hopefully he earns it because that would be a nice boost for the entire line if the left side is set.

is about as big of a red flag as you can have, even if only his second season.

Being an Offensive Lineman evaluated and drafted by the NY Giants is a second huge red flag...

He's someone to keep an eye on with a full off season program and new coaching staff does he improve to serviceable?

A shame if he doesn’t have the internal drive to succeed. However, maybe losing his spot and competing for another position and his next contract could light the fire. I’m asking the question because I’m just really tired of draft picks not panning out in any shape or form. It’s a trend that has really gotten stale.
I was hoping that maybe he and Hernandez could rotate/compete for the same position and maybe, just maybe that internal competition would produce someone who can positively contribute through an entire season.

In comment 15560862 Jimmy Googs said:

Quote:

is about as big of a red flag as you can have, even if only his second season. Being an Offensive Lineman evaluated and drafted by the NY Giants is a second huge red flag...

This.

In comment 15560854 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

Peart tore his ACL in late December. We likely won't see him - if at all - until 2023.

I didnt know he tore his ACL. There is a good chance he never plays in the NFL again.

Tough to change a man's inner workings unless he does it himself. He's probably too tall for OG, and if doesn't want it enough at OT, he probably won't want to mix it up inside either.

My vote is for swing tackle. Not to mention, as Eric said, the knee means we can't count on him in 2022 (Gates either).

Stop trying to make this guy an NFL player. U Conn. should have been a big negative

Swing tackle at best..
.imo

He does not have quick reaction time so pulling or picking up stunts is out, plus his footwork and leverage are poor.

And he will be rehabbing his knee most of 2022.

.

In comment 15560847 David B. said:

Quote:

But I honestly don't think he has the mentality to play OL (last two OL coaches couldn't get him to beat out Soldier, who's awful, or get him to play mean). Nobody should be surprised if he's cut, outright by a new regime. Buf if not, sure, try him at OG. WTF? What's the worst that could happen? Even Flowers found a home at OG. Doesn't work, you can still cut him. Security Guard -- WELL PLAYED! Perfect!

Flowers was terrible but he did have the mentality, which is why he's okay at guard.

You can count on to be back.

Lemieux wasn't all that good and he tore his patella
Gates had a crazy serious injury and 5 or 6 surgeries
Peart tore his ACL in Dec and sucked anyway
Price is a FA and sucked
The rest are jags anyway...

There needs to be more than 1 OL drafted and more than 1 FA signing to be made.

In comment 15560854 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

Peart tore his ACL in late December. We likely won't see him - if at all - until 2023.

If he is not cut before then.

Peart is hurt.
He's just one more
Gettleman burp.

It's not that he isn't cutting it at ORT because he can't do the job physically, it's that he hasn't shown the mental make-up to be tough and grind things out. Until he figures that part out, I don't think moving positions is going to fix anything.

As others have said, not being able to push Solder out of the starting role (or even significant playing time) is a huge red flag.

Now we have a reportedly undermotivated player dealing with an ACL injury.

Security guard seems to be his next job.

On Peart being here next year.

In comment 15560829 Big Blue '56 said:

Quote:

In comment 15560822 Jim in Forest Hills said: Quote: Yes I laughed. 👍🏿👍

So did I.

To guard anything important

In comment 15560979 M.S. said:

Quote:

Peart is hurt. He's just one more Gettleman burp.

You have the excess gas coming out of the wrong end of him.

In comment 15560854 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

Peart tore his ACL in late December. We likely won't see him - if at all - until 2023.

Exactly. He's not a factor on the roster in '22. And he's not a guard.

Yes, I would give a chance at OG.

In comment 15561050 Section331 said:

Quote:

It's not that he isn't cutting it at ORT because he can't do the job physically, it's that he hasn't shown the mental make-up to be tough and grind things out. Until he figures that part out, I don't think moving positions is going to fix anything.

This'll happen on his 2nd team. Adulthood will hit him, and he'll find the drive to make a journeyman's career in the NFL. With NY getting just the shit beginning of his career.