for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: Question about Comcast/Xfinity cable box and modem/router

Vin_Cuccs : 3/26/2023 9:18 pm
Hello all-

My parents are getting absolutely crushed with the price of their internet and cable from Comcast/Xfinity...about $250 per month.

About 4 years ago, I cut the cord and now stream exclusively, mostly through Hulu. They would do the same, but my grandmother lives with my parents and she would not be able to figure out streaming options....so unfortunately, streaming is not feasible.

As a cost-cutting option, they are looking to buy their own cable boxes, modem, and router to avoid the monthly rental cost from Comcast/Xfinity.

So my question is, has anyone purchased their own Comcast/Xfinity compatible cable boxes? If so, which one?

They will also need a modem/router. Any options for a combo unit? My mother works from home, so she will need a landline for the modem/router.

Any info or suggestions would be much appreciated! Thanks in advance!
Vin,  
ColHowPepper : 3/26/2023 9:55 pm : link
Not sure if any value added here, but:
We're new to Xfinity having moved in Aug. I think its one piece, combo modem/router works quite well, includes landlineservice.
I was also told by a friendly rep (aren't they all?) that once service is established that, if you keep the MAIN STB, you can achieve pretty much the same level of service if you give back the other STBs and stream only to those monitors. We haven't gone that route yet
You're not going to be able to buy your own cable box  
moespree : 3/26/2023 10:48 pm : link
What you can do though is buy something that requires a cable card. For example Tivo (there are others too). Then Comcast will give you a cable card to put into the back of the TiVo and that's about $5 a month or so. So in other words you won't have to pay the normal $15-$20 rental fee for the cable box, just the smaller fee for the cable card.

Aa for the modem and router or modem/router combo it has to be compatible to Xfinity. It also has to have enough speed for whatever speed you are signed up for.

I've attached a link, to an Xfinity page that will give you compatible modems and routers once you sign in to your account.
link - ( New Window )
The cost is expensive  
LauderdaleMatty : 3/27/2023 7:20 am : link
Depending on what they are getting. My guess is the cost is so high due to premium services etc. have you looked at the bill. Also I'd be careful about the speed of the internet. Do 3 older people need the faster gig speed. Devil is I the details. Good luck
Fire TV  
HBart : 3/27/2023 7:36 am : link
I'e had Rokus for years, but decided to try a FireTV this time around.

Having used it a couple of months, were I trying to save dough and duplicate cable, I'd get a Fire TV, Prime video, and a good HD antenna. That provides unlimited content options with an even easier interface than cable boxes I see. Local channels are in boxes the top so you see what's on, streaming content shows up on the same screen, one interface to all streaming channels, all integrated into the home screen.

It can get confusing when you tack on Hulu, Netflix, HBO and Disney -- especially when the power saver comes on. But with just Prime and OTA it's simple. $10/month for prime (paid annually) plus whatever channels you tack on in Prime.
Regarding the Price  
GruningsOnTheHill : 3/27/2023 8:25 am : link
After years of deliberating, we finally cut the cable last month when our bill hit $260 per month. I'm a creature of habit, and I didn't want to give up the comfort of being able to scroll through the channels with the Frontier remote, but I found that YouTubeTV has the exact same feature. It was a little bit of a learning curve, but our bill is exactly half what it was with Frontier. I feel like a chump for not having done this years ago.

To your point about your parents paying $250 per month: You always used to be able to call in every year and threaten to take your business to a competitor, at which point the retention dept would step in and give you another 1-year promo price. I found that they were no longer offering these promos. The cable guy who swapped out our router last month to accommodate the higher-speed internet told me that all the big cable companies know that the days of cable TV are numbered, and none of them are giving discounts anymore. He said that they are aggressively jacking up their prices to squeeze every dollar they can out of those who don't mind paying and older people who are set in their ways.

Good luck trying to find a box. I know with Frontier, that's how they make their $$. When we said goodbye to cable last month, they didn't even want their HD boxes back, and the zombie phone rep told me I was free to recycle or do what I wish with them. As would be par for the course, I figured I'd get hit with a bill for not returning the boxes, but again, the cable guy confirmed that Frontier doesn't even want the cable-related equipment back anymore. With all the money I paid to "rent" those boxes over the years, I felt like I should have had them bronzed and displayed in the living room.
RE: You're not going to be able to buy your own cable box  
26.2 : 3/27/2023 8:27 am : link
In comment 16075837 moespree said:
Quote:
What you can do though is buy something that requires a cable card. For example Tivo (there are others too). Then Comcast will give you a cable card to put into the back of the TiVo and that's about $5 a month or so. So in other words you won't have to pay the normal $15-$20 rental fee for the cable box, just the smaller fee for the cable card.

Aa for the modem and router or modem/router combo it has to be compatible to Xfinity. It also has to have enough speed for whatever speed you are signed up for.

I've attached a link, to an Xfinity page that will give you compatible modems and routers once you sign in to your account. link - ( New Window )


The only time I tried to get a compatible modem, it did not end up working even after they came out a couple of times to my house. So I just ended up continuing to rent one from them.
I cut out Directv by  
Beer Man : 3/27/2023 9:20 am : link
Keeping my high-speed internet connection for $60 per month, and then signing up for Youtube TV for about $70 per month. To stream Youtube TV I purchased Roku devises for all of my TVs. YouTube TV will also be carring Sunday Ticket starting this fall.
I would recommend they buy the modem and router,  
Section331 : 3/27/2023 9:32 am : link
they can likely use them with any, or most, providers. I would not buy cable boxes though. First of all, most cable MSO’s will be phasing them out to go with streaming style formats. And even if their MSO sticks with boxes, what happens when they upgrade them? Your parents may be out of luck.
I have Xfinity  
VTChuck : 3/27/2023 9:40 am : link
and am paying ~$225 for Gig fiber internet, Cable w/ sports package and Voice over IP. I rent their router

Our city has a franchise contract w/ Comcast, so no competition.

Our service includes Xfinity Stream with allows you watch all your channels on computer, phone and Roku / Fire etc. Allows me to watch TV in bedroom, den without having additional cable boxes

This is much cheaper than what I paid when I lived in the sticks w/ a local Internet Coop, DirecTV, landline phone and no cell service.

You could probably whittle down the cost by down-grading your internet and dropping premiums. Good luck

My father in law recently moved to an Xfinity area.  
11 to 89 : 3/27/2023 9:47 am : link
bought this modem/router for him and it works great.
Link - ( New Window )
Thanks for the information everyone! I appreciate it!  
Vin_Cuccs : 3/27/2023 10:32 am : link
As expected, this does not seem like it is going to be easy.
What do your parents and grandmother like to watch?  
JohnF : 3/27/2023 11:31 am : link
If they aren't into sports, then a combination of an HD antenna and Roku or Firestick along with a basic cable package should do the trick. I think Xfinity offers a senior package.

With an HD antenna, you can get a lot of free HD local channels (depending on where you are). With my Roku TV, I can easily switch between Over the Air, and then get all the movies and old TV shows I want with Tubi, Pluto, Amazon (if you have Amazon Prime), Xumo, etc.

The key is finding out what they want to see. Most people don't watch 90% or more of what's offered.
RE: I have Xfinity  
Jim in Fairfax : 3/27/2023 11:49 am : link
In comment 16075939 VTChuck said:
Quote:

Our city has a franchise contract w/ Comcast, so no competition.

Franchise agreements don’t preclude competition. They set the terms of operation, which includes offering service to every household in the covered jurisdiction. There’s nothing legally stopping another cable company from signing a franchise agreement and offering service. But practically this rarely happens due to the cost of cabling up all the neighborhoods. Verizon was doing this with FIOS in many areas but stopped.
Back to the Corner