Great win. Too early to worry about draft pick position and it’s not like either Caleb or Drake have looked like world beaters. Daboll and team needed a W.
I know a lot of people on the board won't be happy with this, but with at least adequate play from QB, the Giants may go on a mini win streak. The Patriots are beatable if the defense plays well.
I know a lot of people on the board won't be happy with this, but with at least adequate play from QB, the Giants may go on a mini win streak. The Patriots are beatable if the defense plays well.
The Commanders dogged it today. Pats are coming off their bye. I see a loss next week.
I’d love to see a win against the Eagles. That would make my season. Let the draft fall where it will. We’ll have a very good pick regardless. We need tons of help.
literally gave the game away. Six turnovers, and it should have been seven. And despite the first five, they still had a chance to win at the end.
DeVito was decent. Some nice throws, but holds the ball way too long, which I guess is to be expected given his inexperience. The OL was putrid. No running game until the end. Bad play calling with passes that required deep drops.
Defense got gashed, especially when Lawrence was out. But it was opportunistic.
I don't like when my Giants lose, but they need to this season in order to improve this teams talent. Unfortunately, the Giants Org are special and somehow keep putting themselves in bad positions.
We don't get to play the Commanders again, I doubt any of our remaining opponents turn over the ball 6 times, and we'll still have problems winning games with this OL without a big turnover margin.
tommy is our future back up QB. He does some things pretty well
What I like about him and we saw it in preseason is even for an undrafted walk on he has the demeanor and attitude of someone who's been around for a while he doesn't look scared or have that deer in the headlights look or make panic throws
The coaches and players will always play to win. It's just the reality.
My takeaway is DeVito throwing for 3 TD's, that hasn't happened since 2019 - incredible. This defense will feast on bad QB's.
Schoen picking up that 2nd and a 5th for Leo will open up flexibility to either us it to trade up or take the next tier guy. We are going to take a QB just a question of whom and when.
It is what it is. There’s some ER and WR talent we desperately could use. And can’t rule out an OT like Alt.
He's a vet now that these young guys can lean on. Just gotta manage his carries/touches so as not to burn him out in this lost season as well as going forward (hopefully).
next year? If so this win does not really feel good.
Not one of the top 3 anyway.
Are you going to just keep doing this incessantly? We aren’t going to forfeit games, what are you expecting here? And other teams will play and win games too, you have no idea where we will be picking.
Oh and trades happen to move up in drafts, not sure if you knew that but now you do.
next year? If so this win does not really feel good.
Not one of the top 3 anyway.
We're going to be stuck w Daniel Jones them . I am sure Mara is happry because he didn't want to draft a QB anyway and, this is the perfect excuse to run it back againw Daniel jones who throws for less yards than Danny devito.
People said that when we “lost out” on Chase Young.
People say dumb shit all the time. You are comparing Apples to Oranges.
People think Daniel Jones will wina SB like Eli did even though we;re already past that point. People think Daniel Jones wil right the ship like Phil Simms did -- we are past that point also.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I will never apologize for reveling in beating the Skins
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
People said that when we “lost out” on Chase Young.
Haha, said that earlier in the other thread.
What if the NYG fell out of the top 3-4 and ended up with a stud like the TE Bowers? Sure he’s not as impactful as a top QB but he might be the closest thing to 89 as ever entered the draft. He’d look great in Blue .
Trade up with future picks and the 2’s if a QB is a must but don’t ever turn down a top talent, no matter the position. You can never have enough really good players.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
You know you go on with your weird hard-on for the Jets I have better things to do. I am sorry that there are some really obnoxious Jets fans in your particular area ; I know some that I consider to be decent people. And that 3rd string rookie does not look that much different than our overdrafted, overpaid #6 overall draft pick.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
You know you go on with your weird hard-on for the Jets I have better things to do. I am sorry that there are some really obnoxious Jets fans in your particular area ; I know some that I consider to be decent people. And that 3rd string rookie does not look that much different than our overdrafted, overpaid #6 overall draft pick.
Exactly, and they had them beat with a 3rd string rookie QB. Says it all, really.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
RE: Divito 3 TD, no INT and a 137.7 Quarterback Rating
Exactly, and they had them beat with a 3rd string rookie QB. Says it all, really.
The fact that DEvito just threw over 250 yards and 3 TDs against the Redskins -- same as Daniel jones does -- which is like the only time Jones ever does throw for 250+ yards and more than 1 TD a game -- should tell you all you need to know about your woulda coulda arguments.;
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
The Giants really need to draft some o lineman. Besides, Thomas Neal Schmidts Mekethan Peart Edzudu they haven’t drafted anyone.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
I would laugh my ass off at this comment in April when the Giants draft a QB but I won't remember who wrote it nor will you joke about how wrong you were.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
The Giants have 3 QBs and all 3 would be serviceable to above average behind a decent Oline. If you do draft a QB do it in the second round.
The Giants have 3 QBs and all 3 would be serviceable to above average behind a decent Oline. If you do draft a QB do it in the second round.
The hell are you talking about?
Daniel Jones is a BELOW AVG. QB.
Tyrod is a journeyman back-up.
DEvito is an undrafted free agent who is a rookie at lie age 25. Who so far is the only real question mark at what we have in a QB. WTF is the point of drafting a QB at all then unless someone like Levis slips late. You might as well play Daniel jones then in week 3 when he is ready then and let him play here for 3 years.
RE: RE: TDV sustained those sacks without too much
found their quarterback, Super Bowl next year baby!
All kidding aside, he's a better passer than the backup QB,
and he was running for his life most of the game. They had five sacks in the first quarter alone, he hung in there, give him credit.
All kidding aside, he's a better passer than the backup QB,
Might be a bit strong. There were plenty of explosive plays when Tyrod was in there.
.
Not really, I felt that way in the preseason. Taylor is not very accurate. This kid throws a nice ball with time to throw. I rather see DeVito finish the season out.
was fine, especially given the porous OL. But as HardTruth said, the Commanders are the one team Jones has owned. He likely therefore would have been just as successful today.
The Giants might win another few games, which if doing so, means we don't get Williams, Maye, or Daniels will make many here furious. I won't be one of them. I root for the Giants to win every game.
was fine, especially given the porous OL. But as HardTruth said, the Commanders are the one team Jones has owned. He likely therefore would have been just as successful today.
The Giants might win another few games, which if doing so, means we don't get Williams, Maye, or Daniels will make many here furious. I won't be one of them. I root for the Giants to win every game.
Exactly. Try to win every game like you're supposed to do as a professional with any sense of pride and then let the chips fall where they may with the draft months later
Seriously, though, we're still fine. I don't see us falling too far back by the end of the season. We should still be in play for Daniels or McCarthy and possibly still even have a shot at Maye.
Seriously, though, we're still fine. I don't see us falling too far back by the end of the season. We should still be in play for Daniels or McCarthy and possibly still even have a shot at Maye.
Lot of season left. They were gifted 6 turnovers. Hard to lose.
Player acquisition is not responsibility of the team
Seriously, though, we're still fine. I don't see us falling too far back by the end of the season. We should still be in play for Daniels or McCarthy and possibly still even have a shot at Maye.
Lot of season left. They were gifted 6 turnovers. Hard to lose.
Did we turn the ball over?
Had a team ever with a +6 ever lost.....but we were in position to do so. Keep that in mind.
Glad she got to see a win after making the effort to go to the game! At home on TV, it sounded like at least half a Giants crowd in the stands. CN BBIers who went to the game weigh in on the crowd?
Glad she got to see a win after making the effort to go to the game! At home on TV, it sounded like at least half a Giants crowd in the stands. CN BBIers who went to the game weigh in on the crowd?
She's not back yet, but she was pretty stoked. (She went with her Commanders boy friend... so you can tell she was extra motivated too).
and there’s plenty others who have excelled picked much later, Lamar Jackson, etc. You have to scout and do research well and have the conviction that you’re picking the right guy. Maye and Williams both have great attributes, but a guy like Daniels also looks like a tremendous QB. Never can tell. We selected Barkley instead of Darnold in that draft and how’d that work out for the Jets who picked him at #3. Let the season play out first and then we can talk draft and who’s available. In the mean time, enjoy the win and that your team played with a desire today. They could have just given up. Will they win another game this year? Who knows, but let it play out and enjoy this win for once in a while.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
!
omg show me a shred of proof this is true. People are delusional
and there’s plenty others who have excelled picked much later, Lamar Jackson, etc. You have to scout and do research well and have the conviction that you’re picking the right guy. Maye and Williams both have great attributes, but a guy like Daniels also looks like a tremendous QB. Never can tell. We selected Barkley instead of Darnold in that draft and how’d that work out for the Jets who picked him at #3. Let the season play out first and then we can talk draft and who’s available. In the mean time, enjoy the win and that your team played with a desire today. They could have just given up. Will they win another game this year? Who knows, but let it play out and enjoy this win for once in a while.
Hope for loses so I’ve been conflicted. I want one of the top QB’s but a win always feels good. Even we can’t land one of the top 3 guys though I don’t see any of the other ones worth a top 10 pick.
Hope for loses so I’ve been conflicted. I want one of the top QB’s but a win always feels good. Even we can’t land one of the top 3 guys though I don’t see any of the other ones worth a top 10 pick.
You hope for a win, but are not disappointed if they lose unless it is on some glaringly bonehead call.
Glad she got to see a win after making the effort to go to the game! At home on TV, it sounded like at least half a Giants crowd in the stands. CN BBIers who went to the game weigh in on the crowd?
She's not back yet, but she was pretty stoked. (She went with her Commanders boy friend... so you can tell she was extra motivated too).
Ha! Better yet. At least he’s not a Cowboys or Eagles fan.
Great win. Too early to worry about draft pick position and it’s not like either Caleb or Drake have looked like world beaters. Daboll and team needed a W.
The Bears won’t take a QB. Giants will get one of the 3
Still so long to go, but Bears and Cardinals could stick with their guys. I definitely think the Cardinals do.
Schoen will have to maneuver the draft as needed. That's just the reality of the NFL. I don't care how shitty any team is, you can't go 2-15 on demand.
-Chiefs moved up for Mahomes
-Bills moved up for Allen
It'll be on Schoen to figure it out. But, I think the Jones train left the station if there was any doubt. The 3 passing TD's in a game stat is just unbelievable.
The Bears won’t take a QB. Giants will get one of the 3
Still so long to go, but Bears and Cardinals could stick with their guys. I definitely think the Cardinals do.
Even if the Bears keep Fields, they will get some nice offers for that #1 pick and that will be a team going for a QB. Will the Cards go for Harrison Jr if they sick with Murray? Or will they also trade back? As you said, a long way to go
Let's see if Devito can lead this team to a road playoff win.
Well, in only 2 games he’s got 1/3 of the passing TDs your boy Jones had last season so I’m guessing beating a historically bad defense like the Vikings isn’t impossible.
You literally hate everything. It is so freaking odd that you constantly defend a bad QB that has been heavily involved in one of the darkest periods of Giants football in its history. But again, nobody has ever accused you of being very bright
RE: Let's see if Devito can lead this team to a road playoff win.
Well, in only 2 games he’s got 1/3 of the passing TDs your boy Jones had last season so I’m guessing beating a historically bad defense like the Vikings isn’t impossible.
You literally hate everything. It is so freaking odd that you constantly defend a bad QB that has been heavily involved in one of the darkest periods of Giants football in its history. But again, nobody has ever accused you of being very bright
Okay, let's see Devito do it, then.
I wouldn't really accuse others of being "angry" or "not very bright", though.
Talk about a lack of self-awareness.
RE: RE: RE: Let's see if Devito can lead this team to a road playoff win.
Sure, but Jones gets most of it. He was the best player on the field that day.
Devito has Barkley. Let's see if he can do it.
This is why nobody takes you Jones fan boys seriously. Jones gets all the credit for the wins, as incredibly rare as they’ve been through this career, but when they lose it’s everyone else’s fault. Congratulations to Jones for playing a decent game against a laughable defense. Then got his fucking teeth kicked in the very next week. Once again in embarrassing fashion
RE: RE: RE: RE: Let's see if Devito can lead this team to a road playoff win.
Sure, but Jones gets most of it. He was the best player on the field that day.
Devito has Barkley. Let's see if he can do it.
This is why nobody takes you Jones fan boys seriously. Jones gets all the credit for the wins, as incredibly rare as they’ve been through this career, but when they lose it’s everyone else’s fault. Congratulations to Jones for playing a decent game against a laughable defense. Then got his fucking teeth kicked in the very next week. Once again in embarrassing fashion
I'm more then ready to move on from Jones. Again, with the anger and not being very bright. Now, the road playoff win means nothing, despite the fact that you and others weren't saying that in the offseason and the fact that it's only time this team has looked good in a decade.
RE: RE: RE: Let's see if Devito can lead this team to a road playoff win.
Well, in only 2 games he’s got 1/3 of the passing TDs your boy Jones had last season so I’m guessing beating a historically bad defense like the Vikings isn’t impossible.
You literally hate everything. It is so freaking odd that you constantly defend a bad QB that has been heavily involved in one of the darkest periods of Giants football in its history. But again, nobody has ever accused you of being very bright
Okay, let's see Devito do it, then.
I wouldn't really accuse others of being "angry" or "not very bright", though.
Talk about a lack of self-awareness.
It is amazing that one win against a terrible defense completely wipes away 5 years of mostly complete ineptitude in your mind. It’s almost as if you’re trolling. There’s nothing you don’t bitch about. But you draw the line at….Daniel Jones? Holy shit balls….
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
oh no no no. You Jonsers are not getting off that easy. Phil Simms / Eli Manning my ass.
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
You don’t have to read.
The narrative spun on here by the Jones supporters is “why draft a QB, nobody could perform behind this line”. Meanwhile an undrafted rookie did it while getting sacked 9 times.
but the Commanders looked like the team that was tanking. We got embaressed twice by Dallas come in not even limping but dragging broken legs and gave them a beating without playing the best game we could.
Everyone of their supporters were looking to pounce on us and get them back on track. Feels good to shut them up.
Glad Devito got to get 1, I would like to know how the game plan went because we looked so lost on so many plays and then then so well designed on others. was it a mix of old and new? Was it Devito specific scheme that was working or failing?
Deffensively there was an obvious messqge to punch the ball. Was that a rectuon to how Washington plays or was it brought up that if the Offense cant score the D needs to force things. Would love the D to be that ball crazy all the time!
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
You don’t have to read.
The narrative spun on here by the Jones supporters is “why draft a QB, nobody could perform behind this line”. Meanwhile an undrafted rookie did it while getting sacked 9 times.
How many games did Jones play behind this line, Thomas and Pugh with Barkley on the field. Be more accurate in your observations
… I will be willing the Giants win next week and every other of this season in order to piss off other Giants fans.
?????
I’d rather win out than lose out. What the hell does a high draft pick guarantee you anyway? Haven’t we seen enough 1st round busts to show that it really doesn’t mean much where you draft. You can find impact players all throughout the draft if your scouting is good or if you get lucky.
Also, how exactly do you expect the New York Giants to “tank?”
How do you expect the organization to intentionally lose? What is that method? What free agent will want to come here if he knows that a poor season will result in his benching so the team can lose? Do you expect John Mara to reach an agreement with Daboll that they lose out? Do you expect players to play under their ability for the greater good of the team?
Even if they lose out and draft high. What if the high draft selections are a bust? Do you go on and on tanking? Tanking is a ridiculous idea that only serves to disillusion your fan base, the current players on the roster and any future players who might consider coming here via free agency.
Winning is everything. You keep trying to win come what may and draft where ever you draft.
Let’s win next week and keep winning. 6 more games to go.
With Thomas and Barkley DeVito still got sacked NINE times. Yet was still able to throw for 3 TDs. Somehow he wasn’t Derek Carr’d
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
And the beat goes on!
Sorry all the excuse you guys have made have blown up this year. Tough day for you guys.
No you fool, the Giants won today and it's never a tough day when they win. It may be for some who have ridiculous agendas, but I care about the team winning. You are right I don't have to read and I didn't want to look at the posters before I read the posts, but to avoid you and you're ridiculous one trick pony campaign to bring Daniel Jones into every discussion I will now do that!
No you fool, the Giants won today and it's never a tough day when they win. It may be for some who have ridiculous agendas, but I care about the team winning. You are right I don't have to read and I didn't want to look at the posters before I read the posts, but to avoid you and you're ridiculous one trick pony campaign to bring Daniel Jones into every discussion I will now do that!
Maybe you don’t read since you don’t see all the other posts I make.
Daniel Jones’ name was mentioned nearly 40 times before I even posted on this thread by the way.
With Thomas and Barkley DeVito still got sacked NINE times. Yet was still able to throw for 3 TDs. Somehow he wasn’t Derek Carr’d
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
The Washington Commanders are currently dead last in the NFL in points allowed per game this season. They somehow trail a team that allowed 70 points earlier this season. Devito’s previous TD passes came with the team trailing by an average of 31 points.
Interestingly, the fewest points the Commanders allowed this season was to Tyrod Taylor and the Giants.
It’s over for Jones. It didn’t work out and we basically have one year left with him on the team. Shit happens.
They’re about 20 teams right now in the NFL who are stuck in limbo with QBs who will never be perennial winners. Unfortunately we are one of them. But this obsession on every thread saying the same thing is just weird whether you’re a Jones fan or not.
RE: RE: RE: RE: DeVito is definitely gonna get laid
The narrative spun on here by the Jones supporters is “why draft a QB, nobody could perform behind this line”. Meanwhile an undrafted rookie did it while getting sacked 9 times.
How many games did Jones play behind this line, Thomas and Pugh with Barkley on the field. Be more accurate in your observations
I am with this. Half or more of DeVito's sacks were on him pulling his "inner Jones" and holding the ball too long or running into it.
But I will give DeVito credit. He truly is improving week by week. While still many times holding the ball too long, he is also most times getting it out accurately and with pace to the open guy. I think he sees the field much better than Jones and will trust what he sees more each week, hence the ball will come out quicker meaning fewer sacks.
Worked out well last time, didn't it?
Maybe today....
Forget “roster evaluation “ or winning culture. The giants are bad and that starts at QB. We needed a top guy and today hurt our chances. Sucks
Game thread. 10/10. Pure nonsense.
Just glad they didn’t shut the bed. A little pride.
They did a hell of a job today. Only critique I have today is on the Run D, which kept giving up way too much ground in the middle.
Great win. Too early to worry about draft pick position and it’s not like either Caleb or Drake have looked like world beaters. Daboll and team needed a W.
Quote:
just won't let us have high draft picks
Worked out well last time, didn't it?
Down to 5th now, possibly as low as 12th if they beat the Pats (have to see how many of the 4 win teams play each other).
I know a lot of people on the board won't be happy with this, but with at least adequate play from QB, the Giants may go on a mini win streak. The Patriots are beatable if the defense plays well.
Haha. Yeah is Wink still getting fired in January?
I’ll tell you who should never sniff another DC job. Jack Del Rio. Woof.
How are 6 turnovers on the HC? Likely canned after Dallas game Thursday.
Quote:
we OK with the defense for one more week?
I know a lot of people on the board won't be happy with this, but with at least adequate play from QB, the Giants may go on a mini win streak. The Patriots are beatable if the defense plays well.
The Commanders dogged it today. Pats are coming off their bye. I see a loss next week.
My takeaway is DeVito throwing for 3 TD's, that hasn't happened since 2019 - incredible. This defense will feast on bad QB's.
Quote:
In comment 16295067 Giantsfan79 said:
Quote:
just won't let us have high draft picks
Worked out well last time, didn't it?
Down to 5th now, possibly as low as 12th if they beat the Pats (have to see how many of the 4 win teams play each other).
Can we say that they could eff up a wet dr#*m?
DeVito was decent. Some nice throws, but holds the ball way too long, which I guess is to be expected given his inexperience. The OL was putrid. No running game until the end. Bad play calling with passes that required deep drops.
Defense got gashed, especially when Lawrence was out. But it was opportunistic.
Didn’t you just say last week you were impressed with him?
The dude is terrible. We want Washington to keep him. Lol
YOU PLAY. TO WIN. THE GAME!!!
I don't like when my Giants lose, but they need to this season in order to improve this teams talent. Unfortunately, the Giants Org are special and somehow keep putting themselves in bad positions.
Yep. WSH goes to Dallas on Thanksgiving while the Giants host the Pats. Good chance the Giants are in 3rd next week.
Schoen better be prepared to trade up.
What I like about him and we saw it in preseason is even for an undrafted walk on he has the demeanor and attitude of someone who's been around for a while he doesn't look scared or have that deer in the headlights look or make panic throws
Exactly.. 100% I just feel this Org will screw this up too.. smh
Yikes…
My takeaway is DeVito throwing for 3 TD's, that hasn't happened since 2019 - incredible. This defense will feast on bad QB's.
Schoen picking up that 2nd and a 5th for Leo will open up flexibility to either us it to trade up or take the next tier guy. We are going to take a QB just a question of whom and when.
It is what it is. There’s some ER and WR talent we desperately could use. And can’t rule out an OT like Alt.
Fuck that lol
Quote:
to win, but I also don't want Washington moving ahead of us for the QB.
Yep. WSH goes to Dallas on Thanksgiving while the Giants host the Pats. Good chance the Giants are in 3rd next week.
Schoen better be prepared to trade up.
There will be better QBs in the later 1st or 2nd round than Jones..even if it is Bo Nix.
Things happen for a reason. Trust the process!
Problem is there are teams currently in front of us who aren’t trading out of those picks for any package.
Sy has gotten me on the Jayden Daniels bandwagon, but beyond that it begins to look like variations of Sam Howell.
Quote:
to win, but I also don't want Washington moving ahead of us for the QB.
Didn’t you just say last week you were impressed with him?
The dude is terrible. We want Washington to keep him. Lol
Howell's worst two games in the past 5-6 weeks were against the Giants. He's been pretty darn good otherwise. Pay attention.
Quote:
In comment 16295124 Eric from BBI said:
Quote:
to win, but I also don't want Washington moving ahead of us for the QB.
Didn’t you just say last week you were impressed with him?
The dude is terrible. We want Washington to keep him. Lol
Howell's worst two games in the past 5-6 weeks were against the Giants. He's been pretty darn good otherwise. Pay attention.
Is it Howell, or is it Rivera who doesn't seem able to beat the Giants.
Quote:
In comment 16295124 Eric from BBI said:
Quote:
to win, but I also don't want Washington moving ahead of us for the QB.
Didn’t you just say last week you were impressed with him?
The dude is terrible. We want Washington to keep him. Lol
Howell's worst two games in the past 5-6 weeks were against the Giants. He's been pretty darn good otherwise. Pay attention.
You’re correct, but he’s so bad against the Giants that it’s difficult to believe that he’d be good against anyone.
I don’t think he was getting fired at all. The effort was more the issue than the results.
Yep, think of the QBs in the division if Washington gets Williams, Maye or Daniels.
It's important to see the team not quitting on the coach.
By next Sunday night they will be
+1
Panthers v Titans
Cardinals v Rams
Not one of the top 3 anyway.
Panthers v Titans
Cardinals v Rams
*THIS*
Quote:
next year? If so this win does not really feel good.
Not one of the top 3 anyway.
Are you going to just keep doing this incessantly? We aren’t going to forfeit games, what are you expecting here? And other teams will play and win games too, you have no idea where we will be picking.
Oh and trades happen to move up in drafts, not sure if you knew that but now you do.
Panthers v Titans
Cardinals v Rams
I’m confident in a loss to the Pats.
Our ownership of the Commanders was just too strong of a force to be denied.
Quote:
next year? If so this win does not really feel good.
Not one of the top 3 anyway.
We're going to be stuck w Daniel Jones them . I am sure Mara is happry because he didn't want to draft a QB anyway and, this is the perfect excuse to run it back againw Daniel jones who throws for less yards than Danny devito.
Oddest thing. He cooks the Eagles every time and doesn’t seem to make much of a difference against the Giants, even when his numbers aren’t bad.
Agreed. The Bears got their QB back today too.
Is it Howell, or is it Rivera who doesn't seem able to beat the Giants.
We are 15-6-1 in the past decade. 32-15-1 since 2000. They just struggle against us like we do against the eagles
Quote:
Patriots v Giants
Panthers v Titans
Cardinals v Rams
I’m confident in a loss to the Pats.
Our ownership of the Commanders was just too strong of a force to be denied.
As am I. Belichick defense with 2 weeks to prepare. Mac Jones might legit be playing for his NFL life also.
And as nice as this felt I can see a let down game from DeVito and the defense both.
Charlotte Carroll
@charlottecrrll
·
6m
Breaking lol: #giants locker room has no water for showers
People said that when we “lost out” on Chase Young.
Charlotte Carroll
@charlottecrrll
·
6m
Breaking lol: #giants locker room has no water for showers
LMAO!
Also the most accurate pass thrown by someone in a Commander’s uniform today.
Quote:
.
People said that when we “lost out” on Chase Young.
People say dumb shit all the time. You are comparing Apples to Oranges.
People think Daniel Jones will wina SB like Eli did even though we;re already past that point. People think Daniel Jones wil right the ship like Phil Simms did -- we are past that point also.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
We are 1 win away from possibly picking as low as 14th!
What did you expect? That they would lose their las 7 games! That s on you not the team. These guys showed today they haven’t stopped competing.
This is what happens when you begin depending on losses with 40’some % of a season left.
Don’t be mad at the team
Or Cleveland, or the Lions
Quote:
.
People said that when we “lost out” on Chase Young.
Haha, said that earlier in the other thread.
What if the NYG fell out of the top 3-4 and ended up with a stud like the TE Bowers? Sure he’s not as impactful as a top QB but he might be the closest thing to 89 as ever entered the draft. He’d look great in Blue .
Trade up with future picks and the 2’s if a QB is a must but don’t ever turn down a top talent, no matter the position. You can never have enough really good players.
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
You know you go on with your weird hard-on for the Jets I have better things to do. I am sorry that there are some really obnoxious Jets fans in your particular area ; I know some that I consider to be decent people. And that 3rd string rookie does not look that much different than our overdrafted, overpaid #6 overall draft pick.
Quote:
In comment 16295298 Arcade_Games said:
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
You know you go on with your weird hard-on for the Jets I have better things to do. I am sorry that there are some really obnoxious Jets fans in your particular area ; I know some that I consider to be decent people. And that 3rd string rookie does not look that much different than our overdrafted, overpaid #6 overall draft pick.
Exactly, and they had them beat with a 3rd string rookie QB. Says it all, really.
TDFC scrambled and got caught, not sacked/drilled/annihilated, for many of them.
So, good?
is way, way too precious.
Hey, here's an idea: celebrate the win.
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
Quote:
In comment 16295298 Arcade_Games said:
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
It's definitely a dream for Daniel Jones.
Exactly, and they had them beat with a 3rd string rookie QB. Says it all, really.
The fact that DEvito just threw over 250 yards and 3 TDs against the Redskins -- same as Daniel jones does -- which is like the only time Jones ever does throw for 250+ yards and more than 1 TD a game -- should tell you all you need to know about your woulda coulda arguments.;
Quote:
In comment 16295302 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
In comment 16295298 Arcade_Games said:
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
The Giants really need to draft some o lineman. Besides, Thomas Neal Schmidts Mekethan Peart Edzudu they haven’t drafted anyone.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
I would laugh my ass off at this comment in April when the Giants draft a QB but I won't remember who wrote it nor will you joke about how wrong you were.
TDFC scrambled and got caught, not sacked/drilled/annihilated, for many of them.
So, good?
are we just typing DJFC to mean anything now?
is way, way too precious.
Hey, here's an idea: celebrate the win.
Hello? Exactly!!!
The Giants really need to draft some o lineman. Besides, Thomas Neal Schmidts Mekethan Peart Edzudu they haven’t drafted anyone.
Oh you are trying to be cute now. Then sign some free agent fucking lineman then.
Tyrod Taylor already showed you that passing behind this line is highly possible. His only problem is getting hurt when running with the football.
Quote:
In comment 16295302 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
In comment 16295298 Arcade_Games said:
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
Here is a concept: draft a QB and draft some O line players as well! Wow mind blowing stuff right there!
The Giants have 3 QBs and all 3 would be serviceable to above average behind a decent Oline. If you do draft a QB do it in the second round.
The Giants have 3 QBs and all 3 would be serviceable to above average behind a decent Oline. If you do draft a QB do it in the second round.
The hell are you talking about?
Daniel Jones is a BELOW AVG. QB.
Tyrod is a journeyman back-up.
DEvito is an undrafted free agent who is a rookie at lie age 25. Who so far is the only real question mark at what we have in a QB. WTF is the point of drafting a QB at all then unless someone like Levis slips late. You might as well play Daniel jones then in week 3 when he is ready then and let him play here for 3 years.
Quote:
damage. Gotta think DJFC would have taken at least 1 severe blow.
TDFC scrambled and got caught, not sacked/drilled/annihilated, for many of them.
So, good?
are we just typing DJFC to mean anything now?
In a word, yes.
im wuth ya on this...why all the hate towards Wink and our D?
IMHO, using it should be a two week suspension. It is only used to stir up animosity and get under peoples' skins.
All kidding aside, he's a better passer than the backup QB,
and he was running for his life most of the game. They had five sacks in the first quarter alone, he hung in there, give him credit.
NYG or WSH? LOL
160 yds 0 TD 0 Int
200 yds 1 TD 0 Int in 5Q
2021
249 yds 1 TD 0 int
2020
112 yds 1 TD 1 int
212 yds 1 TD 0 int
2019
352 yds 5 TD 0 int in 5Q
225 yds 1 TD 2 int
Jones is 5-1-1 in his career vs. Washington. Jones' record against the rest of the NFL: 17-34
What exactly does that mean anymore? Are BPAs less risky than need picks?
Let me answer for you - no.
If the BPA approach was such a good system, more teams would have better drafts. But they don't because drafting is hard.
It's kinda like the Yanks vs. the Twins, okay back to the late games now...more talk tom.
All kidding aside, he's a better passer than the backup QB,
Might be a bit strong. There were plenty of explosive plays when Tyrod was in there.
I really like Maye as well.
Quote:
All kidding aside, he's a better passer than the backup QB,
Might be a bit strong. There were plenty of explosive plays when Tyrod was in there.
Not really, I felt that way in the preseason. Taylor is not very accurate. This kid throws a nice ball with time to throw. I rather see DeVito finish the season out.
The Giants might win another few games, which if doing so, means we don't get Williams, Maye, or Daniels will make many here furious. I won't be one of them. I root for the Giants to win every game.
The Giants might win another few games, which if doing so, means we don't get Williams, Maye, or Daniels will make many here furious. I won't be one of them. I root for the Giants to win every game.
Exactly. Try to win every game like you're supposed to do as a professional with any sense of pride and then let the chips fall where they may with the draft months later
We keep hearing Daboll's coming back. I'd like to see evidence that's a good idea.
Quote:
In comment 16295399 Carson53 said:
Quote:
All kidding aside, he's a better passer than the backup QB,
Might be a bit strong. There were plenty of explosive plays when Tyrod was in there.
.
Taylor is not very accurate.
This is an "eye test" thing. He completed 65% of his passes this year.
Last time he was a full-time starter (2017) he completed 63%. Accuracy's one of his strengths.
We keep hearing Daboll's coming back. I'd like to see evidence that's a good idea.
The Patriot and Packer games are winnable
Lot of season left. They were gifted 6 turnovers. Hard to lose.
I want Maye and feel we need to be in the top 2 in order to get him but you need to let the season play out and see where you end up.
Thinking back to 2004, we were drafting 4th and then we’re still able to get the QB they wanted.
It may cost draft picks but that is how it works. I can see Chicago trading back with one of their picks.
Enjoy this win.
Quote:
Seriously, though, we're still fine. I don't see us falling too far back by the end of the season. We should still be in play for Daniels or McCarthy and possibly still even have a shot at Maye.
Lot of season left. They were gifted 6 turnovers. Hard to lose.
Did we turn the ball over?
Had a team ever with a +6 ever lost.....but we were in position to do so. Keep that in mind.
She's not back yet, but she was pretty stoked. (She went with her Commanders boy friend... so you can tell she was extra motivated too).
Does he live with his Mom or his Stepmom?
Dnew15 : 4:11 pm : link : reply
Worst BBI post ever -- and that's saying a lot.
What happened?
Charlotte Carroll
@charlottecrrll
·
6m
Breaking lol: #giants locker room has no water for showers
Quote:
in this parent's basement tonight!!
Does he live with his Mom or his Stepmom?
Should be with Zach Wilson's mom's friend
Quote:
In comment 16295302 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
In comment 16295298 Arcade_Games said:
Quote:
In comment 16295277 bc4life said:
Quote:
Glad to see that they are still competing.
We should have beat Bills & Jets. So, Giants should be at at least 5 wins. The draft is the draft. If they fall out of position to get the guy they want, there are plenty of other holes to fill.
Keep in mind, if they get anything other than 1st 2 picks, any team could trade up and grab their guy.
I am so sick of reading this stuff.
A. The Giants should nto be a 5 win team. They should NOT have beat the Jets or the Bills. They are better teams than the Gaints.
B. This is a rare opportunity to get out from Daniel Jone and that horrible contract of which wh'll be stuck with permanaent medicrity. An undrafted free agent just threw for over 250 yards and 3 TDs vs the Washington Commanders like Daniel jones usually does. If that was Daniel jones there would be posters here anoointing this guy a top QB in the NFL.
They absolutely should have beat the Jets. They almost did with a 3rd string rookie QB.
The Giants aren’t picking a QB in the draft considering the state of their O line.
The Gaints are not picking one because Mara loves Daniel jones like a son -- despite not being a good QB.
!
THIS!!
Quote:
Charlotte Carroll
@charlottecrrll
·
6m
Breaking lol: #giants locker room has no water for showers
Quote:
In comment 16295432 SirLoinOfBeef said:
Quote:
in this parent's basement tonight!!
Does he live with his Mom or his Stepmom?
Should be with Zach Wilson's mom's friend
You hope for a win, but are not disappointed if they lose unless it is on some glaringly bonehead call.
Quote:
Glad she got to see a win after making the effort to go to the game! At home on TV, it sounded like at least half a Giants crowd in the stands. CN BBIers who went to the game weigh in on the crowd?
She's not back yet, but she was pretty stoked. (She went with her Commanders boy friend... so you can tell she was extra motivated too).
Ha! Better yet. At least he’s not a Cowboys or Eagles fan.
Quote:
.
Great win. Too early to worry about draft pick position and it’s not like either Caleb or Drake have looked like world beaters. Daboll and team needed a W.
Agree.
That was a weird game.
Still so long to go, but Bears and Cardinals could stick with their guys. I definitely think the Cardinals do.
Schoen will have to maneuver the draft as needed. That's just the reality of the NFL. I don't care how shitty any team is, you can't go 2-15 on demand.
-Chiefs moved up for Mahomes
-Bills moved up for Allen
It'll be on Schoen to figure it out. But, I think the Jones train left the station if there was any doubt. The 3 passing TD's in a game stat is just unbelievable.
Quote:
The Bears won’t take a QB. Giants will get one of the 3
Still so long to go, but Bears and Cardinals could stick with their guys. I definitely think the Cardinals do.
Even if the Bears keep Fields, they will get some nice offers for that #1 pick and that will be a team going for a QB. Will the Cards go for Harrison Jr if they sick with Murray? Or will they also trade back? As you said, a long way to go
Well, in only 2 games he’s got 1/3 of the passing TDs your boy Jones had last season so I’m guessing beating a historically bad defense like the Vikings isn’t impossible.
You literally hate everything. It is so freaking odd that you constantly defend a bad QB that has been heavily involved in one of the darkest periods of Giants football in its history. But again, nobody has ever accused you of being very bright
Barkley gets no credit for that win?
Quote:
Oh, wait.
Barkley gets no credit for that win?
Sure, but Jones gets most of it. He was the best player on the field that day.
Devito has Barkley. Let's see if he can do it.
Quote:
Oh, wait.
Well, in only 2 games he’s got 1/3 of the passing TDs your boy Jones had last season so I’m guessing beating a historically bad defense like the Vikings isn’t impossible.
You literally hate everything. It is so freaking odd that you constantly defend a bad QB that has been heavily involved in one of the darkest periods of Giants football in its history. But again, nobody has ever accused you of being very bright
Okay, let's see Devito do it, then.
I wouldn't really accuse others of being "angry" or "not very bright", though.
Talk about a lack of self-awareness.
Quote:
In comment 16295784 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
Oh, wait.
Barkley gets no credit for that win?
Sure, but Jones gets most of it. He was the best player on the field that day.
Devito has Barkley. Let's see if he can do it.
This is why nobody takes you Jones fan boys seriously. Jones gets all the credit for the wins, as incredibly rare as they’ve been through this career, but when they lose it’s everyone else’s fault. Congratulations to Jones for playing a decent game against a laughable defense. Then got his fucking teeth kicked in the very next week. Once again in embarrassing fashion
Quote:
In comment 16295804 Sean said:
Quote:
In comment 16295784 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
Oh, wait.
Barkley gets no credit for that win?
Sure, but Jones gets most of it. He was the best player on the field that day.
Devito has Barkley. Let's see if he can do it.
This is why nobody takes you Jones fan boys seriously. Jones gets all the credit for the wins, as incredibly rare as they’ve been through this career, but when they lose it’s everyone else’s fault. Congratulations to Jones for playing a decent game against a laughable defense. Then got his fucking teeth kicked in the very next week. Once again in embarrassing fashion
I'm more then ready to move on from Jones. Again, with the anger and not being very bright. Now, the road playoff win means nothing, despite the fact that you and others weren't saying that in the offseason and the fact that it's only time this team has looked good in a decade.
Quote:
In comment 16295784 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
Oh, wait.
Well, in only 2 games he’s got 1/3 of the passing TDs your boy Jones had last season so I’m guessing beating a historically bad defense like the Vikings isn’t impossible.
You literally hate everything. It is so freaking odd that you constantly defend a bad QB that has been heavily involved in one of the darkest periods of Giants football in its history. But again, nobody has ever accused you of being very bright
Okay, let's see Devito do it, then.
I wouldn't really accuse others of being "angry" or "not very bright", though.
Talk about a lack of self-awareness.
It is amazing that one win against a terrible defense completely wipes away 5 years of mostly complete ineptitude in your mind. It’s almost as if you’re trolling. There’s nothing you don’t bitch about. But you draw the line at….Daniel Jones? Holy shit balls….
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
Quote:
On Jones. First 3 td game in 4 years is wild
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
oh no no no. You Jonsers are not getting off that easy. Phil Simms / Eli Manning my ass.
Quote:
On Jones. First 3 td game in 4 years is wild
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
You don’t have to read.
The narrative spun on here by the Jones supporters is “why draft a QB, nobody could perform behind this line”. Meanwhile an undrafted rookie did it while getting sacked 9 times.
Everyone of their supporters were looking to pounce on us and get them back on track. Feels good to shut them up.
Glad Devito got to get 1, I would like to know how the game plan went because we looked so lost on so many plays and then then so well designed on others. was it a mix of old and new? Was it Devito specific scheme that was working or failing?
Deffensively there was an obvious messqge to punch the ball. Was that a rectuon to how Washington plays or was it brought up that if the Offense cant score the D needs to force things. Would love the D to be that ball crazy all the time!
Quote:
In comment 16295778 ajr2456 said:
Quote:
On Jones. First 3 td game in 4 years is wild
10 years from now are you stil going to be
taking every chance you get to denigrate Daniel Jones. The Giants won, Jones is out for the year, give it a rest, please!
You don’t have to read.
The narrative spun on here by the Jones supporters is “why draft a QB, nobody could perform behind this line”. Meanwhile an undrafted rookie did it while getting sacked 9 times.
How many games did Jones play behind this line, Thomas and Pugh with Barkley on the field. Be more accurate in your observations
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
And the beat goes on!
Quote:
With Thomas and Barkley DeVito still got sacked NINE times. Yet was still able to throw for 3 TDs. Somehow he wasn’t Derek Carr’d
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
And the beat goes on!
Sorry all the excuse you guys have made have blown up this year. Tough day for you guys.
?????
I’d rather win out than lose out. What the hell does a high draft pick guarantee you anyway? Haven’t we seen enough 1st round busts to show that it really doesn’t mean much where you draft. You can find impact players all throughout the draft if your scouting is good or if you get lucky.
Also, how exactly do you expect the New York Giants to “tank?”
How do you expect the organization to intentionally lose? What is that method? What free agent will want to come here if he knows that a poor season will result in his benching so the team can lose? Do you expect John Mara to reach an agreement with Daboll that they lose out? Do you expect players to play under their ability for the greater good of the team?
Even if they lose out and draft high. What if the high draft selections are a bust? Do you go on and on tanking? Tanking is a ridiculous idea that only serves to disillusion your fan base, the current players on the roster and any future players who might consider coming here via free agency.
Winning is everything. You keep trying to win come what may and draft where ever you draft.
Let’s win next week and keep winning. 6 more games to go.
Quote:
In comment 16296015 ajr2456 said:
Quote:
With Thomas and Barkley DeVito still got sacked NINE times. Yet was still able to throw for 3 TDs. Somehow he wasn’t Derek Carr’d
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
And the beat goes on!
Sorry all the excuse you guys have made have blown up this year. Tough day for you guys.
No you fool, the Giants won today and it's never a tough day when they win. It may be for some who have ridiculous agendas, but I care about the team winning. You are right I don't have to read and I didn't want to look at the posters before I read the posts, but to avoid you and you're ridiculous one trick pony campaign to bring Daniel Jones into every discussion I will now do that!
No you fool, the Giants won today and it's never a tough day when they win. It may be for some who have ridiculous agendas, but I care about the team winning. You are right I don't have to read and I didn't want to look at the posters before I read the posts, but to avoid you and you're ridiculous one trick pony campaign to bring Daniel Jones into every discussion I will now do that!
Maybe you don’t read since you don’t see all the other posts I make.
Daniel Jones’ name was mentioned nearly 40 times before I even posted on this thread by the way.
He has a third of the passing TDs Jones had all of last in two starts with the same line.
Is that clearer for you?
The Washington Commanders are currently dead last in the NFL in points allowed per game this season. They somehow trail a team that allowed 70 points earlier this season. Devito’s previous TD passes came with the team trailing by an average of 31 points.
Interestingly, the fewest points the Commanders allowed this season was to Tyrod Taylor and the Giants.
It’s both sides. It’s just crazy at this point.
It’s over for Jones. It didn’t work out and we basically have one year left with him on the team. Shit happens.
They’re about 20 teams right now in the NFL who are stuck in limbo with QBs who will never be perennial winners. Unfortunately we are one of them. But this obsession on every thread saying the same thing is just weird whether you’re a Jones fan or not.
Quote:
In comment 16295544 cjac said:
Quote:
In comment 16295432 SirLoinOfBeef said:
Quote:
in this parent's basement tonight!!
Does he live with his Mom or his Stepmom?
Should be with Zach Wilson's mom's friend
haha! But isn’t Zach Wilson’s mom’s friend like 26 years old!
Thought she is 42ish. Best kind for young guy....
The narrative spun on here by the Jones supporters is “why draft a QB, nobody could perform behind this line”. Meanwhile an undrafted rookie did it while getting sacked 9 times.
How many games did Jones play behind this line, Thomas and Pugh with Barkley on the field. Be more accurate in your observations
I am with this. Half or more of DeVito's sacks were on him pulling his "inner Jones" and holding the ball too long or running into it.
But I will give DeVito credit. He truly is improving week by week. While still many times holding the ball too long, he is also most times getting it out accurately and with pace to the open guy. I think he sees the field much better than Jones and will trust what he sees more each week, hence the ball will come out quicker meaning fewer sacks.