Bypassed 2 QBs who went 2 and 4 picks after us and as I’m typing this I think Denver is taking Nix at 12, all for a wide receiver which may be the deepest position in this draft.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
Bypassed 2 QBs who went 2 and 4 picks after us and as I’m typing this I think Denver is taking Nix at 12, all for a wide receiver which may be the deepest position in this draft.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
Love you JonC, but can you elaborate? Because I’m having a really hard time accepting this outcome. What a horrible evening. 2024 season already than the drain.
Unless it was sarcasm?!
It was so obvious all these QBs were going to be gone by 12
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
Per the bold, 100%. Schoen has tripled down.
Do you think Schoen will admit to calling the Pats about Maye? Or perhaps it was soft interest at best and the plan was to sit chilly and wait for the WR at 6?
He isn't good. Nabers or not. Improvements along the OL or not. And people can't say that we haven't tried to bring in weapons or improvements in front of him.
He isn't a gamechanger. He's barely average. The team overpaid, and now we are stuck with his fragile neck for yet another season.
Bypassed 2 QBs who went 2 and 4 picks after us and as I’m typing this I think Denver is taking Nix at 12, all for a wide receiver which may be the deepest position in this draft.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
I do not believe that they tried to trade up for Maye. Nabers was their guy. Imo the talk about the Giants trading up was from other teams trying to increase offers.
RE: i think it’s just finally put-up-or-shutup time
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
Most teams in QB he'll are trying to improve, but just don't hit on the right guys. We are actively committing to this loser while making massive donations to his generational wealth fund.
Don't take a quarterback. They suck. Fire them now.
Trade up for a quarterback. The giants panicked. We got fleeced and we got the worse one of the whole draft. They suck. Fire them now.
Stay put and draft a quarterback. We drafted him too high. He isn't even a first rounder, we could have got him in the 4th round. They suck. Fire them now.
Bypassed 2 QBs who went 2 and 4 picks after us and as I’m typing this I think Denver is taking Nix at 12, all for a wide receiver which may be the deepest position in this draft.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
I do not believe that they tried to trade up for Maye. Nabers was their guy. Imo the talk about the Giants trading up was from other teams trying to increase offers.
rapaport is usually pretty accurate and he reported it after the pats made their pick that both NYG and MIN made a last attempt to get up and they said no.
Quote:
Ian Rapoport
@RapSheet
·
1h
From our NFL Draft coverage: The #Patriots had big-time trade offers... and decided to stick and pick.
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
All 3 are better than Jones. But, one way to look at it is Nabers is likely a lot better than any of those 3. Basically, with Nix now gone also, this is 100^ on the shoulders of Jones. WR1 to go with Robinson and Hyatt and an improved OL. No excuses. Put up numbers for the first time in your career.
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
Best case is Drew Lock is resurrected and we don't
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
i'm surprised they werent more concerned with the injuries. anybody can get hurt but if you have 2 anybodies you have twice as good of a chance to have 1 healthy one.
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Most teams in QB he'll are trying to improve, but just don't hit on the right guys. We are actively committing to this loser while making massive donations to his generational wealth fund.
I wonder... could it really be as simple as ownership simply refusing to acknowledge they were wrong about him? It honestly seems that base.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
i'm surprised they werent more concerned with the injuries. anybody can get hurt but if you have 2 anybodies you have twice as good of a chance to have 1 healthy one.
If Jones is telling the truth, and the neck issue was just a stinger. And he's already sprinting on the ACL -- seems like the injuries aren't of the opinion-changing variety.
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
Great point and something myself and many other fans simply overlooked because we want to move on from Jones.
Unless they were in the top 3 and there hands would truly forced, they weren’t going QB.
And definitely think there’s buyers remorse on that contract. They probably like him as a bridge option though. A lot of this first round decision had to do with opportunity cost imo, there were better non-qb options in this draft than basically all of our other top 10 picks in recent years. This was a better draft, probably the one we should have had the 5th and 7th picks in. I think that factored more than people realize.
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Do I think Schoen checked in to see what it might take? Sure. Do I think Schoen went balls to the wall to get a QB at #3? Frankly, I'm not so sure.
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
If they liked Jones so much then why they try and trade up for Maye?
Most teams in QB he'll are trying to improve, but just don't hit on the right guys. We are actively committing to this loser while making massive donations to his generational wealth fund.
I wonder... could it really be as simple as ownership simply refusing to acknowledge they were wrong about him? It honestly seems that base.
Yeah I do think it's that. But I'm also not going to defend Schoen. He wasn't able to do anything about it so he's worthless. I guess the only escape for us at this point is that Jones gets old enough and chooses to retire or gets injured enough that he can't continue
RE: Best case is Drew Lock is resurrected and we don't
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Do I think Schoen checked in to see what it might take? Sure. Do I think Schoen went balls to the wall to get a QB at #3? Frankly, I'm not so sure.
So you don’t know what the offer was?
But you’d rather complain that we are all in on DJ with in fact they did make an offer
They obviously didn't like the group after the top 3. Gotta trust the work
Have you 'trusted the work' these last 12 years?
Exactly. “Trust the work” of a franchise that can’t draft worth a shit.
New front office and they spent a ton of time with the QBs
I am sorry they didn't ask you for your opinion on the draft. Obviously we should have let this crew make the selection
He isn't good. Nabers or not. Improvements along the OL or not. And people can't say that we haven't tried to bring in weapons or improvements in front of him.
He isn't a gamechanger. He's barely average. The team overpaid, and now we are stuck with his fragile neck for yet another season.
Yay.
....."And people can't say that we haven't tried to bring in weapons or improvements in front of him."
Yes, we tried ... and failed. Look, I'm not a huge Jones fan ... definite flaws. But saying we TRIED to get him weapons and protection is not a reflection on him, we FAILED. Given all the circumstances, I think we made the best choice tonight, not because we owe it to him, but because it's best for the team. Feel free to disagree.
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
If they liked Jones so much then why they try and trade up for Maye?
I wanted a QB too….but that doesn’t make sense
Because it's possible to like two things at the same time.
When the Giants picked Nabers, there were 3 top 15 QBs available. And they liked Daniel Jones more.
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
If they liked Jones so much then why they try and trade up for Maye?
I wanted a QB too….but that doesn’t make sense
Because it's possible to like two things at the same time.
When the Giants picked Nabers, there were 3 top 15 QBs available. And they liked Daniel Jones more.
Again beauty is in the eye of the beholder and if they didn’t have a conviction on the remaining QB’s then why take one
Has literally nothing to do with DJ
Again they had their guy…but NE wasn’t willing to trade
And definitely think there’s buyers remorse on that contract. They probably like him as a bridge option though. A lot of this first round decision had to do with opportunity cost imo, there were better non-qb options in this draft than basically all of our other top 10 picks in recent years. This was a better draft, probably the one we should have had the 5th and 7th picks in. I think that factored more than people realize.
I think they are looking at 2024 as sunk cost so they don't want to flush $40 milion.
But you’d rather complain that we are all in on DJ with in fact they did make an offer
I'm calling it like I see it.
Did we make a legit offer? Did we even make an offer? I don't know.
Again, I don't doubt Schoen called Wolf to get a feel for the situation. But maybe it was a call to check a box.
Who are you saying we should have made an offer for? Unless Washington had shocked everyone and not taken Daniels, I wouldn't have traded up for Maye or McCarthy. And, it ended up McCarthy was there for the taking anyway.
Now, with no QB to take in round 2, the question is are they better with Jones/Nabers or McCarthy and a round 2 WR in a WR heavy draft.
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Do I think Schoen checked in to see what it might take? Sure. Do I think Schoen went balls to the wall to get a QB at #3? Frankly, I'm not so sure.
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
Keep crying. The Giants didn't see it your way and drafted the player they thought better to help the team. Just because you wanted a QB doesn't mean it was the right pick to force one. Get over yourself
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
Keep crying. The Giants didn't see it your way and drafted the player they thought better to help the team. Just because you wanted a QB doesn't mean it was the right pick to force one. Get over yourself
Have you considered the possibility that the Giants don’t know what they are doing?
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
Keep crying. The Giants didn't see it your way and drafted the player they thought better to help the team. Just because you wanted a QB doesn't mean it was the right pick to force one. Get over yourself
Have you considered the possibility that the Giants don’t know what they are doing?
Have you considered they have more knowledge than you and understand why things went to shit last year?
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
i'm surprised they werent more concerned with the injuries. anybody can get hurt but if you have 2 anybodies you have twice as good of a chance to have 1 healthy one.
If Jones is telling the truth, and the neck issue was just a stinger. And he's already sprinting on the ACL -- seems like the injuries aren't of the opinion-changing variety.
in-season Chau said the neck injury was a nothing injury and unrelated to his injury last year. they cleared him for Vegas so I was never that concerned with the neck injury specifically, just that he's a QB who takes a lot of hits and has not shown to be an ironman like Allen.
his progress on the ACL seems borderline shocking, though getting back to training is different than rushing for 50+ yards a game and being near the top of the league in first downs. if that part of his game regresses it's not insignificant.
i think someone else said this (bw?) but ultimately it seems they were willing to pick a qb they had in a different tier than jones (maye) but weren't willing to pick QBs who they didnt like better.
anyone who wanted a QB. I was ecstatic at yesterday's rumors that we had No. 3 overall.
But, the Giants didn't pick a QB at 6 because none of them were better than Jones. When they couldn't get their QB in Maye they stuck to their board and got BPA. This is what good teams do. It's why the Ravens are so good at drafting.
Think of it this way, did they pass on a RB because they think none of them are better than their RB room, did they pass on Q. Mitchell because McCloud is better than him at CB? No.
They didn't pass on JJM or Penix or whoever because they thought DJ was better. They had a target who was probably No. 1 remaining on their board with the chance to trade up but were never going to pry 3 away from NE.
They stuck to the board and took their BPA.
It sucks for the QB crowd. I was so hopeful that Maye was going to be a Giant yesterday. I don't have much hope for this team and I'm increasingly pessimistic that this regime will get their chance to draft their QB and that bums me out. I have real hope that if they do then the Giants will be perennial playoff/SB contenders but the results yesterday give me doubt they will ever have that chance.
It's a sobering realization. But the process was correct. You can be upset that the future is bleak but it was the right move based on their board.
We don't need a QB. We have the great Daniel Jones.
insane. knew this was a solid class but didnt see that coming.
bw is right. Schoen just went all in on Jones. Now I expect to win with the expensive QB.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
But our NY Giants had absolutely no interest in 3 of them which were completely available.
Unfortunately that number is 10,000.
Love you JonC, but can you elaborate? Because I’m having a really hard time accepting this outcome. What a horrible evening. 2024 season already than the drain.
Unless it was sarcasm?!
But you know what there will be a lot of in rounds 2 and 3? Wide receivers.
btw...what's the over-under on when Nabers asks for a trade?
Have you 'trusted the work' these last 12 years?
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
Per the bold, 100%. Schoen has tripled down.
Do you think Schoen will admit to calling the Pats about Maye? Or perhaps it was soft interest at best and the plan was to sit chilly and wait for the WR at 6?
You must be new
I don't see what Schoen and Dabs do - clearly.
He isn't good. Nabers or not. Improvements along the OL or not. And people can't say that we haven't tried to bring in weapons or improvements in front of him.
He isn't a gamechanger. He's barely average. The team overpaid, and now we are stuck with his fragile neck for yet another season.
Yay.
Quote:
Bypassed 2 QBs who went 2 and 4 picks after us and as I’m typing this I think Denver is taking Nix at 12, all for a wide receiver which may be the deepest position in this draft.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
I do not believe that they tried to trade up for Maye. Nabers was their guy. Imo the talk about the Giants trading up was from other teams trying to increase offers.
Finally? Last year after that contract was his put up or shut up and he cut out his own tongue.
Yup, Giants passed on 3 of them after Ll the work. I guess other teams disagree. We shall see.
Agree. This reeks of Barkley 2.0. Great player no infrastructure to maximize his talents. Giants will be back in the GM head coach pool in 26.
Hopefully there will be new people making it.
This message board is more toxic than a teenagers fortnight discord chat.
This message board is more toxic than a teenagers fortnight discord chat.
Go win the division, Daniel.
What a wonderful thing to have hold out hope for. A scrap heap QB who has been given up on by two teams and, a guy who, at best, is a back up.
Woooooo baby! Sign me up and give me a medium Pepsi!
This team is run by assholes.
Quote:
They obviously didn't like the group after the top 3. Gotta trust the work
Have you 'trusted the work' these last 12 years?
Exactly. “Trust the work” of a franchise that can’t draft worth a shit.
This message board is more toxic than a teenagers fortnight discord chat.
They picked up a shiny new toy with shit for a QB room. Spare me.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
So sad
Trade up for a quarterback. The giants panicked. We got fleeced and we got the worse one of the whole draft. They suck. Fire them now.
Stay put and draft a quarterback. We drafted him too high. He isn't even a first rounder, we could have got him in the 4th round. They suck. Fire them now.
Quote:
In comment 16488639 Chris684 said:
Quote:
Bypassed 2 QBs who went 2 and 4 picks after us and as I’m typing this I think Denver is taking Nix at 12, all for a wide receiver which may be the deepest position in this draft.
The Giants have very little hope to sell fans for next season.
They had to know that by not picking again until 47, they were going to get one chance at a significant QB selection and they passed it up.
we'll see how it ends up but it was certainly an unexpected endorsement of jones.
they tried to trade up for drake maye though, so it would seem they had qbs who they saw as upgrades and others they didnt.
I do not believe that they tried to trade up for Maye. Nabers was their guy. Imo the talk about the Giants trading up was from other teams trying to increase offers.
rapaport is usually pretty accurate and he reported it after the pats made their pick that both NYG and MIN made a last attempt to get up and they said no.
@RapSheet
·
1h
From our NFL Draft coverage: The #Patriots had big-time trade offers... and decided to stick and pick.
https://x.com/RapSheet/status/1783657462630907932 - ( New Window )
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
i'm surprised they werent more concerned with the injuries. anybody can get hurt but if you have 2 anybodies you have twice as good of a chance to have 1 healthy one.
So sad
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
🤦🏻♂️
I wonder... could it really be as simple as ownership simply refusing to acknowledge they were wrong about him? It honestly seems that base.
i'm surprised they werent more concerned with the injuries. anybody can get hurt but if you have 2 anybodies you have twice as good of a chance to have 1 healthy one.
If Jones is telling the truth, and the neck issue was just a stinger. And he's already sprinting on the ACL -- seems like the injuries aren't of the opinion-changing variety.
Too funny.
Yes the excuses are over for DJ. The flip side is, he has never had a #1 WR worth a shit until right now.
The thing is, although they tried, they never did get him those weapons and protection, trying and failing doesn't count, so ....
Not exactly a high bar.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
Great point and something myself and many other fans simply overlooked because we want to move on from Jones.
Unless they were in the top 3 and there hands would truly forced, they weren’t going QB.
Quote:
It didn’t go your waaaaaaaay
So sad
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Quote:
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Do I think Schoen checked in to see what it might take? Sure. Do I think Schoen went balls to the wall to get a QB at #3? Frankly, I'm not so sure.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
If they liked Jones so much then why they try and trade up for Maye?
I wanted a QB too….but that doesn’t make sense
Quote:
Most teams in QB he'll are trying to improve, but just don't hit on the right guys. We are actively committing to this loser while making massive donations to his generational wealth fund.
I wonder... could it really be as simple as ownership simply refusing to acknowledge they were wrong about him? It honestly seems that base.
Yeah I do think it's that. But I'm also not going to defend Schoen. He wasn't able to do anything about it so he's worthless. I guess the only escape for us at this point is that Jones gets old enough and chooses to retire or gets injured enough that he can't continue
Quote:
In comment 16488902 bw in dc said:
Quote:
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Do I think Schoen checked in to see what it might take? Sure. Do I think Schoen went balls to the wall to get a QB at #3? Frankly, I'm not so sure.
So you don’t know what the offer was?
But you’d rather complain that we are all in on DJ with in fact they did make an offer
Quote:
In comment 16488718 larryflower37 said:
Quote:
They obviously didn't like the group after the top 3. Gotta trust the work
Have you 'trusted the work' these last 12 years?
Exactly. “Trust the work” of a franchise that can’t draft worth a shit.
New front office and they spent a ton of time with the QBs
I am sorry they didn't ask you for your opinion on the draft. Obviously we should have let this crew make the selection
I don't see what Schoen and Dabs do - clearly.
He isn't good. Nabers or not. Improvements along the OL or not. And people can't say that we haven't tried to bring in weapons or improvements in front of him.
He isn't a gamechanger. He's barely average. The team overpaid, and now we are stuck with his fragile neck for yet another season.
Yay.
....."And people can't say that we haven't tried to bring in weapons or improvements in front of him."
Yes, we tried ... and failed. Look, I'm not a huge Jones fan ... definite flaws. But saying we TRIED to get him weapons and protection is not a reflection on him, we FAILED. Given all the circumstances, I think we made the best choice tonight, not because we owe it to him, but because it's best for the team. Feel free to disagree.
Quote:
In comment 16488914 Thegratefulhead said:
Quote:
It didn’t go your waaaaaaaay
So sad
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
If they liked Jones so much then why they try and trade up for Maye?
I wanted a QB too….but that doesn’t make sense
Because it's possible to like two things at the same time.
When the Giants picked Nabers, there were 3 top 15 QBs available. And they liked Daniel Jones more.
Quote:
I very much doubted the Giants would take a QB. I get the diligence, and I certainly believe they rated Williams, Daniels, and Maye all as upgraded to Jones. But I don't think they were ever going to make a huge push.
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
If they liked Jones so much then why they try and trade up for Maye?
I wanted a QB too….but that doesn’t make sense
Because it's possible to like two things at the same time.
When the Giants picked Nabers, there were 3 top 15 QBs available. And they liked Daniel Jones more.
Again beauty is in the eye of the beholder and if they didn’t have a conviction on the remaining QB’s then why take one
Has literally nothing to do with DJ
Again they had their guy…but NE wasn’t willing to trade
And who is to say that is the right move
btw...what's the over-under on when Nabers asks for a trade?
Training camp.
I think Lock starts the year, we're DOA in Oct again.
Again beauty is in the eye of the beholder and if they didn’t have a conviction on the remaining QB’s then why take one
Has literally nothing to do with DJ
Again they had their guy…but NE wasn’t willing to trade
The Giants passing on 3 top 15 QBs, including QBs Payton and O'Connell picked, doesn't indicate to you they like Jones?
So you don’t know what the offer was?
But you’d rather complain that we are all in on DJ with in fact they did make an offer
I'm calling it like I see it.
Did we make a legit offer? Did we even make an offer? I don't know.
Again, I don't doubt Schoen called Wolf to get a feel for the situation. But maybe it was a call to check a box.
And an All-Pro line and a better WR2, WR3, TE, kicker, punter, FB...
The dead guy from Weekend at Bernies would look better in preseason than DJ.
I think they are looking at 2024 as sunk cost so they don't want to flush $40 milion.
Quote:
So you don’t know what the offer was?
But you’d rather complain that we are all in on DJ with in fact they did make an offer
I'm calling it like I see it.
Did we make a legit offer? Did we even make an offer? I don't know.
Again, I don't doubt Schoen called Wolf to get a feel for the situation. But maybe it was a call to check a box.
Now, with no QB to take in round 2, the question is are they better with Jones/Nabers or McCarthy and a round 2 WR in a WR heavy draft.
Quote:
In comment 16488902 bw in dc said:
Quote:
Jones is a > prospect than McCarthy, Penix and Nix.
Because he had a crack at all three and passed.
Frankly, I really don't want to hear anymore that Schoen is taking marching orders from Mara. I keep hearing from a group of posters how SMART Schoen is.
Well, if you believe that, you'd better believe Jones is his ticket. And he has tripled down.
If the Pats accepted our trade offer
Then this narrative wouldn’t exist
Do you think they would have tried to trade up if they were doubling down on DJ?
Do I think Schoen checked in to see what it might take? Sure. Do I think Schoen went balls to the wall to get a QB at #3? Frankly, I'm not so sure.
I doubt John would let him.
Quote:
In comment 16488976 rsjem1979 said:
Quote:
In comment 16488914 Thegratefulhead said:
Quote:
It didn’t go your waaaaaaaay
So sad
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
Keep crying. The Giants didn't see it your way and drafted the player they thought better to help the team. Just because you wanted a QB doesn't mean it was the right pick to force one. Get over yourself
Quote:
In comment 16489033 Giantsbigblue said:
Quote:
In comment 16488976 rsjem1979 said:
Quote:
In comment 16488914 Thegratefulhead said:
Quote:
It didn’t go your waaaaaaaay
So sad
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
Keep crying. The Giants didn't see it your way and drafted the player they thought better to help the team. Just because you wanted a QB doesn't mean it was the right pick to force one. Get over yourself
Have you considered the possibility that the Giants don’t know what they are doing?
Quote:
In comment 16489121 rsjem1979 said:
Quote:
In comment 16489033 Giantsbigblue said:
Quote:
In comment 16488976 rsjem1979 said:
Quote:
In comment 16488914 Thegratefulhead said:
Quote:
It didn’t go your waaaaaaaay
So sad
Can’t wait to hear the all new batch of excuses next year for your boy.
Cry
Mature. Go win games or shut the fuck up.
Keep crying. The Giants didn't see it your way and drafted the player they thought better to help the team. Just because you wanted a QB doesn't mean it was the right pick to force one. Get over yourself
Have you considered the possibility that the Giants don’t know what they are doing?
Have you considered they have more knowledge than you and understand why things went to shit last year?
Quote:
I bet Lock looks better in preseason than Jones does.
The dead guy from Weekend at Bernies would look better in preseason than DJ.
You mean Bernie?
Richard Todd
Quote:
They simply like Jones a lot. And if you like your QB, you don't go out of your way to replace him.
i'm surprised they werent more concerned with the injuries. anybody can get hurt but if you have 2 anybodies you have twice as good of a chance to have 1 healthy one.
If Jones is telling the truth, and the neck issue was just a stinger. And he's already sprinting on the ACL -- seems like the injuries aren't of the opinion-changing variety.
in-season Chau said the neck injury was a nothing injury and unrelated to his injury last year. they cleared him for Vegas so I was never that concerned with the neck injury specifically, just that he's a QB who takes a lot of hits and has not shown to be an ironman like Allen.
his progress on the ACL seems borderline shocking, though getting back to training is different than rushing for 50+ yards a game and being near the top of the league in first downs. if that part of his game regresses it's not insignificant.
i think someone else said this (bw?) but ultimately it seems they were willing to pick a qb they had in a different tier than jones (maye) but weren't willing to pick QBs who they didnt like better.
Quote:
who was handed a starting job with the same team for 6 straight years?
Richard Todd
Yes. A mere 40+ years ago.
But, the Giants didn't pick a QB at 6 because none of them were better than Jones. When they couldn't get their QB in Maye they stuck to their board and got BPA. This is what good teams do. It's why the Ravens are so good at drafting.
Think of it this way, did they pass on a RB because they think none of them are better than their RB room, did they pass on Q. Mitchell because McCloud is better than him at CB? No.
They didn't pass on JJM or Penix or whoever because they thought DJ was better. They had a target who was probably No. 1 remaining on their board with the chance to trade up but were never going to pry 3 away from NE.
They stuck to the board and took their BPA.
It sucks for the QB crowd. I was so hopeful that Maye was going to be a Giant yesterday. I don't have much hope for this team and I'm increasingly pessimistic that this regime will get their chance to draft their QB and that bums me out. I have real hope that if they do then the Giants will be perennial playoff/SB contenders but the results yesterday give me doubt they will ever have that chance.
It's a sobering realization. But the process was correct. You can be upset that the future is bleak but it was the right move based on their board.
I feel like this is the most sane post you ever made. hahaha j/k