for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

I think Penix should be the target

Jim in Forest Hills : 2/21/2024 10:02 am
Open to Daniels/Maye at 6 if they drop but assuming the top 3 QBs are taken, Penix at 6 or a trade down/up as needed. I'm no scout but he just looks like he's a dominant passer who will put points on the board. He can shuffle around to avoid pressure well enough but he gets the ball out quick (Jones biggest weakness). His upside looks through the roof.

I've heard Tua comps but to me I see more Herbert than Tua. I think Penix can really stress defenses with his arm and willingness to trust it.

If they are willing to risk it based on intel, a small trade down?

I know there are a million opinions out there but watching the top QBs he's the guy I think can drive peak offense.

Take Penix and let the best man win between him and Jones in camp (if Jones is ready).
Pages: 1 2 3 <<Prev | Show All |
Lets be honest here.  
Gusto1903 : 2/22/2024 9:49 am : link
While i can see the top 3 picks surely being QBs, i cant for the love of god see a scenario, where one of the top 3 QBs drops outside of the Top 4 or at the very least 5.

The worst thing, that happened for my conclusion is, that the Cardinals are at 4. They dont necessarily need a QB and therefore are a sure target for other teams to trade down and open a spot for the QB that drops out of the Top 3. (or even JJ Mccarthy, who knows). There are teams not so far away, that will look to draft a qb in this draft. Im looking at the Vikings, the Broncos, the Raiders, the Saints, the Seahawks, heck even the Falcons i can see either trading up for a QB. They could probably offer the best package aswell, but i think they will look at a vet qb instead).

If the Cardinals for some reason pass on trading away from 4 if theres a QB left, and even select another non-qb, i can see the Chargers trade down with said teams, as they have Herbert. Of course they can just pick the guy they need instead, but i dont think itll be a QB.

The Chargers probably get their guy later in the draft aswell, so.

I see close to no chance at drafting a popular QB at 6, like at all.

So we either trade up (which im not a fan of) or we pick another stud at 6. Preferably one of those WRs
Big fan of Penix  
Formerly TD : 2/22/2024 12:17 pm : link
Would be happy with him if it came to that. We need to fix RT asap if we draft him, though. He would be starting by midseason and we can’t have Neal protecting his blind side.
Penix can sling it  
Giantophile : 2/22/2024 2:10 pm : link
as well as anyone I've seen coming out in a long time. Don't want him at 6 but I'm surprised no one has been pitching the Burrow/Chase formula of taking the WR and QB and pairing them together at the next level.

Rome at 6, trade back into mid first or sit tight in 2nd and take Penix.
Currently who do the Giants have at QB?  
Fishmanjim57 : 2/23/2024 10:31 am : link
Daniel Jones (5 year veteran who is constantly injured)
Tyrod Taylor ( 13 year veteran who is constantly injured)
Tommy DeVito (1 year undrafted QB, who was injured in his rookie season)

Do the Giants need to continue with a drafted QB. who has been injured throughout his college career?
Absolutely not! Avoid Penix!!
Pages: 1 2 3 <<Prev | Show All |
Back to the Corner