BBI, if you could have any head coach who would it be?

..

.

As the GM too. Hell he can be the DC all at the same time if wants.

Then there is Tomlin, Payton, and I also really like McVay.

What are you driving at?

.

Even if his kids are scum

In comment 15570155 Chris684 said:

Quote:

..

+1

…

In comment 15570176 USAF NYG Fan said:

Quote:

As the GM too. Hell he can be the DC all at the same time if wants. Then there is Tomlin, Payton, and I also really like McVay. What are you driving at?

Curious to see who bbi sees as the ideal leader.

McVay is a close second.

-

With McVay being my 2nd choice.

That team is very well run. I love that they bring in talent too.

While I want to say Belicheck, I am not sure he can even recreate what he did in New England—not just because of Brady but the whole infrastructure.

I like how Tomlin’s teams compete.

How many losing seasons has he had? Even with injuries, he keeps them in the playoff hunt.

It might be too difficult to turn down a Rams style offense. My god it would be fun after the last few years.

It’s not close for me given his age. He’s been doing this without a QB. Jimmy G is just a guy.

.

In comment 15570203 The_Boss said:

Quote:

-

That was 60 years ago. Can you imagine a coach from that era in today's game? He'd have 8 fullbacks on the roster.

In comment 15570203 The_Boss said:

Quote:

-

Compared to the recent stiffs they’ve had, I’d even take 2021 Lombardi.

...

In comment 15570176 USAF NYG Fan said:

Quote:

As the GM too. Hell he can be the DC all at the same time if wants. Then there is Tomlin, Payton, and I also really like McVay. What are you driving at?

You realize Belichick is 17-17 last 2 years?

Imagine his record coaching the Giant roster.

In comment 15570245 j_rud said:

Quote:

In comment 15570203 The_Boss said: Quote: - That was 60 years ago. Can you imagine a coach from that era in today's game? He'd have 8 fullbacks on the roster.

Could go both ways and play inside LB’s

Matt Lafleur or Mike Tomlinson

.

Go You N. U.

I’m sure he had seen enough football in his life to figure out the details. As far as a teacher/leader of men? Nobody else close.

The 1998 Louisiana state mud dogs were the greatest team I ever saw.

In comment 15570295 Stan in LA said:

Quote:

In comment 15570176 USAF NYG Fan said: Quote: As the GM too. Hell he can be the DC all at the same time if wants. Then there is Tomlin, Payton, and I also really like McVay. What are you driving at? You realize Belichick is 17-17 last 2 years? Imagine his record coaching the Giant roster.

Seriously?

First it's 17-16 in the last two years. Last year was his first losing season since his 1st year as HC of the Patriots
That's 1 losing season in 20 years. His record is 244-92 as the Patriots HC. He had to bring in Cam Newton as his QB last year after losing Brady. This year he made the playoffs with a rookie QB. The man has 8 rings and is EASILY the goat.

Oh and he loves the Giants organization.

Again, Seriously?

Love how he builds a really deep staff with innovative minds again and again. Good offensive mind who knows what he needs on defense too.

Mike Vrabel. I really like what he has done with that team. He seems to get the most out of his teams. They should have won had his OC not called a play where his QB was in the gun on 3rd and less than 1.

In comment 15570394 robbieballs2003 said:

Quote:

Mike Vrabel. I really like what he has done with that team. He seems to get the most out of his teams. They should have won had his OC not called a play where his QB was in the gun on 3rd and less than 1.

Good call. What he is able to do without an elite QB deserves serious consideration.

Kyle Shanahan

Kyle Shanahan and it’s not even close. His game plans are incredible, he tailors his schemes around his players, and squeezes out the most from the level of talent he’s given. Hes the best coach in the NFL right now (aside from maybe Belichick) and he’s only 42.

Here too

Little Bill

Belichick.

In comment 15570389 Sammo85 said:

Quote:

Love how he builds a really deep staff with innovative minds again and again. Good offensive mind who knows what he needs on defense too.

+1

In comment 15570240 AcesUp said:

Quote:

It’s not close for me given his age. He’s been doing this without a QB. Jimmy G is just a guy.

+1

In comment 15570250 Jim in Fairfax said:

Quote:

In comment 15570203 The_Boss said: Quote: - Compared to the recent stiffs they’ve had, I’d even take 2021 Lombardi.

Haha now you’ve got me imagining the skeleton of Vince Lombardi dressed up in Giants gear and a headset on the sideline.

“… And as we’ve seen all season, the expression on Lombardi’s face never changes— he remains unflappable regardless of the score or situation.”

…

is going to be 70 years old in April. For that reason alone, he's not who I would pick. I'd want someone who I could reasonably expect could be here 6, 7, 10 years from now.

Shanahan for me.