I've wondered if Eli being the iron man actually accelerated his decline. The dude was tough as hell and played through a lot of stuff. That adds up fast.
We've spent a lot of time in the "honeymoon period" with coaches and GM's. During that you're concentrating more on what they do good vs what they do bad. You're also looking through things in a more hopeful light.
I still think you really need 3 full years to evaluate a coach or GM unless they really screw up like Judge's famous rant or back to back QB sneaks.
had money in his pocket and gambled on basketball on grass vision.. In northeast. should have been fired on the spot.. Wasted prime yrs of a SuperBowl Champion QB and Coach.
Eli had "great years" 2014-2016. Most of that though, was OBJ.
Because other good QBs are allowed to have good WRs and no one says anything but Eli is only good if he can do it without decent WR talent. Never got that.
go back to 05 and see how many here hated Eli Manning, Coughlin and Accorsi, and 05 was a good year.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
go back to 05 and see how many here hated Eli Manning, Coughlin and Accorsi, and 05 was a good year.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
We didn’t have to wait. We’ve always known you were an evil monster.
RE: I said it at the time and I ll say it again. What ruined Eli
be worse to go back and read threads at how well Gettleman was doing.
Ah the good ol' days of having someone throw personal insults at anyone who didn't understand the brilliance of Dave Gettleman! Thank the Good Lord most of those clowns have moved on.
go back to 05 and see how many here hated Eli Manning, Coughlin and Accorsi, and 05 was a good year.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
We didn’t have to wait. We’ve always known you were an evil monster.
go back to 05 and see how many here hated Eli Manning, Coughlin and Accorsi, and 05 was a good year.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
I'd rather demand excellence than be encouraged by occasional mediocrity.
I've wondered if Eli being the iron man actually accelerated his decline. The dude was tough as hell and played through a lot of stuff. That adds up fast.
Statistically yes. Eye test - meh
I still think you really need 3 full years to evaluate a coach or GM unless they really screw up like Judge's famous rant or back to back QB sneaks.
Fixed it for ya 😉
They did run the ball much better in 2012 but the really good running team of years past was gone and the skill group of 2011 was long gone imv.
Because other good QBs are allowed to have good WRs and no one says anything but Eli is only good if he can do it without decent WR talent. Never got that.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
We didn’t have to wait. We’ve always known you were an evil monster.
100%.
Reese put the franchise into the great destruction of the LOS. OL bottomed out in 2013 and the DL followed in 2014.
The Giants still are not fixed on both sides ten years later.
Ah the good ol' days of having someone throw personal insults at anyone who didn't understand the brilliance of Dave Gettleman! Thank the Good Lord most of those clowns have moved on.
Quote:
go back to 05 and see how many here hated Eli Manning, Coughlin and Accorsi, and 05 was a good year.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
We didn’t have to wait. We’ve always known you were an evil monster.
Ty, I think.
If you're a negative NYG fan, you've been validated the last 10 years or so, save for 2016 and 2022. If you're an optimist, you've been exposed as the evil monster you truly are.
I'd rather demand excellence than be encouraged by occasional mediocrity.