for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Positions NOT to draft tonight?

lugnut : 4/26/2024 5:17 pm
I mean, as in I wouldn’t even bother with: OL, LB, S.

Said some of this on another thread re OL: We have a LOT of new blockers on this team already. 14 total OL, including 5 (4?) new adds, and 6 TEs, including 2 new blocking-only (practically). Let that shake out this year, although we need a catching TE. (We can’t effing seem to draft well here anyway.)

LB/S: We have a certifiable excellent LB in Okereke, and ascendant one in McFadden. Everyone else is middling and/or ST only, and we are exceedingly unlikely to spend or get a blue chip. So good enough. S not that important in the grand scheme, we have just enough, and I gather the class is not that good/deep.

So ignore all those and go full bore for what we really need: CB, DL, RB, catching TE, and I would even double dip at WR based on value if the class really is that deep. That’s yer 5 picks right there.
disagree on OL  
bigbluewillrise : 4/26/2024 5:18 pm : link
we need help there.

one injury away from starting McKethan.
agree on OL  
Jim in Tampa : 4/26/2024 5:25 pm : link
2 potential starters and 3 depth OL signed in FA. Unless there's a HUGE difference in talent when the Giants are on the clock tonight, I'd prefer other positions.

Take the BPA at CB, DT, RB, TE or S.
I don't know what positions or players they're prioritizing on defense  
81_Great_Dane : 4/26/2024 5:27 pm : link
The new guy's going to need some players who fit his scheme. So I think safety may be a higher priority than BBIers think. Especially since McKinney left.

Wouldn't take an inside linebacker in rounds 2-3 because they have Okereke and I don't think there's an impactful player there to be had.

I don't think they take an OT tonight unless they trade Neal. Which seems unlikely. That doesn't mean Neal is being handed the job; it just means they don't want to replace Neal with a green rookie.

Probably not a TE tonight. On the other hand, I would be surprised if they don't take a RB sometime in their next three picks, if only because they need a good running game so they don't have to rely on Jones or Lock to carry the offense. I think they'd like a RB who is a good receiver; is good in pass protection; and is good enough to make the defense account for him. A home run hitter would be nice. I think they liked Barkley's skill set but he was too expensive for the role they needed him for. A rookie 2nd or 3rd round pick is going to be a lot cheaper.

QB  
pjcas18 : 4/26/2024 5:28 pm : link
we're all set there.
I can find rational for anything  
Biteymax22 : 4/26/2024 5:30 pm : link
Other than kicker, punter or long snapper
Can't agree on S  
logman : 4/26/2024 5:32 pm : link
...
WR  
Amc825 : 4/26/2024 5:35 pm : link
That’s it……
Only two positions  
Amtoft : 4/26/2024 5:40 pm : link
not to draft... K and Punter... and I guess Long snapper if you want to include that.
RE: WR  
gersh : 4/26/2024 5:44 pm : link
In comment 16492515 Amc825 said:
Quote:
That’s it……

+1
BPA but, if close, CB has to be prioritized
The Guard who Sy has a 1st round grade has to be considered if there
Trey Benson at RB has to be a possibility
With McKinney gone - getting a highly rated safety would be helpful (especially if not getting a CB starter type here)
QB  
gameday555 : 4/26/2024 5:46 pm : link
And if you can’t get Sanders or Sinnott, no TE is worth it to me.

I can't understand how so many fans feel OL isn't a need  
Cyrus the Great : 4/26/2024 5:59 pm : link
We signed a few lousy and one maybe good offensive linemen. We have seen nothing from Evan Neal to make us believe he is going to be better. Instead, everyone is putting blind faith in the new OL coach that he will perform some magic and turn Neal into an NFL caliber OT. I don't buy it, I think the line as stands currently will most likely suck next year.
This team needs impact players  
GiantsFan84 : 4/26/2024 6:08 pm : link
Every position should be on the board.
Need OL  
giantstock : 4/26/2024 6:48 pm : link
As SY stated -- Giants have nothing but a bunch of maybes other than their LT.

No way would I discount it. IMO it should be a priority rather thna have more prayers. Theidea shouldn't be to be content with at best a mediocre OL.
I can see us going LB  
George : 4/26/2024 7:56 pm : link
Edgerrin Cooper is a good player who can improve our defense in multiple ways.
It’s a safety  
Rudy5757 : 4/26/2024 8:35 pm : link
I guess they disagree with you
RE: Can't agree on S  
Del Shofner : 4/26/2024 9:28 pm : link
In comment 16492508 logman said:
Quote:
...


good call
Back to the Corner