And I wanted Rome… honestly have to stay put and see who falls to us. Williams - Daniels - Maye - jj - mhj - nabers and Rome we will have our choice at 2 of them.
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
Those are 3 guys I'd be targeting in rd2 or via tradeup if we go QB rd1.
I am with you.
QB in round 1
WR in round 2.
Take advantage of both the reality of being in position to get a QB in a talented QB draft and take advantage of the massive depth of the WR position.
Yeah if we teade up, which I think we will, I hope we keep our picks this year like EA did with the rd2 pick for Eli. He got Chris Snee with that pick. If we could hit on QB and trade up for a potential #1wr then we are in business and that future 1st won't be so high imo. Best case scenario imo is we get JJM at pick 4 by trading up twice with LAC and AZ (letting both teams know the deal), LAC get a future 3rd AZ gets a future 2nd and they both get their top choices. Otherwise a direct tradeup with AZ would likely be for our 2025 1st. Then again, if they really feel conviction in Maye then go ahead and trade up but it would be hard to keep our 2nd this year in that scenario imo.
QB is the only position where need trumps BPA (within reason - I'm not taking a Penix or Nix over the WR).
There may/should be decent WR options available in round 2. In addition, good WRs are available in the 1st round of every draft. When you have a chance to take a QB you like, you do it. Good WRs are *much* easier to come by than potential franchise QBs.
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
I would use #6 to get our QB and save #47 for WR. I would even trade up from 47 if we feel one of the WRs we like might not make it to 47.
Eyeing Franklin, Mitchell, Leggett and Coleman at 47 - would package my 2/3 to move up in round 2 or into round 1 if I see a run on WRs in the 20s or 30s.
Big deal. Can he play pro football? We've seen many WRs come out of college with great numbers and great stats (and some even drafted by the Giants) who, for one reason or another, cant really play the pro game. I'd be more interested in hearing how their interviews go, what their character is like, and how confident the decision makers are that they aren't drafting another Toney e.g.
Big deal. Can he play pro football? We've seen many WRs come out of college with great numbers and great stats (and some even drafted by the Giants) who, for one reason or another, cant really play the pro game. I'd be more interested in hearing how their interviews go, what their character is like, and how confident the decision makers are that they aren't drafting another Toney e.g.
He's very good at getting open, catching contested balls and getting yards after the catch. So, I'd say yes, he can play pro football.
My comp for Nabers is Issac Bruce. Similar size and Bruce was once described as an “arc of electricity” coming in and out of his breaks. Nabers has the same effortless single and double moves while running full speed into and through his breaks.
Big deal. Can he play pro football? We've seen many WRs come out of college with great numbers and great stats (and some even drafted by the Giants) who, for one reason or another, cant really play the pro game. I'd be more interested in hearing how their interviews go, what their character is like, and how confident the decision makers are that they aren't drafting another Toney e.g.
Tell me you have no idea who we are talking about without saying it...
Big deal. Can he play pro football? We've seen many WRs come out of college with great numbers and great stats (and some even drafted by the Giants) who, for one reason or another, cant really play the pro game. I'd be more interested in hearing how their interviews go, what their character is like, and how confident the decision makers are that they aren't drafting another Toney e.g.
Tell me you have no idea who we are talking about without saying it...
Are you suggesting interviews and character don't matter? That you already know - based on game highlights and YouTube videos e.g. - who would be a good pro and who wouldn't?
Press conference hadn't run the 40 since HS and just started working on it about 3 weeks ago if I heard correctly. He had been dealing with a toe issue. Wonder what his speed would have been if he was working with a team since the season ended.
Big deal. Can he play pro football? We've seen many WRs come out of college with great numbers and great stats (and some even drafted by the Giants) who, for one reason or another, cant really play the pro game. I'd be more interested in hearing how their interviews go, what their character is like, and how confident the decision makers are that they aren't drafting another Toney e.g.
Agree. Giants can’t gamble here. They should be done with flashy WR’s. Odunze seems more of a sure thing imo. I fell in love with Odunze’s competitiveness.
He's very good at getting open, catching contested balls and getting yards after the catch. So, I'd say yes, he can play pro football.
In college, yes. In the pros? You have no idea.
You can say that about every single player in every single draft...
By the way, this guy is a top rated prospect by some of the most respected people who do this for a living, but yea he can't "play in the NFL"...
You sound like a total buffoon.
Read my post, asswipe. I didn’t say he can’t play in the NFL. I’m interested in knowing the results of further study beyond just stats. The “guys who do this for a living” often get it wrong, and “top rated prospects” often fail in the pros, so I’m expecting the Giants decision makers to be better than those “guys” you reference.
By the way, note how my use of quotation marks refer to words you actually wrote, while yours, well, don’t. And I’m the one who sounds like a buffoon.
This is exactly where i am...
I'm with ya on this too. I'm as desperate as anyone for a QB but a stud #1 WR, Burns and an improved offensive line is a solid offseason.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
Adonai Mitchell 6'2 205 9.97 ras 4.35 40
Xavier Leggette 6'1 221 9.66 ras 4.47 40
Troy Franklin 6'2 176 9.33 ras 4.41 40
Those are 3 guys I'd be targeting in rd2 or via tradeup if we go QB rd1.
Quote:
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
Adonai Mitchell 6'2 205 9.97 ras 4.35 40
Xavier Leggette 6'1 221 9.66 ras 4.47 40
Troy Franklin 6'2 176 9.33 ras 4.41 40
Those are 3 guys I'd be targeting in rd2 or via tradeup if we go QB rd1.
I am with you.
QB in round 1
WR in round 2.
Take advantage of both the reality of being in position to get a QB in a talented QB draft and take advantage of the massive depth of the WR position.
Quote:
In comment 16447733 Dave on the UWS said:
Quote:
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
Adonai Mitchell 6'2 205 9.97 ras 4.35 40
Xavier Leggette 6'1 221 9.66 ras 4.47 40
Troy Franklin 6'2 176 9.33 ras 4.41 40
Those are 3 guys I'd be targeting in rd2 or via tradeup if we go QB rd1.
I am with you.
QB in round 1
WR in round 2.
Take advantage of both the reality of being in position to get a QB in a talented QB draft and take advantage of the massive depth of the WR position.
Yeah if we teade up, which I think we will, I hope we keep our picks this year like EA did with the rd2 pick for Eli. He got Chris Snee with that pick. If we could hit on QB and trade up for a potential #1wr then we are in business and that future 1st won't be so high imo. Best case scenario imo is we get JJM at pick 4 by trading up twice with LAC and AZ (letting both teams know the deal), LAC get a future 3rd AZ gets a future 2nd and they both get their top choices. Otherwise a direct tradeup with AZ would likely be for our 2025 1st. Then again, if they really feel conviction in Maye then go ahead and trade up but it would be hard to keep our 2nd this year in that scenario imo.
There may/should be decent WR options available in round 2. In addition, good WRs are available in the 1st round of every draft. When you have a chance to take a QB you like, you do it. Good WRs are *much* easier to come by than potential franchise QBs.
Quote:
In comment 16447733 Dave on the UWS said:
Quote:
There are a ton of legit #1 type receives in this draft.
BUT, these 3 guys are easily potential pro-bowlers and that's what you want out of the #6 pick in the draft.
As much as we need a QB, I would be VERY tempted (if I'm JS) to let the draft come to me. This guy really is the second coming of OBJ. 6 ft and 4.35 holy crap!!!
Adonai Mitchell 6'2 205 9.97 ras 4.35 40
Xavier Leggette 6'1 221 9.66 ras 4.47 40
Troy Franklin 6'2 176 9.33 ras 4.41 40
Those are 3 guys I'd be targeting in rd2 or via tradeup if we go QB rd1.
I am with you.
QB in round 1
WR in round 2.
Take advantage of both the reality of being in position to get a QB in a talented QB draft and take advantage of the massive depth of the WR position.
+1
100%
Eyeing Franklin, Mitchell, Leggett and Coleman at 47 - would package my 2/3 to move up in round 2 or into round 1 if I see a run on WRs in the 20s or 30s.
He's very good at getting open, catching contested balls and getting yards after the catch. So, I'd say yes, he can play pro football.
He's very good at getting open, catching contested balls and getting yards after the catch. So, I'd say yes, he can play pro football.
In college, yes. In the pros? You have no idea.
Tell me you have no idea who we are talking about without saying it...
Well, he carries a gun so we know he’s tough.
Tell me you have no idea who we are talking about without saying it...
Are you suggesting interviews and character don't matter? That you already know - based on game highlights and YouTube videos e.g. - who would be a good pro and who wouldn't?
NYG - ( New Window )
Agree. Giants can’t gamble here. They should be done with flashy WR’s. Odunze seems more of a sure thing imo. I fell in love with Odunze’s competitiveness.
Quote:
He's very good at getting open, catching contested balls and getting yards after the catch. So, I'd say yes, he can play pro football.
In college, yes. In the pros? You have no idea.
You can say that about every single player in every single draft...
By the way, this guy is a top rated prospect by some of the most respected people who do this for a living, but yea he can't "play in the NFL"...
You sound like a total buffoon.
Quote:
In comment 16447864 Ira said:
Quote:
He's very good at getting open, catching contested balls and getting yards after the catch. So, I'd say yes, he can play pro football.
In college, yes. In the pros? You have no idea.
You can say that about every single player in every single draft...
By the way, this guy is a top rated prospect by some of the most respected people who do this for a living, but yea he can't "play in the NFL"...
You sound like a total buffoon.
Read my post, asswipe. I didn’t say he can’t play in the NFL. I’m interested in knowing the results of further study beyond just stats. The “guys who do this for a living” often get it wrong, and “top rated prospects” often fail in the pros, so I’m expecting the Giants decision makers to be better than those “guys” you reference.
By the way, note how my use of quotation marks refer to words you actually wrote, while yours, well, don’t. And I’m the one who sounds like a buffoon.