HC/DC/OC-

Unless something controversial happens off the field.

I would replace McGaughey and Bobby Johnson. I would also sign Andre Patterson to a long term extension as DL coach.

I really didn't want Wink to leave for a HC job last year but this year I feel differently. There should be some good options available to replace him if he leaves.

go to, IMHO.

be brought back?

More imagination. And I m not talking trick plays . This year I could swear Garrett was our OC again.

devastating to lose Wink, but now I would probably prefer he be gone. I think his scheme with just 2 down linemen is awful. His man corners either give too much space or don't jam at the line, and his blitzes are not getting home. Unless this offense is just beyond help, I can't see what Kafka's doing to make it better. His playcalling is often ridiculously conservative.

You are, what your record says you are. (Courtesy of Coach Parcells)

Has earned another year with a OL and QB1.
Does anyone think some other OC could do better?
When we have no QB the other team just loads the box and takes away Saquon.
What would you do differently as OC given our injury plagued season????

and his shitty calls can get the F out of here. I'd like to keep Wink.

Mcgaughey getting fired shouldn't even be a question. Same for Johnson

I would fire Johnson during the bye week, no question.

but not Kafka. It's their offense.

I think they both should get a pass but all for new blood at OL and Special teams coaching.

But Daboll will need to take over the offense more going forward. He is going to be on the hot seat to start the year next year. He needs to lean in and take control weather it is as play caller or full on OC.

It’s Daboll’s offense, and Daboll is almost certainly intimately involved in game planning. How much of the offensive dysfunction is Kafka’s fault? If we believe Caboll should be back because he’s been saddled with an UDFA rookie QB and an atrocious OL, why doesn’t Kafka get the same benefit?

That said, I don’t know what qualities Kafka brings to the table. What I am almost certain of is whomever Daboll bring in as OC, the offense is still going to have his imprint on it, and it should. That is why he is the HC.

Oline is abysmal and has been all year. Has anyone seen development from any of these players? Sure injuries screw with cohesion and chemistry, but that’s the challenge of the Oline Coach. Every team deals with it and the Giants have not done a very good job of handling adversity.

Of them all. Not one single coach on this staff deserves to have a job in 2024. This is an embarrassing mess. Better coaches would produce a better outcome on the field, I have no doubt.