Draft a month away - who is the first round pick?

Who do I think it'll be? Odunze.

Maye.

Nabers

trade back up for Penix

.

In comment 16445824 Ron Johnson said:

Quote:

trade back up for Penix

oops I didn't read the post


change it to Nabers

JJ

.

.

Odunze or Nabers - I’ll go Nabers

I think there’s a run on QBs and giants take an elite receiver. I’ve changed my opinion and now rank Nabers above odunze

Odunze

.

Been my gut feeling all along.

.

.

.

and not trading away top 3 picks, any year.

I hope its WR - no matter who. I can live with Nabors/Odunze over 4th or 5th QB (that they say were targeting at #3 - yea right).

.

Nothing other than a gut feeling.

How? I don't know, just a feeling. I'm hoping we don't have to spend too much draft capital, but my gut feeling is JJM will be a NY Giant.

First time I watched him last year I thought he looked like a New York Giant. As the season went on I prayed he'd be a New York Giant. Add it him being mentored by Eli makes me think even more he's going to be a NY Giant.

Odunze!

..

Brian Thomas, Jr.

Odunze.

Nabers is the pick and even though 4 QBs will already be gone people will still complain they should have took a QB.

At 5 or 6.
If we get outbid for Qbs then Odunze. I think that Nabors is off the Giants board for off the field issues. I know this has been discussed before on this board and not going to rehash.

and trade up for Penix

In comment 16445880 bw in dc said:

Quote:

Brian Thomas, Jr.

What is your logic here for taking a WR, but not one of the 3 blue chips expected to be available at 6?

Are we trading down or is Schoen just going to overthink it?

In a trade down for two #1. Hoping then for stud 3-4 DE, WR, TE, Rb, DE, NT.

.

maybe this is just draft season bs but it feels like he's going to end up QB4.

i also think mhj/odunze are off the board by #6.

At 6!

no question.

.

..

If we don’t trade up and top-4 QBs are gone, please give me Nabers. Elite WR are getting expensive and we need a weapon on offense for Drew Lock to throw to…….

Maye or JJM

Giants trade 6, 70, and 2025 round one to Arizona and draft Maye.

unless something catastrophic happens.

But hoping it is Maye.

Mara acted far too giddy about potentially drafting a QB to compete with Jones. Jones is basically his son so I call bullshit.

In comment 16445968 christian said:

Quote:

Giants trade 6, 70, and 2025 round one to Arizona and draft Maye.

& if Drake is a stud, no one-outside of Jack Stroud-will GAF.

In comment 16446002 SFGFNCGiantsFan said:

Quote:

In comment 16445968 christian said: Quote: Giants trade 6, 70, and 2025 round one to Arizona and draft Maye. & if Drake is a stud, no one-outside of Jack Stroud-will GAF.

Eightshamrocks would like a word. Carl in CT is waiting as well…

In comment 16445886 Chris684 said:

Quote:

In comment 16445880 bw in dc said: Quote: Brian Thomas, Jr. What is your logic here for taking a WR, but not one of the 3 blue chips expected to be available at 6? Are we trading down or is Schoen just going to overthink it?

I believe BTJR is the best WR in this draft. Tremendous upside. Thus, it's a big four WR class, not big three.

So, admittedly, my personal bias is creeping in here and I am hoping Schoen sees the same thing I do - if we go WR.

And if we don't go QB, I actually hope we go OL and get the WR later due to this year being a bumper crop for WRs.

..

Or JJ

Rome Odunze, WR

JJM
Odunze
Nabers
Maye

in that order.

However, the order of my preference is...
Maye
JJM
Nabers
Odunze

At #5 after trade with Chargers.

Then trade up later and get Penix 😀

In comment 16445857 stoneman said:

Quote:

and not trading away top 3 picks, any year. I hope its WR - no matter who. I can live with Nabors/Odunze over 4th or 5th QB (that they say were targeting at #3 - yea right).

You seem to be assuming that the 4th QB taken will be trash or not worthy of pick 6.

This is supposedly a very strong QB draft and based on history, the 4th QB could end up being the best or at least as good as 1 or 2.

It's not unusual for the top 1 or 2 QBs not being the 1st or 2nd drafted. Ex. the 2 best of 2018 were the 3rd and 5th taken.

JJM or Maye could be the 4th taken and end up with the best or comparable career. Only God knows right now.

is my guess

Draft goes:

1) Chi - Williams
2) Wash - Daniels
3) NE - Maye
4) Minn (trade) - McCarthy
5) SD - MHJ
6) NYG - Odunze

Some people aren’t getting the question(I’m doing it now too) he said just a name no explanations

...

just to watch this place burn.

Malik Nabers at 6

.

Maybe twice. And then the BPA.

In comment 16446598 hyadoin said:

Quote:

Maybe twice. And then the BPA.

THIS

Like it's Maye.

In comment 16446446 djm said:

Quote:

just to watch this place burn.

I think everyone here knows you don't want a qb, so there's more to that hope than just wanting to watch this place burn. I BBI would go more ballistic about trading up for JJM than taking a blue chip receiver at 6.

Quarterback U.

#4

In comment 16446446 djm said:

Quote:

just to watch this place burn.

If it results in Penix or Nix in round 2 I'd be thrilled.

at 4.

The best fit on this team IMO.

..

I believe it goes: Williams, JD, JJ, MHJ, Odunze.
Minn doesn't trade up because because JJ is gone, so it's a choice between Maye and Nabers. QB wins.

Odunze. Trade up for a QB won’t work. Too costly. Take the best QB on the board in Rd 2 (Nix, Penix, Rattler).

Chargers pick Alt.

.

In comment 16446446 djm said:

Quote:

just to watch this place burn.

Symbolic because we’d be burning another season.

.

.

QB’s picked before number 6