I've been posting about it for a decade.
The problem for McAdoo, Shurmur, and Judge were they couldn't beat the Cowboys and Eagles.
Given who the Giants (and the rest of the division) play this year, I think it will be tough for three playoff teams to come out of the NFC East again. The schedules are just too tough.
I want to see three things this year from the team vis a vis the rest of the division:
(1) Giants sweeping the Commanders.
(2) Giants at least going 1-1 versus the Cowboys, but moving past them in the overall standings. This is doable in my view.
(3) I expect the Giants to have problems with the Eagles again. Much depends on the impact of the loss of their two coordinators. Splitting the series 1-1 would be a MAJOR accomplishment. However, the one thing that would be very disheartening is to see the Eagles beat the Giants 48-22 and 38-7 again. Those games were not even competitive. At the very least, the Giants need to demonstrate they are in the same league with the Eagles.