This will surely change between now and April, but as it stands right now, the draftnik consensus seems to divide the prospects into...
SuperBlue: Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, Marvin Harrison Jr
Blue: Olu Fashanu, Brock Bowers
Red: Dallas Turner, Joe Alt, Keon Coleman, Jared Verse, Rome Odunze, Kool Aid McKinstry, etc, etc, etc (figure on more than a dozen red chips and roughly 20 or so prospects overall with 1st round grades, historically speaking).
The top three in the SuperBlue category haven't budged from their spots since the start of the year, but there's been some shuffling just below with Dallas Turner and Joe Alt making the strongest push to join Fashanu and Bowers as consensus blue chippers. As for those two, I wouldn't be surprised to see Fashanu join Harrison Jr as the only two non-QB SuperBlues while Bowers falls to the Red category.
Of course there are a handful of QB prospects who could crash the Blue/Super Blue party. Shedeur Sanders seems to be picking up steam, ranked #9 overall on the
Great Blue North Big Board and #5 on
Mel Kiper's Board (dated 10/19 so not sure if it's current). And Jayden Daniels, JJ McCarthy, Bo Nix, and Michael Penix Jr, and Quinn Ewers are some others who are enjoying some love from the draftnik community.
Also, this Harbaugh game planning is really messing up the McCarthy scouting and introducing a big wild card into the 1st rd.
The Giants could potentially trade back into the first round round (which would likely mean giving up two of their three Day 2 picks and their 2025 first round pick) to hopefully nab the second tier QB of their choice.
We haven't even gotten into the nit-picking season on these guys yet.
We haven't even gotten into the nit-picking season on these guys yet.
Yes, but what else you want to talk about....
Otherwise, I think you categorized it well.
Quote:
on how this draft is going to shape up.
We haven't even gotten into the nit-picking season on these guys yet.
Yes, but what else you want to talk about....
Ugh.
You're so right.
Let the nit-picking begin.
FYI, I have been saying Arch Manning will be next real giants QB two years ago. I agree, drafting Marvin Harrison will probably give us two Bilitnekoff winners at the WR1 and WR2 positions that's if marvin wins the award which is likely.
1. QB Williams
2. WR Harrison
3. QB Maye
4. OL Fashanu
5. ER Verse
6. CB Newton
7. OL Alt
8. ER Turner
9. ER Egbuka (Giants)
10 ER Latham
Trapasso...
1. QB Williams
2. QB Maye
3. WR Harrison
4. QB Nix (Giants)
5. Ol Fashanu
6. CB Newton
7. OL Fuaga
8. WR Odunze
9. QB McCarthy
10.OL Alt
Edwards...
1. QBWilliams
2. QB Maye
3. WR Harrison
4. ER Turner (Giants)
5. TE Bowers
6. OL Fashanu
7. OL Alt
8. QB McCarthy
9. ER Verse
10.ER Latham
All three in total (from CBS Sports)... - ( New Window )
Quote:
I stopped reading your post once I saw Jayden Daniels was not in the super blue or blue categories.
It's not about me, it's about the consensus among draftniks. It's a fluid situation that will surely change but this is where we are right now (or before this past weekend).
With all due respect, you posted it as your opinion of the entire draftnik community. Unless you are an AI entity capable of computational models assimilating all meta data.
Jayden Daniels is a legit conversation to be the #1 pick of the draft…..
Based on how he's played this year, I would not touch him in the first round. And I'm a Penn State fan.
He needs to be in the "Most Likely to Bust" category.
With all due respect, you posted it as your opinion of the entire draftnik community. Unless you are an AI entity capable of computational models assimilating all meta data.