We should have won that game. We'll win in two weeks. I thought we were going to get stomped after we went down 10-0. But they finally started running Jones again. That's the key to our offense until we get legitimate WRs.
say "impressed" but I think a lot of Giants fans are looking at this game from a biased position.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
Agree.. The fact that the Giants competed with the Cowboys last week and should have won this game against Washington with the current talent the Giants have now, is short of amazing. Every Giant fan should be thanking the Giants coaching staff. Be thankful we now have an excellent HC and DC.
say "impressed" but I think a lot of Giants fans are looking at this game from a biased position.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
Agree.. The fact that the Giants competed with the Cowboys last week and should have won this game against Washington with the current talent the Giants have now, is short of amazing. Every Giant fan should be thanking the Giants coaching staff. Be thankful we now have an excellent HC and DC.
-it is week 14 this coming week and we have 4 losses
-if you’re using this season as a means to find some talented players to add to the mix, McCloud seems like a nice find. Guy is solid.
-Ojulari, when healthy, really makes our pash rush dangerous. He’s awesome when he’s out there
-Thibodeaux turning a corner and could be rounding into form for the stretch run
-Bellinger definitely makes a difference out there
-Neal looked good and not too rusty
Negatives:
-Interior OL is somewhat awful
-we legitimately can’t throw to any receivers except Slayton and Hodgins, the offense basically has to be confined to them as far as WR goes. Really sucks but it is what it is
-Kafka getting away from up tempo and aggressiveness in the second half was odd. Can’t say whether or not it was intentional and we couldn’t get anything in the run game going. Gotta recognize it sooner I guess.
This offense is completely anemic. The defense looked fine and had the strip sack to set up a touchdown. Other than that the offense could barely get anything going. I feel like that deep Slayton play was about as many yards as the rest of the passing offense combined.
Not sure why we're using words like impressed. This offense is bottom of the barrel. It looked great the first few weeks but at this point it is on par with 2020 & 2021 offense.
Agree with OP. I felt we were going to get crushed after the 10 -0 lead. The previous regimes probably would of been. I'm still flying high on the turn around of this team.
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
Your an idiot. Without his legs we get destroyed yesterday. Let’s run down the list of things
Throws perfect pass to slayton within FG range feliciano penalty backs us up.
Throws perfect pass to slayton dropped. Would have won the game.
In OT. No timeouts 30 seconds left gets us within a decent shot at a field goal.
He can’t catch, run and throw to himself. Let’s also ignore the interior of the offensive line is atrocious. When Bredeson is back I put him at left guard and move gates to right guard. Enough of glowinski 7mm for what????? Horrendous signing
This coaching staff is allowed to be criticized. Kafka has been terrible since the Seattle game.
Daboll’s decision to have Jackson return punts after McKinney broke his hand was an egregious error in personnel management.
I know the roster is thin, and injuries have piled up in key positions. But the gameplan offensively has seemed to become so risk adverse that it’s been detrimental to the playcalling and game planning.
This coaching staff is allowed to be criticized. Kafka has been terrible since the Seattle game.
Daboll’s decision to have Jackson return punts after McKinney broke his hand was an egregious error in personnel management.
I know the roster is thin, and injuries have piled up in key positions. But the gameplan offensively has seemed to become so risk adverse that it’s been detrimental to the playcalling and game planning.
Seeing as how that 2nd half was being played and the results they were getting from the offense, it was the correct thing to do. They had a 2nd and two early in the 3rd quarter and Barkley just didn't get anything and on third it was another half assed play that netted 1 yard...
say "impressed" but I think a lot of Giants fans are looking at this game from a biased position.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
For all the reasons you stated, I think I would have been even more depressed with the tie if I was a Washington fan. The Giants could neither stop the run or guard McLaurin in the passing game.
The O actually was very reminiscent of the earlier first 7 games. Then it just vanished in the 2nd and that had to be the worst second half production wise. Be interesting if Sy or anyone else comments as to what WFT did/didn't do differently and why the Giants stopped executing. I was very pleased with the D especially after Williams went down. They battled.
two RB's running into each other on one of the biggest plays of the game or the offensive lineman who felt the need to run 20 yards downfield to pose and cost them a huge gain that could have potentially put the game away.
say "impressed" but I think a lot of Giants fans are looking at this game from a biased position.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
And in spite of all this we were ahead in the 4th by 7....
The D broke (and with that secondary not difficult to fathom) and they tied the game. Insofar as the OT, once we gave up the ball I thought we were dead. We made it to a tie, not good but better than a loss. Granted this was ours to have.
Not sure what folks were watching, but skins shot themselves in the foot a number of times. They could have easily won this game and have 2 weeks to plan for the next one.
The defense played very well. They picked up the offense holding the Commanders to a field goal after the turnover, and holding them off the score board for almost the entire second half despite getting no more than a few seconds rest between series.
Kafka wasn’t able to run tempo in the second half because his defense was gassed and they needed to get them a rest. They needed a few first downs here and there but they couldn’t get it. Running tempo would have only made the problems the offense created for the defense worse.
This team has some pieces on defense and Wink is doing well with what he has. The offense is probably playing to where their talent is. They need an infusion of interior linemen and playmakers.
two RB's running into each other on one of the biggest plays of the game or the offensive lineman who felt the need to run 20 yards downfield to pose and cost them a huge gain that could have potentially put the game away.
Have to agree with this post. I d give it a tie. Seriously though I m over this game and if someone at the beginning of the season said we d be 7-4-1 in December and in the playoff hunt I d have been ecstatic.
RE: RE: We're in year one of a three year rebuild.
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
If your QB is "fair to middling" (and I'm not certain that Jones can even achieve that level) then that QB is NOT the answer.
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
If your QB is "fair to middling" (and I'm not certain that Jones can even achieve that level) then that QB is NOT the answer.
Read the whole sentence the word "might" is in there. Furthermore, if the Giants determine there is a draft worthy QB in next years draft and they have the draft capital then draft the guy. We all have our opinions but we are not the experts. If DJ is back next year in some capacity the gm/ coach feel that he is of value to the team on some level.
The formula worked for three quarters - defense and Barkley and the go-ahead 20 yard "drive" in the 3rd quarter.
Don't look now but the UDFA quarterback took his team 90 yards in 2 minutes on the road to tie the game. And when the ball was put in the hands of our #1 pick, the 6th pick in the entire draft to take the team down for a winning FG with time on the clock? Zip, Nada. During OT when a FG would have won the game. Zero. Woulda, coulda, shoulda.
Yeah, it does seem like the early season Daboll- play to win- has been taken over by this current Daboll- playing not to lose.
Not to be argumentative, but I'd like to see what the starting lineups for Sept-Oct looked like, compared to Nov-Dec. We're using guys who weren't even on the roster the first 5 or 6 weeks. I don't know much, but I'd tend to think that might have something to do with the conservative approach. Maybe I'm way off base, I don't know.
Jones is a free agent, and you are all seeing in real time the confidence level they have in his abilities. If Taylor can't beat Jones out, you have to wonder about paying him $7 million.
And no boys, you don't run out and get receivers to bolster your crappy 6 yard an attempt qb. You do as Buffalo did, you get the wideout when the qb shows he can use such a player.
Interior OL was awful, the CBs made some really nice plays but were targeted and beaten plenty too. The defense ran out of gas in the fourth quarter, the ILBs are awful as usual.
The offense not being able to do much in the second half, some really suspect coaching and tactical decisions, and the constant mistakes snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. Failing to go up 10 late in the game gave WASH the crack they needed.
The formula worked for three quarters - defense and Barkley and the go-ahead 20 yard "drive" in the 3rd quarter.
Don't look now but the UDFA quarterback took his team 90 yards in 2 minutes on the road to tie the game. And when the ball was put in the hands of our #1 pick, the 6th pick in the entire draft to take the team down for a winning FG with time on the clock? Zip, Nada. During OT when a FG would have won the game. Zero. Woulda, coulda, shoulda.
Seems to me that the "moral victory" crowd is populated by people who want to stay the course with the QB and RB, and as such it's in their best interests to view the performance positively.
Point blank, they scored 20 points, 7 of which came on a 20-yard drive thanks to the defense. If the Giants had won 20-13, they'd be praising the QB. Instead it's "not on him". As always.
I don't see a big deal with keeping Barkley as long as it does not handicap the team. I don't think keeping Barkley is as simple as 'yes, no' 'bad, good'. The type of contract matters.
RE: RE: RE: RE: We're in year one of a three year rebuild.
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
If your QB is "fair to middling" (and I'm not certain that Jones can even achieve that level) then that QB is NOT the answer.
Read the whole sentence the word "might" is in there. Furthermore, if the Giants determine there is a draft worthy QB in next years draft and they have the draft capital then draft the guy. We all have our opinions but we are not the experts. If DJ is back next year in some capacity the gm/ coach feel that he is of value to the team on some level.
I read the whole the sentence.I saw you used the word "might". I'm saying if the QB is "fair to middling" there is absolutely no question as to whether he "might" be the answer. He is NOT.
I don’t share your optimism
It was dogshit man.
Dogshit.
You dont need to be profound.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
Yeah, it does seem like the early season Daboll- play to win- has been taken over by this current Daboll- playing not to lose.
Agree.. The fact that the Giants competed with the Cowboys last week and should have won this game against Washington with the current talent the Giants have now, is short of amazing. Every Giant fan should be thanking the Giants coaching staff. Be thankful we now have an excellent HC and DC.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
Agree.. The fact that the Giants competed with the Cowboys last week and should have won this game against Washington with the current talent the Giants have now, is short of amazing. Every Giant fan should be thanking the Giants coaching staff. Be thankful we now have an excellent HC and DC.
-it is week 14 this coming week and we have 4 losses
-if you’re using this season as a means to find some talented players to add to the mix, McCloud seems like a nice find. Guy is solid.
-Ojulari, when healthy, really makes our pash rush dangerous. He’s awesome when he’s out there
-Thibodeaux turning a corner and could be rounding into form for the stretch run
-Bellinger definitely makes a difference out there
-Neal looked good and not too rusty
Negatives:
-Interior OL is somewhat awful
-we legitimately can’t throw to any receivers except Slayton and Hodgins, the offense basically has to be confined to them as far as WR goes. Really sucks but it is what it is
-Kafka getting away from up tempo and aggressiveness in the second half was odd. Can’t say whether or not it was intentional and we couldn’t get anything in the run game going. Gotta recognize it sooner I guess.
Not sure why we're using words like impressed. This offense is bottom of the barrel. It looked great the first few weeks but at this point it is on par with 2020 & 2021 offense.
Definitely deserves the big bucks, right fanboys?
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
But when the o line sucks and the receivers suck that is not a reason for Jones not to be impressive.
People make no sense.
If your o line sucks it's hard to run or throw the ball. It's the same problem we have had for 10 years.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
Definitely deserves the big bucks, right fanboys?
Your an idiot. Without his legs we get destroyed yesterday. Let’s run down the list of things
Throws perfect pass to slayton within FG range feliciano penalty backs us up.
Throws perfect pass to slayton dropped. Would have won the game.
In OT. No timeouts 30 seconds left gets us within a decent shot at a field goal.
He can’t catch, run and throw to himself. Let’s also ignore the interior of the offensive line is atrocious. When Bredeson is back I put him at left guard and move gates to right guard. Enough of glowinski 7mm for what????? Horrendous signing
This coaching staff is allowed to be criticized. Kafka has been terrible since the Seattle game.
Daboll’s decision to have Jackson return punts after McKinney broke his hand was an egregious error in personnel management.
I know the roster is thin, and injuries have piled up in key positions. But the gameplan offensively has seemed to become so risk adverse that it’s been detrimental to the playcalling and game planning.
This coaching staff is allowed to be criticized. Kafka has been terrible since the Seattle game.
Daboll’s decision to have Jackson return punts after McKinney broke his hand was an egregious error in personnel management.
I know the roster is thin, and injuries have piled up in key positions. But the gameplan offensively has seemed to become so risk adverse that it’s been detrimental to the playcalling and game planning.
Seeing as how that 2nd half was being played and the results they were getting from the offense, it was the correct thing to do. They had a 2nd and two early in the 3rd quarter and Barkley just didn't get anything and on third it was another half assed play that netted 1 yard...
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
For all the reasons you stated, I think I would have been even more depressed with the tie if I was a Washington fan. The Giants could neither stop the run or guard McLaurin in the passing game.
The Commanders blew a 10-0 early lead. They out-gained the Giants in first downs, total yards, rushing yards, passing yards, and held a massive advantage in time of possession.
The Commanders held the Giants to 21 yards in the second half.
And the Commanders still didn't win the game.
Also keep in mind that the Commanders had the better rated defense and special teams. And the Giants secondary had Moreau, McCloud, and Gilbert starting.
And in spite of all this we were ahead in the 4th by 7....
The D broke (and with that secondary not difficult to fathom) and they tied the game. Insofar as the OT, once we gave up the ball I thought we were dead. We made it to a tie, not good but better than a loss. Granted this was ours to have.
they did
Kafka wasn’t able to run tempo in the second half because his defense was gassed and they needed to get them a rest. They needed a few first downs here and there but they couldn’t get it. Running tempo would have only made the problems the offense created for the defense worse.
This team has some pieces on defense and Wink is doing well with what he has. The offense is probably playing to where their talent is. They need an infusion of interior linemen and playmakers.
Quote:
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
If your QB is "fair to middling" (and I'm not certain that Jones can even achieve that level) then that QB is NOT the answer.
I don’t share your optimism
I hear that, I mean we couldn't even get a lousy 3pts in the 4th qt
I'm impressed that the team has done as well as it has, considering the injuries and talent level.
Is it just me, or was tackling a real issue yesterday?
I'm impressed that the team has done as well as it has, considering the injuries and talent level.
Is it just me, or was tackling a real issue yesterday?
The tackling was a complete embarrassment. Nick McLoud should be cut today for his laughable effort on the game tying TD at the end of regulation.
Quote:
In comment 15933383 MOOPS said:
Quote:
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
If your QB is "fair to middling" (and I'm not certain that Jones can even achieve that level) then that QB is NOT the answer.
Read the whole sentence the word "might" is in there. Furthermore, if the Giants determine there is a draft worthy QB in next years draft and they have the draft capital then draft the guy. We all have our opinions but we are not the experts. If DJ is back next year in some capacity the gm/ coach feel that he is of value to the team on some level.
Don't look now but the UDFA quarterback took his team 90 yards in 2 minutes on the road to tie the game. And when the ball was put in the hands of our #1 pick, the 6th pick in the entire draft to take the team down for a winning FG with time on the clock? Zip, Nada. During OT when a FG would have won the game. Zero. Woulda, coulda, shoulda.
Quote:
scared, cost us a victory. Joe Judge special.
Yeah, it does seem like the early season Daboll- play to win- has been taken over by this current Daboll- playing not to lose.
Not to be argumentative, but I'd like to see what the starting lineups for Sept-Oct looked like, compared to Nov-Dec. We're using guys who weren't even on the roster the first 5 or 6 weeks. I don't know much, but I'd tend to think that might have something to do with the conservative approach. Maybe I'm way off base, I don't know.
And no boys, you don't run out and get receivers to bolster your crappy 6 yard an attempt qb. You do as Buffalo did, you get the wideout when the qb shows he can use such a player.
The offense not being able to do much in the second half, some really suspect coaching and tactical decisions, and the constant mistakes snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. Failing to go up 10 late in the game gave WASH the crack they needed.
Don't look now but the UDFA quarterback took his team 90 yards in 2 minutes on the road to tie the game. And when the ball was put in the hands of our #1 pick, the 6th pick in the entire draft to take the team down for a winning FG with time on the clock? Zip, Nada. During OT when a FG would have won the game. Zero. Woulda, coulda, shoulda.
Seems to me that the "moral victory" crowd is populated by people who want to stay the course with the QB and RB, and as such it's in their best interests to view the performance positively.
Point blank, they scored 20 points, 7 of which came on a 20-yard drive thanks to the defense. If the Giants had won 20-13, they'd be praising the QB. Instead it's "not on him". As always.
Quote:
In comment 15933405 Maijay said:
Quote:
In comment 15933383 MOOPS said:
Quote:
We're in year one of a brand new GM, brand new Head Coach and brand new OC.
Expect growing pains on all levels.
The garbage is being sorted out and a foundation is being poured. The overwhelming majority are buying in and the ones that aren't will be gone soon enough.
The playoffs are within reach, a feat almost nobody would have thought possible a mere three months ago.
Did I mention meaningful games in December?
Sit back and enjoy the show.
Your assessment is spot on.The team has many holes to fill and the current coach and GM are competent at their jobs. The negative obsession with Daniel Jones is profound on this site. He is a fair to middling QB who might be the answer. If their draft position allows them to draft a potential franchise QB please do it. DJ has heart and at least he's a good back up QB. We have the right to be optimistic about the future. I think the team is in good hands both administratively and coaching wise.
If your QB is "fair to middling" (and I'm not certain that Jones can even achieve that level) then that QB is NOT the answer.
Read the whole sentence the word "might" is in there. Furthermore, if the Giants determine there is a draft worthy QB in next years draft and they have the draft capital then draft the guy. We all have our opinions but we are not the experts. If DJ is back next year in some capacity the gm/ coach feel that he is of value to the team on some level.
I read the whole the sentence.I saw you used the word "might". I'm saying if the QB is "fair to middling" there is absolutely no question as to whether he "might" be the answer. He is NOT.