Top 5 players NYG have drafted, signed or traded that SUCK

were more productive than Kadarius Toney at this point.

Jury is still out as he can turn it around, but... just sayin

.

Nothing left in the tank when we signed him.

Can't remember his name now. But he was beyond washed when he came here.

In comment 15844121 OBJ_AllDay said:

Quote:

Can't remember his name now. But he was beyond washed when he came here.

Brian Mitchell

Rocky Thompson
Junior Ioane

End of thread

projected to go late in the draft, Giants took him in the first round. Total bust.

In comment 15844138 Greg from LI said:

Quote:

End of thread

Good call. He derailed the 2009 season by himself.

Rocky Thompson
Eldridge Small
Kanavis Mc Ghee
Derek Brown
William Joseph

In comment 15844110 MartyNJ1969 said:

Quote:

Nothing left in the tank when we signed him.

If we signed Herman today, he'd be starting next week.

.

Solder
Flowers
Brandon Marshall
Patrick Omameh
Geoff Schwartz
Jonathan Stewart

...Also Cedric Jones should be an honorable mention as a draftee, and Carlos Emmons as a FA.

In comment 15844154 rasbutant said:

Quote:

Solder Flowers Brandon Marshall Patrick Omameh Geoff Schwartz Jonathan Stewart

Solder's 2021 performance was the most embarrassing I've seen. Golladay looks like All-Pro talent in comparison.

Joe Don Looney
John Hicks
Craig Morton
Butch Woolfolk
Tyrone Wheatley

picking guys like Rocky Thompson, Eldridge Small, Derek Brown, Cedrick Jones are low hanging fruit

Aka: toast

Joseph.

He and Archie Manning invented the run for your life offense

You would have to greatly expand the "5" requirement just for the last decade. It's difficult to choose just 5 imv.

1. Ron Dayne
2. Ereck Flowers
3. William Joseph
4. Sinorice Moss
5. Clint Sintin

Eye exam please

In comment 15844210 FatHeadTommy said:

Quote:

Eye exam please

You beat me to it!

At the very least an honorable mention.

In comment 15844110 MartyNJ1969 said:

Quote:

Nothing left in the tank when we signed him.

My head went here too.. if only he could've pulled down that Hail Mary against the Texans :)

Evan Engram !

In comment 15844225 johnnyb said:

Quote:

In comment 15844210 FatHeadTommy said: Quote: Eye exam please You beat me to it! At the very least an honorable mention.

He belongs on this list b/c of where he was picked, in front of Terry Glenn, Marvin Harrison, Ray Lewis, and Will Anderson, among others.

huge contract. 7 year deal if I remember..... dude to hurt half way through 1st season and retired

He made Ereck Flowers look like Anthony Munoz

In comment 15844192 Larry in Pencilvania said:

Quote:

He and Archie Manning invented the run for your life offense

I think the OP was blasting the return the Giants got for trading Tarkenton back to Minnesota.

I think the point of this thread is "Kenny Golladay is the worst player acquisition in Giants history." That may be true.

The thing is, every team has draft busts and mistakes (Derek Brown, Rocky Thompson, DeAndre Baker, yup) bad trades and free agent disasters. Also calamitous injuries (Jason Sehorn). I try to avoid dwelling on them but a lot of fans have PTSD about these things.

I figure, sometimes you win, sometimes you lose, sometimes it rains. Everybody gets lucky now and then (Ahmad Bradshaw) and everybody screws up now and then. Getting lucky doesn't make the GM a genius, screwing up doesn't make the GM an idiot. The good ones make more good decisions and screw up less. If we get that with Schoen, I'll be happy.

In comment 15844138 Greg from LI said:

Quote:

End of thread

Jesus what a brutal time. Didn’t they bring him back a second time or am I thinking of someone else?

In comment 15844300 fish3321 said:

Quote:

huge contract. 7 year deal if I remember..... dude to hurt half way through 1st season and retired

Arrington was at least playing well before the injury if I recall correctly

Jeremy Lincoln? Free agent i believe

and giving up the 2nd overall draft pick, which Dallas turned into Hall of Famer Randy White

LT Ereck Flowers
LG Will Hernandez
C Jon Halapio
RG Patrick Omameh
RT Nate Solder

QB Dave Brown

RB Jonathan Stewart
RB Ron Dayne

WR Brandon Marshall
WR Kenny Golladay
WR Sinorice Moss

TE Evan Engram
TE Brandon Myers

DE Cedric Jones
DT William Joseph
DT Marvin Austin
DE Owa Odighizuwa


LB Carlos Emmons
LB Barrett Green
LB Lorenzo Carter

CB DeAndre Baker
S CC Brown
S Will Demps
CB Sam Beal

Joe Don Looney
Eldrige Small
Rocky Thompson

the signings of Golladay and Solder were the most damaging to this team.

In comment 15844330 Chris684 said:

Quote:

LT Ereck Flowers LG Will Hernandez C Jon Halapio RG Patrick Omameh RT Nate Solder QB Dave Brown RB Jonathan Stewart RB Ron Dayne WR Brandon Marshall WR Kenny Golladay WR Sinorice Moss TE Evan Engram TE Brandon Myers DE Cedric Jones DT William Joseph DT Marvin Austin DE Owa Odighizuwa LB Carlos Emmons LB Barrett Green LB Lorenzo Carter CB DeAndre Baker S CC Brown S Will Demps CB Sam Beal

Marvin Austin had an important Super Bowl sack.

In comment 15844192 Larry in Pencilvania said:

Quote:

He and Archie Manning invented the run for your life offense

I believe he said trading Tarkenton back to Minnesota, but the Giants got Norm Snead in the trade and went 8-6 before the bottom fell out the next year.

In comment 15844346 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

In comment 15844330 Chris684 said: Quote: LT Ereck Flowers LG Will Hernandez C Jon Halapio RG Patrick Omameh RT Nate Solder QB Dave Brown RB Jonathan Stewart RB Ron Dayne WR Brandon Marshall WR Kenny Golladay WR Sinorice Moss TE Evan Engram TE Brandon Myers DE Cedric Jones DT William Joseph DT Marvin Austin DE Owa Odighizuwa LB Carlos Emmons LB Barrett Green LB Lorenzo Carter CB DeAndre Baker S CC Brown S Will Demps CB Sam Beal Marvin Austin had an important Super Bowl sack.

No he didn't. You're thinking of Jay Alford.

4th round pick, not the worst waste of a pick by a stretch, but he got cut during his first training camp. Think he played in 2 NFL games the following season with the Lions, that was his career

In comment 15844138 Greg from LI said:

Quote:

End of thread

Amazing reference. Forgot this guy. Awful.

In comment 15844346 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

In comment 15844330 Chris684 said: Quote: LT Ereck Flowers LG Will Hernandez C Jon Halapio RG Patrick Omameh RT Nate Solder QB Dave Brown RB Jonathan Stewart RB Ron Dayne WR Brandon Marshall WR Kenny Golladay WR Sinorice Moss TE Evan Engram TE Brandon Myers DE Cedric Jones DT William Joseph DT Marvin Austin DE Owa Odighizuwa LB Carlos Emmons LB Barrett Green LB Lorenzo Carter CB DeAndre Baker S CC Brown S Will Demps CB Sam Beal Marvin Austin had an important Super Bowl sack.

Jay Alford had the sack late in 4th Quarter versus Tom Brady. I would also consider Tim Carter or Thomas Lewis at WR.

In comment 15844358 Gman11 said:

Quote:

In comment 15844192 Larry in Pencilvania said: Quote: He and Archie Manning invented the run for your life offense I believe he said trading Tarkenton back to Minnesota, but the Giants got Norm Snead in the trade and went 8-6 before the bottom fell out the next year.

They also got a first round pick which they drafted Brad Van Pelt with.

The team got old and had little talent, especially on offense. It was going to be bad, and Tarkenton wasn’t going to save it.

In comment 15844346 US1 Giants said:

Quote:

In comment 15844330 Chris684 said: Quote: LT Ereck Flowers LG Will Hernandez C Jon Halapio RG Patrick Omameh RT Nate Solder QB Dave Brown RB Jonathan Stewart RB Ron Dayne WR Brandon Marshall WR Kenny Golladay WR Sinorice Moss TE Evan Engram TE Brandon Myers DE Cedric Jones DT William Joseph DT Marvin Austin DE Owa Odighizuwa LB Carlos Emmons LB Barrett Green LB Lorenzo Carter CB DeAndre Baker S CC Brown S Will Demps CB Sam Beal Marvin Austin had an important Super Bowl sack.

That was William Joseph

In comment 15844330 Chris684 said:

Quote:

LT Ereck Flowers LG Will Hernandez C Jon Halapio RG Patrick Omameh RT Nate Solder QB Dave Brown RB Jonathan Stewart RB Ron Dayne WR Brandon Marshall WR Kenny Golladay WR Sinorice Moss TE Evan Engram TE Brandon Myers DE Cedric Jones DT William Joseph DT Marvin Austin DE Owa Odighizuwa LB Carlos Emmons LB Barrett Green LB Lorenzo Carter CB DeAndre Baker S CC Brown S Will Demps CB Sam Beal

I'd put Tom Maddox or Mike Glennon on that list instead of Brown. I know he wasn't a great quarterback but I don't think he was quite as bad as some here made him out to be and he played his ass off for us on some pretty bad teams so I'm always willing to give Dave B a break

In comment 15844138 Greg from LI said:

Quote:

End of thread

I remember when the post said something to the effect of "CC stands for can't cover"

In comment 15844138 Greg from LI said:

Quote:

End of thread

I don't understand how it took even 14 minutes for his name to come up. That 09 season is an all time worst by any Giant regardless of position, at least in my life time.

I mean, he made most of us forget about Will Demps. You have any goddamn idea how hard that is? It's like forgetting about a famine because it's now raining sulphur.

We gave the Cowboys the 2nd pick in the draft who turned out to be Randy White!

Far worse than Dave Brown just because the trade helped the Cowboys so much!

And don't forget Aaron Ross's evil twin Aaron Rouse, the only player on the field worse than CC Brown.

Clifton McNeil. WR
Matt Hazeltine. LB
Ralph Gugilemo QB

and Apple. Back-to-back horrendous top 10 picks.

In comment 15844501 Bleedblue10 said:

Quote:

In comment 15844346 US1 Giants said: Quote: In comment 15844330 Chris684 said: Quote: LT Ereck Flowers LG Will Hernandez C Jon Halapio RG Patrick Omameh RT Nate Solder QB Dave Brown RB Jonathan Stewart RB Ron Dayne WR Brandon Marshall WR Kenny Golladay WR Sinorice Moss TE Evan Engram TE Brandon Myers DE Cedric Jones DT William Joseph DT Marvin Austin DE Owa Odighizuwa LB Carlos Emmons LB Barrett Green LB Lorenzo Carter CB DeAndre Baker S CC Brown S Will Demps CB Sam Beal Marvin Austin had an important Super Bowl sack. That was William Joseph

Neither of them played in the Super Bowl. Jay Alford had a Super Bowl sack

Mister “Just like getting a first round pick” Jabril Peppers.

Just awful. Fuck you, Dave Gettleman.

is every giant player ever.......

You're basically saying who are the worst giants of all time.

logged in to add Rueben Randle to the list of suck. Fuck that guy.

We had Unai Unga start several games at MLB in 2015.