Pat Leonard
@PLeonardNYDN
I asked Joe Schoen about whether Washington QB Michael Penix Jr. acquitted himself medically, and if Giants are reticent to draft guys with injury histories.
Schoen said luckily, in Monday's medical meeting, the Giants did NOT lose many players off this year's draft board. He also said while he won't go into Penix Jr.'s specifics, how a player RESPONDS to injuries and surgeries is a major indicator, and Penix has been healthy recently
GiantsWFAN
@giantswfan
·
46s
#NYGiants Schoen - if you take a QB very low, the odds are you are hoping to get an inexpensive backup, given the price of their contract
GiantsWFAN
@giantswfan
·
11s
#NYGiants Schoen - it is a "good QB class...i think it is deep"....been fun getting to know these guys, like to do it every year....info can be important down the road
The Giant Insider Podcast and Newspaper
@GiantInsider
·
53s
Schoen says they had 170 players on the board that went back to college.
That is an amazing number.
said he's impressed with how many games some of these QBs have played. Bo Nix has played more games than any QB in the history of college football IIRC.
Ryan Dunleavy
@rydunleavy
·
54s
Joe Schoen said #Giants might be extra wary to stay away from players who are perceived injury risks because of what theyve been through injury-wise in past few years
Dan Salomone
@Dan_Salomone
·
1m
Schoen said it's a good and deep QB class. "It's been really fun" getting to know them. There are only a few people on Earth who can play the position.
GiantsWFAN
@giantswfan
·
2m
#NYGiants Schoen - it is a "good QB class...i think it is deep"....been fun getting to know these guys, like to do it every year....info can be important down the road
Dan Salomone
@Dan_Salomone
·
50s
Schoen is "still confident" in Daniel Jones and how he is wired. "I've got a good relationship with Daniel" and they communicate well.
GiantsWFAN
@giantswfan
·
2m
#NYGiants Schoen - it is a "good QB class...i think it is deep"....been fun getting to know these guys, like to do it every year....info can be important down the road
This is a great sales pitch for why the Giants spent so much time with the QBs. Actually makes sense also.
Dan Duggan
@DDuggan21
It'll take some time to wade through Schoen's draft-related comments, but quick notes on current players:
• It does not sound like he has any intention of negotiating an extension with Darius Slayton, who is skipping voluntary workouts because he wants a raise.
• Still no word from Darren Waller, who continues to contemplate retirement. Schoen said the team has given no deadline for a decision.
I would really NOT want to play poker with this guy. He could pass a lie detector test!!
As Eric has said, don't listen to the words, pay attention to the actions.
GiantsWFAN
@giantswfan
·
5s
#NYGiants Schoen - have gotten a lot of calls from people behind us to trade up to six...in fact, a surprising amount already
Basically he gave us a lot of GM speak which is good. My take away is he's open to any proposal . I couldn't get a read if next years number one is on the table.
He did not sound concerned about moving future picks based on who could be available. He referenced a lot of players now staying in school based on NIL.
It's not only scripted, its memorized. It will be their tact if they are unable to draft a QB (which is possible).
Then he can say "as I've told you guys, the expectation is Daniel will be the starter and we are comfortable with our QB room".
It's a predictable tact.
It's not only scripted, its memorized. It will be their tact if they are unable to draft a QB (which is possible).
Then he can say "as I've told you guys, the expectation is Daniel will be the starter and we are comfortable with our QB room".
It's a predictable tact.
The fact that it is the same wording is telling (at least to me).
Kind of reminds me of that scene in Congress in "Lincoln"... "it's a lawyer's dodge!"
Giants are taking a QB, but one shouldn't be surprised if it's Nix in an unusual trade down and take a different player (WR), then up from Round 2 scenario.
As for Waller, the fact Giants took hard looks at Sinnott and Theo Johnson has me wondering if they know which way he's leaning already and go there in Rounds 2-4.
said they have had a lot of calls from teams behind them who might want to move up. He seemed surprised by the number of those teams. I wonder if those teams want to move up for one of the "big three" WRs or maybe JJM if the Giants don't want him.
said they have had a lot of calls from teams behind them who might want to move up. He seemed surprised by the number of those teams. I wonder if those teams want to move up for one of the "big three" WRs or maybe JJM if the Giants don't want him.
I bet you this is the case, plus possibly Alt.
Dave and I went into detail about this on his podcast so I'm hoping that is posted soon.
It's not only scripted, its memorized. It will be their tact if they are unable to draft a QB (which is possible).
Then he can say "as I've told you guys, the expectation is Daniel will be the starter and we are comfortable with our QB room".
It's a predictable tact.
It may be tactless to point this out, but the word you are looking to employ is “tack.”
said they have had a lot of calls from teams behind them who might want to move up. He seemed surprised by the number of those teams. I wonder if those teams want to move up for one of the "big three" WRs or maybe JJM if the Giants don't want him.
I bet you this is the case, plus possibly Alt.
Dave and I went into detail about this on his podcast so I'm hoping that is posted soon.
I have been told by pro poker players that there are tells when someone is either being deceitful, misleading, or not truthful.
For the most part, Schoen was very forthright.
This makes it easier to read the tells.
A major tell is if someone touches their face or mouth.
Another is if the person raises their eyebrows.
You can look back at the conference and come to your conclusions.
When talking about Jones he was not being forthright.
He reacted when responding that the plan is for DJ to be starting at the beginning of the season.
He reacted when he was talking about players being eliminated for medical reasons. Suggesting that there are concerns about the medical recommendations.
But if you notice he touches his face when asked about JJ moving up the draft. Don't know what to make of it. But it may mean that JJ is not moving up in the Giant's estimation.
I am not certain of the meaning but there was some significant deception there.
He also reacts when saying that the college QBs played extensively and were impressive. I do not know if he is suggesting that the QB play was less impressive than it appeared.
Finally, he was forthright when talking about DJ at the end.
There was no ambiguity.
But I noted Joe said they hope there are no setbacks. A couple times.
For some reason I keep seeing an asterisk, probably just dirt on my glasses.
I still think Jones is not ready at the beginning of camp and starts the season on the PUP. 'Running in a straight line'? That doesn't really sound like a ringing endorsement.
I take away from his comments that teams behind the Giants have Nabers & Odunze ranked very, very highly on their draft boards (assuming there is no way MHjr makes it to #6).
I’d love if someone asked him about Jones playing this fall in light of that injury clause.
But why would they do that the week before the draft? One that they enter with so many questions about QB, in a draft that's (allegedly) a strong draft for QB, and one that they have been very tight lipped about to date? The only people that benefits are fans who want to know what direction they are going... lol
I have been told by pro poker players that there are tells when someone is either being deceitful, misleading, or not truthful.
For the most part, Schoen was very forthright.
This makes it easier to read the tells.
A major tell is if someone touches their face or mouth.
Another is if the person raises their eyebrows.
You can look back at the conference and come to your conclusions.
When talking about Jones he was not being forthright.
He reacted when responding that the plan is for DJ to be starting at the beginning of the season.
He reacted when he was talking about players being eliminated for medical reasons. Suggesting that there are concerns about the medical recommendations.
But if you notice he touches his face when asked about JJ moving up the draft. Don't know what to make of it. But it may mean that JJ is not moving up in the Giant's estimation.
I am not certain of the meaning but there was some significant deception there.
He also reacts when saying that the college QBs played extensively and were impressive. I do not know if he is suggesting that the QB play was less impressive than it appeared.
Finally, he was forthright when talking about DJ at the end.
There was no ambiguity.
I noticed this too. When he said he was comfortable going into the season with Jones, Lock and DeVito, he noticeably tensed up, started juggling his arms, and lost the smile that was there for much of the other responses. It was very noticeable to me. He did not like answering that question.
RE: Major reason not to trade away next year's picks
The Giant Insider Podcast and Newspaper
@GiantInsider
·
53s
Schoen says they had 170 players on the board that went back to college.
That is an amazing number.
So that means they already have grades (albeit written in pencil) on 170 guys for next year…another reason to not mortgage the future with a trade up.
RE: RE: Major reason not to trade away next year's picks
The Giant Insider Podcast and Newspaper
@GiantInsider
·
53s
Schoen says they had 170 players on the board that went back to college.
That is an amazing number.
So that means they already have grades (albeit written in pencil) on 170 guys for next year…another reason to not mortgage the future with a trade up.
Great response to not trade any premium assets for next year unless it's a QB above 6. Trading up in the 2nd makes no sense to me.
Next draft class is supposedly very good for defense, pass rushers and corners notably. Premium positions.
@PLeonardNYDN
I asked Joe Schoen about whether Washington QB Michael Penix Jr. acquitted himself medically, and if Giants are reticent to draft guys with injury histories.
Schoen said luckily, in Monday's medical meeting, the Giants did NOT lose many players off this year's draft board. He also said while he won't go into Penix Jr.'s specifics, how a player RESPONDS to injuries and surgeries is a major indicator, and Penix has been healthy recently
@giantswfan
·
46s
#NYGiants Schoen - if you take a QB very low, the odds are you are hoping to get an inexpensive backup, given the price of their contract
@giantswfan
·
11s
#NYGiants Schoen - it is a "good QB class...i think it is deep"....been fun getting to know these guys, like to do it every year....info can be important down the road
@GiantInsider
·
53s
Schoen says they had 170 players on the board that went back to college.
That is an amazing number.
@rydunleavy
·
54s
Joe Schoen said #Giants might be extra wary to stay away from players who are perceived injury risks because of what theyve been through injury-wise in past few years
@Dan_Salomone
·
1m
Schoen said it's a good and deep QB class. "It's been really fun" getting to know them. There are only a few people on Earth who can play the position.
Quote:
just said he's comfortable going into the season with Jones, Lock, and DeVito. Cue the meltdown.
Sure. That's why six quarterbacks have visited.
Yeah, I don't believe it either. And it's what you'd expect him to say. But as JonC frequently says, follow their actions not words.
@giantswfan
·
2m
#NYGiants Schoen - it is a "good QB class...i think it is deep"....been fun getting to know these guys, like to do it every year....info can be important down the road
Jack Stroud won’t take that well.
Hopefully you are reading that correctly. How could anyone give DJ a ringing endorsement?
@Dan_Salomone
·
50s
Schoen is "still confident" in Daniel Jones and how he is wired. "I've got a good relationship with Daniel" and they communicate well.
@rydunleavy
·
29s
#Giants Joe Schoen said ‘it was not true’ that he has buyer’s remorse on Daniel Jones contract extension
@giantswfan
·
2m
#NYGiants Schoen - it is a "good QB class...i think it is deep"....been fun getting to know these guys, like to do it every year....info can be important down the road
This is a great sales pitch for why the Giants spent so much time with the QBs. Actually makes sense also.
"Kadarius Toney isn't going anywhere."
"Wink Martindale is our defensive coordinator."
@rydunleavy
·
29s
#Giants Joe Schoen said ‘it was not true’ that he has buyer’s remorse on Daniel Jones contract extension
"I really fucked up that Jones contract...." :)
@DDuggan21
It'll take some time to wade through Schoen's draft-related comments, but quick notes on current players:
• It does not sound like he has any intention of negotiating an extension with Darius Slayton, who is skipping voluntary workouts because he wants a raise.
• Still no word from Darren Waller, who continues to contemplate retirement. Schoen said the team has given no deadline for a decision.
As Eric has said, don't listen to the words, pay attention to the actions.
@giantswfan
·
5s
#NYGiants Schoen - have gotten a lot of calls from people behind us to trade up to six...in fact, a surprising amount already
come to papa
Then he can say "as I've told you guys, the expectation is Daniel will be the starter and we are comfortable with our QB room".
It's a predictable tact.
I was unable to listen but what are your highlights? QB in play? Trade down on the table? Trade up possibility starts at 3?
Then he can say "as I've told you guys, the expectation is Daniel will be the starter and we are comfortable with our QB room".
It's a predictable tact.
The fact that it is the same wording is telling (at least to me).
Kind of reminds me of that scene in Congress in "Lincoln"... "it's a lawyer's dodge!"
Daboll gives nothing in press conferences, but Schoen is quite informative, albeit measured and careful.
Quote:
know why fans have said these pre-draft pressers are a waste of time. I got a lot out of this one, and last year's too.
I was unable to listen but what are your highlights? QB in play? Trade down on the table? Trade up possibility starts at 3?
I'll have the transcript up shortly. Key points are already posted in this thread.
As for Waller, the fact Giants took hard looks at Sinnott and Theo Johnson has me wondering if they know which way he's leaning already and go there in Rounds 2-4.
They want the right QB....and willing to trade 2025 picks.
They are well prepared.....and all options are on table.
I came away, feeling the Giants are in good hands
They want the right QB....and willing to trade 2025 picks.
They are well prepared.....and all options are on table.
I came away, feeling the Giants are in good hands
I get the same sense. I think trade down is a real possibility if they don't go QB.
They want the right QB....and willing to trade 2025 picks.
They are well prepared.....and all options are on table.
I came away, feeling the Giants are in good hands
Problem is these draft picks they have been selecting need to start performing. Some have, but some haven't (injuries have been a factor too).
I'd feel better if the results to date were better.
They also made a colossal screw up on the Jones/Barkley situations last offseason.
I bet you this is the case, plus possibly Alt.
Dave and I went into detail about this on his podcast so I'm hoping that is posted soon.
Then he can say "as I've told you guys, the expectation is Daniel will be the starter and we are comfortable with our QB room".
It's a predictable tact.
It may be tactless to point this out, but the word you are looking to employ is “tack.”
Quote:
said they have had a lot of calls from teams behind them who might want to move up. He seemed surprised by the number of those teams. I wonder if those teams want to move up for one of the "big three" WRs or maybe JJM if the Giants don't want him.
I bet you this is the case, plus possibly Alt.
Dave and I went into detail about this on his podcast so I'm hoping that is posted soon.
Yes, Alt as well.
For some reason I keep seeing an asterisk, probably just dirt on my glasses.
I am not sure a rookie center....with that OL around him...had any hope.
The OL coach did not have the OL ready for prime time.
Hyatt type of routes were not an option...we can blame the QB.....but that OL was historically bad.
I think the defense is close
And the punter stepped up....hopefully kicker gets healthy.
For the most part, Schoen was very forthright.
This makes it easier to read the tells.
A major tell is if someone touches their face or mouth.
Another is if the person raises their eyebrows.
You can look back at the conference and come to your conclusions.
When talking about Jones he was not being forthright.
He reacted when responding that the plan is for DJ to be starting at the beginning of the season.
He reacted when he was talking about players being eliminated for medical reasons. Suggesting that there are concerns about the medical recommendations.
But if you notice he touches his face when asked about JJ moving up the draft. Don't know what to make of it. But it may mean that JJ is not moving up in the Giant's estimation.
I am not certain of the meaning but there was some significant deception there.
He also reacts when saying that the college QBs played extensively and were impressive. I do not know if he is suggesting that the QB play was less impressive than it appeared.
Finally, he was forthright when talking about DJ at the end.
There was no ambiguity.
For some reason I keep seeing an asterisk, probably just dirt on my glasses.
I still think Jones is not ready at the beginning of camp and starts the season on the PUP. 'Running in a straight line'? That doesn't really sound like a ringing endorsement.
I take away from his comments that teams behind the Giants have Nabers & Odunze ranked very, very highly on their draft boards (assuming there is no way MHjr makes it to #6).
But why would they do that the week before the draft? One that they enter with so many questions about QB, in a draft that's (allegedly) a strong draft for QB, and one that they have been very tight lipped about to date? The only people that benefits are fans who want to know what direction they are going... lol
For the most part, Schoen was very forthright.
This makes it easier to read the tells.
A major tell is if someone touches their face or mouth.
Another is if the person raises their eyebrows.
You can look back at the conference and come to your conclusions.
When talking about Jones he was not being forthright.
He reacted when responding that the plan is for DJ to be starting at the beginning of the season.
He reacted when he was talking about players being eliminated for medical reasons. Suggesting that there are concerns about the medical recommendations.
But if you notice he touches his face when asked about JJ moving up the draft. Don't know what to make of it. But it may mean that JJ is not moving up in the Giant's estimation.
I am not certain of the meaning but there was some significant deception there.
He also reacts when saying that the college QBs played extensively and were impressive. I do not know if he is suggesting that the QB play was less impressive than it appeared.
Finally, he was forthright when talking about DJ at the end.
There was no ambiguity.
I noticed this too. When he said he was comfortable going into the season with Jones, Lock and DeVito, he noticeably tensed up, started juggling his arms, and lost the smile that was there for much of the other responses. It was very noticeable to me. He did not like answering that question.
@GiantInsider
·
53s
Schoen says they had 170 players on the board that went back to college.
That is an amazing number.
So that means they already have grades (albeit written in pencil) on 170 guys for next year…another reason to not mortgage the future with a trade up.
Quote:
The Giant Insider Podcast and Newspaper
@GiantInsider
·
53s
Schoen says they had 170 players on the board that went back to college.
That is an amazing number.
So that means they already have grades (albeit written in pencil) on 170 guys for next year…another reason to not mortgage the future with a trade up.
Great response to not trade any premium assets for next year unless it's a QB above 6. Trading up in the 2nd makes no sense to me.
Next draft class is supposedly very good for defense, pass rushers and corners notably. Premium positions.