Art Stapleton
@art_stapleton
·
31m
Former Rams and Lions DL A'Shawn Robinson is visiting the #Giants on Monday, source confirms. The 6-foot-4, 330-pounder would seem to be a very good add up front. Torn meniscus ended his 2022 in Nov.
We'll see what the market ends up being and if #NYG and Robinson make it work.
I didn't get to see many Giants games this year and in the ones I did see didn't really focus on it -- in what circumstances did the Giants use 2 DL vs. 3? Counting Thibodeaux and Ojulari or Ward as LBs, was it usually a 2-4-5 or 2-3-6 alignment? It seems like they rarely played 3 down linemen. Would they do it more with better depth?
I know Martindale likes to mix it up, but I'm trying to picture the roles of Lawrence, Williams, Roches and Robinson (assuming they sign him). thanks.
I didn't get to see many Giants games this year and in the ones I did see didn't really focus on it -- in what circumstances did the Giants use 2 DL vs. 3? Counting Thibodeaux and Ojulari or Ward as LBs, was it usually a 2-4-5 or 2-3-6 alignment? It seems like they rarely played 3 down linemen. Would they do it more with better depth?
I know Martindale likes to mix it up, but I'm trying to picture the roles of Lawrence, Williams, Roches and Robinson (assuming they sign him). thanks.
Earlier in the year before Davidson and Williams got hurt there was a fair amount of 3 DL alignments. In fact, they started 3 DLs (Williams, Dex and Leo) in a straight 3-4-4 the first game against Tenn. After the injuries, it became a lot of 2-4-5 pretty much out of necessity.
paying attention to the cap. Schoen is. The contracts are all structured with long term implications considered, and Schoen continues to add talent to the roster in the areas that needed upgrading.
People may be wondering “why no OL?” One, they have a number of young guys who need to be developed and two: the improvements may be better obtained from the draft.
paying attention to the cap. Schoen is. The contracts are all structured with long term implications considered, and Schoen continues to add talent to the roster in the areas that needed upgrading.
People may be wondering “why no OL?” One, they have a number of young guys who need to be developed and two: the improvements may be better obtained from the draft.
Remember that Leonard Williams CAP cost is currently over $30 million. Think big picture on several fronts.
I think they let both Leonard and Adoree walk.
Get two relatively good comp picks (3rd and 4th?). Also, that means you can spend next year's money this year.
Usually I would not favor that but they have to give DJ weapons and an OL to see if he is the guy.
And while Leonard was great, his play declined significantly last year. Injury? Yes. But guys over 30 get injured. Allotting him 30 million in cap space would be a mistake imo for a rebuilding team.
There’s always a mix:
Guys who are core (Thomas);
Guys who set a floor (Glowinski, Bredeson, Feliciano if he returns);
Guys you hope can do more (Neal, Ezeudu, maybe McKethan).
There were some solid floor-setters available in free agency, but the draft and some maturation by the “do more” group might yield as much or more improvement without the hefty price tag.
I’m trying to enjoy the run up to the 2023 season, and you’re mapping out who to let walk next year. You’re right, of course, that the cap requires a multi-year planning horizon.
Schoen is plugging holes, as promised. D line, TE, WR... They probably need a WR1/X in the early rounds, maybe a center and a safety but the draft becomes less about need and more about adding as much talent as possible. Maybe not pure BPA but closer to that than in recent years.
Also, I would think that from the GM's point of view, you sign veterans for depth as stopgaps and hope that you develop guys who step up to become useful depth, or starters, after they've had a year of NFL training.
RE: RE: What's your prediction for NFCE RB's A'Shawn?
watch the cap. But some of us like to do so. There's (at least) 3 aspects to football: the players, the coaching, and the management. As fans, we have no impact on any of it, but it can be fun to analyze any aspect of the game. Or we can choose to ignore any aspect if such is not up your alley.
Blindly thinking Schoen has a handle on it just because he's the GM is not automatically good thinking. Remember, Gettleman once had a plan and watched the budget, and look where that got us. Not saying Schoen is in DG's league, but right now we are only going on blind faith that he's not.
You can't get emotional about the 32M number, nor the 6M in dead money on next year. 12M of those dollars are literally how the Giants operated last year, and 8M of it was there the moment he signed his deal.
The only number that matters is 18M, that's the new cash he's owed.
What would you pay Leonard Williams for 1 year? What would you pay him for 2 years?
with Dex and Leo would be Chris Canty. Robinson may be a version of that (and hopefully as good as Canty was for us)
Canty had above average pass rush ability . Robinson not so much. However he certainly has talent and would be a sizeable upgrade in depth over last year.
Still pretty young and would be a massive depth upgrade. Anything that improves depth and doesn’t really impact cap long term is fine by me. Would really like this signing.
I see us playing more 3-4 than we did this year. I wondered if that was due to a lack of depth at IDL, and I now suspect it was.
I think part of it. They need to be bigger and more stout on the front. This is especially true against division teams.
This player has played the 5tech so he may be looked at being on the field with Leo and Dex. Wink had bigger DE's in Baltimore. I also think targeting a player is in the cards this draft. Bigger DE with some rush ability on the inside who excels at stopping the run.
if you haven’t been paying attention to Schoens deals than that’s on you. Not picking up Jones’ 5th, not caving to Barkley, taking it on the chin with Golladay, and a lot of low cost, low risk deals last year and this year with decent upside = confidence in our GM based on what’s transpired to date.
if you haven’t been paying attention to Schoens deals than that’s on you. Not picking up Jones’ 5th, not caving to Barkley, taking it on the chin with Golladay, and a lot of low cost, low risk deals last year and this year with decent upside = confidence in our GM based on what’s transpired to date.
robinson and reed played next to each other at bama, got picked 3 selections apart in the 2nd round of the 2016 draft, and have each bounced around the nfl as run stuffers.
Quote:
Aaron Wilson @AaronWilson_NFL
#Seahawks Jarran Reed two years, $9M, $4.19M gtd, $3M signing bonus, salaries $1.19M (gtd), $3.96M; $20K per game active roster bonus 2023, $30K per game active roster bonus 2024; $900K playtime-sacks incentive annual
if im doing math right, his first year cap # is 2.7m. year 2 he has a 4m salary/5.5m cap #, or they can cut him, save $4m, and eat the 1.5m in dead $.
Probably room on the roster for one more DL, though I’d imagine probably for a rookie. But CC sure would be a sweet one or two year rental if the price is right.
on the DL to help give Dex & Leo rest and not compromise the run defense when they are out. I would love to see a LB early in the draft too to pair with Okereke who can run to the ball and suddenly your run defense is no longer a glaring weakness taking on Philly and Dallas.
on the DL to help give Dex & Leo rest and not compromise the run defense when they are out. I would love to see a LB early in the draft too to pair with Okereke who can run to the ball and suddenly your run defense is no longer a glaring weakness taking on Philly and Dallas.
Love him or hate him he’s nailed a few moves this off-season.
He didn’t nail anything that was not out there or known. If a guy is coming to the building the parameters on a deal are in place other than in his case someone to look at the medicals or check him out personally. If he doesn’t sign it’s cause he failed his physical.
“ #Giants DT A’Shawn Robinson lo tendría prácticamente cerrado con la franquicia de Nueva York. Fuentes cercanas al equipo me confirman que Joe Schoen esta enfocado en esta FA, en reforzar la defensa contra la carrera. En las próximas horas se anunciará el contrato. #TogetherBlue”
Google translate says it will be announced soon lol
Sometimes when visits are reported as being on a certain date, the visit starts in the late afternoon/early evening with the team taking the player to dinner then the following day they check medicals and what not.
pff tracks that and calls it 'stops'. in 2021 robinson was 2nd best in the nfl with 39 (aaron donald was first with 40).
@art_stapleton
·
31m
Former Rams and Lions DL A'Shawn Robinson is visiting the #Giants on Monday, source confirms. The 6-foot-4, 330-pounder would seem to be a very good add up front. Torn meniscus ended his 2022 in Nov.
We'll see what the market ends up being and if #NYG and Robinson make it work.
Quote:
wish they had a stat for tackles at LOS, 1 yard, 2 yard. Not as flashy but still big defensive plays, especially first two categories
pff tracks that and calls it 'stops'. in 2021 robinson was 2nd best in the nfl with 39 (aaron donald was first with 40).
Great find, Eric.
nunez-roches had 21 in 18 games. this was a career best for him by a lot.
williams had 20 in 14 games.
robinson had 18 in 10 games before he got hurt.
seems like nyg believe in stops.
I know Martindale likes to mix it up, but I'm trying to picture the roles of Lawrence, Williams, Roches and Robinson (assuming they sign him). thanks.
Guys come here may reach a new level.
Guys come here may reach a new level.
Thats a great point. He taught Dex some serious 'Ju Jitsu' hand fighting technique and now we gets leverage on these guys and drives them into the QB!
Well, the pandemic had something to do with that in recent years too.
I know Martindale likes to mix it up, but I'm trying to picture the roles of Lawrence, Williams, Roches and Robinson (assuming they sign him). thanks.
Earlier in the year before Davidson and Williams got hurt there was a fair amount of 3 DL alignments. In fact, they started 3 DLs (Williams, Dex and Leo) in a straight 3-4-4 the first game against Tenn. After the injuries, it became a lot of 2-4-5 pretty much out of necessity.
Quote:
PAIN !
How’s this guy going to ever hear the play call?
That was hilarious.
People may be wondering “why no OL?” One, they have a number of young guys who need to be developed and two: the improvements may be better obtained from the draft.
People may be wondering “why no OL?” One, they have a number of young guys who need to be developed and two: the improvements may be better obtained from the draft.
Well said
I think they let both Leonard and Adoree walk.
Get two relatively good comp picks (3rd and 4th?). Also, that means you can spend next year's money this year.
Usually I would not favor that but they have to give DJ weapons and an OL to see if he is the guy.
And while Leonard was great, his play declined significantly last year. Injury? Yes. But guys over 30 get injured. Allotting him 30 million in cap space would be a mistake imo for a rebuilding team.
Guys who are core (Thomas);
Guys who set a floor (Glowinski, Bredeson, Feliciano if he returns);
Guys you hope can do more (Neal, Ezeudu, maybe McKethan).
There were some solid floor-setters available in free agency, but the draft and some maturation by the “do more” group might yield as much or more improvement without the hefty price tag.
Haha! 😂
Also, I would think that from the GM's point of view, you sign veterans for depth as stopgaps and hope that you develop guys who step up to become useful depth, or starters, after they've had a year of NFL training.
Quote:
PAIN !
How’s this guy going to ever hear the play call?
Freaking hilarious
Blindly thinking Schoen has a handle on it just because he's the GM is not automatically good thinking. Remember, Gettleman once had a plan and watched the budget, and look where that got us. Not saying Schoen is in DG's league, but right now we are only going on blind faith that he's not.
The only number that matters is 18M, that's the new cash he's owed.
What would you pay Leonard Williams for 1 year? What would you pay him for 2 years?
That's the only thing to worry about.
Canty had above average pass rush ability . Robinson not so much. However he certainly has talent and would be a sizeable upgrade in depth over last year.
Quote:
PAIN !
How’s this guy going to ever hear the play call?
Hahaha
I think part of it. They need to be bigger and more stout on the front. This is especially true against division teams.
This player has played the 5tech so he may be looked at being on the field with Leo and Dex. Wink had bigger DE's in Baltimore. I also think targeting a player is in the cards this draft. Bigger DE with some rush ability on the inside who excels at stopping the run.
Silly, I know..
#Seahawks Jarran Reed two years, $9M, $4.19M gtd, $3M signing bonus, salaries $1.19M (gtd), $3.96M; $20K per game active roster bonus 2023, $30K per game active roster bonus 2024; $900K playtime-sacks incentive annual
if im doing math right, his first year cap # is 2.7m. year 2 he has a 4m salary/5.5m cap #, or they can cut him, save $4m, and eat the 1.5m in dead $.
I’ve been campaigning for just that(LB early)
He didn’t nail anything that was not out there or known. If a guy is coming to the building the parameters on a deal are in place other than in his case someone to look at the medicals or check him out personally. If he doesn’t sign it’s cause he failed his physical.
Google translate says it will be announced soon lol
Sometimes when visits are reported as being on a certain date, the visit starts in the late afternoon/early evening with the team taking the player to dinner then the following day they check medicals and what not.