Sy's remaining grades for Day 3

Not discounting the idea, but Schoen and Daboll have done some of their finest work in round 4, 5, 6, and 7 in the last two drafts.

if we do draft a RB in round 4, the guy could very well be good enough to be a starter.

In comment 16494337 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

Not discounting the idea, but Schoen and Daboll have done some of their finest work in round 4, 5, 6, and 7 in the last two drafts.

I agree. I just think it's fair to be on the table.

to see them take a QB. I wouldn't think they would, but it wouldn't shock me.

I still say Milton fits the profile.

need a strong UDFA class after this draft.

three are still with the team (DeVito, Ford-Wheaton, Dyontae Johnson).

In comment 16494346 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

need a strong UDFA class after this draft.

Possibly the best thing about not having a 7th.. being able to work on identifying potential UDFAs a round early..

In comment 16494264 Go Terps said:

Quote:

Given that, both the Oregon kids Franklin and Irving are really fast. I'd target both.

They added a bunch of pieces to the trenches in FA and trades. It should be no surprise they needed to add to the secondary and WR position in the draft. But that won’t stop you from whining about the picks and jumping to “They clearly want to play basketball on grass” stupid ass comments. Should they have ignored these positions?

-

Haven’t had a back who can run tough between the tackles in forever

I’ve seen him play since the 5 grade, but does he fit our system? Or any system? He’s a power back, when most teams use the pass catching elusive backs these days. I think it would be great to get him. He’s a local kid who played at St Joes Regional and plays 100%. I feel Dabol and Kafka want a dual threat guy. Just my 2 cents.

Is an interesting one here if he’s being viewed as a TE. I think it’s not doubt going to be a TE or RB.

size and speed - make it so

In comment 16494325 Jim in Tampa said:

Quote:

I like Estime and Wright at RB. Johnson or Wilson at TE.

Exactly what I was going to post. Offense needs a boost early on today.

Get a TE and RB for this roster. Still some nice talent on board at both positions. Wouldn't even mind a trade up to get both right here in Round 4...quality over quantity.

In comment 16494367 3rdnlong said:

Quote:

I’ve seen him play since the 5 grade, but does he fit our system? Or any system? He’s a power back, when most teams use the pass catching elusive backs these days. I think it would be great to get him. He’s a local kid who played at St Joes Regional and plays 100%. I feel Dabol and Kafka want a dual threat guy. Just my 2 cents.

I want Estime or Wright. Theo Johnson if they are gone.

In comment 16494431 Rjanyg said:

Quote:

In comment 16494367 3rdnlong said: Quote: I’ve seen him play since the 5 grade, but does he fit our system? Or any system? He’s a power back, when most teams use the pass catching elusive backs these days. I think it would be great to get him. He’s a local kid who played at St Joes Regional and plays 100%. I feel Dabol and Kafka want a dual threat guy. Just my 2 cents. I want Estime or Wright. Theo Johnson if they are gone.

I can't get excited about Estime. Not explosive at all
. He's a guy who takes a lot of time to get to the line and gets run down from behind. He needs an offensive line that doesn't allow penetration. Name the last running back who ran 4.7 who had a good NFL career.
Is he even an improvement over Brightwell? Get the guy who can break a big play now (Wright please) and then the complimentary guy next year.

But dude could never put it all together. Wherever he goes I wish him the best. He has the potential to be very good

In comment 16494215 AcidTest said:

Quote:

are the remaining players who had 30 visits with the Giants: Spencer Rattler, QB South Carolina Tejhaun Palmer, WR UAB Audric Estime, RB Notre Dame (LOCAL) Theo Johnson, TE Penn St (LOCAL) Giovanni Manu, OT Univ of British Columbia Khristian Boyd, DT Northern Iowa Pheldarius Payne, DT Virginia Tech Tyrice Knight, LB UTEP Chau Smith-Wade, CB Washington St Evan Williams, DB Oregon Chigozie Anusiem, CB Colorado St Cam Hart, CB Notre Dame Jayden Hicks, S Washington St

Thanks very much for posting this … I was wondering the same but too lazy to do the work.

signed 5 vet free agents along the OL already, and currently have 14 on the roster. Since 25 OLs were already taken during the first 3 rounds, drafting an OL may not be in this year's plan.

Should they decided to draft one today, keep an eye on Beaux Limmer of Arkansas. He has proven he can play both guard and center, and his Razorback Pro Day workout was done by Giants new OL coach Carmen Bricillo. Clearly there was interest.

I’ll be very intrigued with Milton today.

.

Top level games, completed 64% of his passes for nearly 6000 yards with 44 TDs and only 7 Interceptions ??? And he’s not been talked about since he tore up his ankle in November. This guy is a winner and I hope Schabs takes a shot.

C'mon!

If so I would live him with the next pick.

Doesn't fit the track team mold though.

BPA & hopefully,it will align with our needs(TE,RB,DL,QB)

is an interesting story

I'd be a little surprised if they pass on him.

In comment 16494220 bwitz said:

Quote:

No sense in drafting any of the QBs left.

Not a Brock Purdy fan I presume?

The pick I want.

and whomever we have long term at QB could use an athletic TE with some size. Sanders is fine, but I prefer Theo Johnson from Penn St.

In comment 16494242 Anakim said:

Quote:

1) TE JT Sanders - Texas 2) RB Jaylen Wright - Tennessee 3) TE Cade Stover - Ohio State 4) DL Brandon Dorlus - Oregon 5) RB Ray Davis - Kentucky 6) ILB Cedric Gray - UNC 7) EDGE Austin Booker - Kansas I want Sanders or Wright in Round 4. Give me Sanders or Wright in Round 4!!!!

+1 Sanders or Wright for me too. Sanders would add something we don't have, can't believe he is still there. Wasn't he supposed to go in Rd 2?

TE - Sanders
TE - Stover
WR - Franklin

Get your RB in Rd 5

He’s raw, but good size and a good athlete. Not afraid to stick his nose in among DL. He needs to be coached up a bit, but I think he could be a good one.

and trade Slayton. Some good RB value to be had.

Decamerion Richardson is an intriguing prospect.

He is fast and athletic. 4.34 forty
He is long 6'-2" with 32 3/8 " arms.
He is only 188 lbs but he has the frame to put on weight.

He is stiff for corner and may not be able to play safety.
But he is a great athlete and two year starter at Miss. State

In comment 16494445 Spider56 said:

Quote:

In comment 16494215 AcidTest said: Quote: are the remaining players who had 30 visits with the Giants: Spencer Rattler, QB South Carolina Tejhaun Palmer, WR UAB Audric Estime, RB Notre Dame (LOCAL) Theo Johnson, TE Penn St (LOCAL) Giovanni Manu, OT Univ of British Columbia Khristian Boyd, DT Northern Iowa Pheldarius Payne, DT Virginia Tech Tyrice Knight, LB UTEP Chau Smith-Wade, CB Washington St Evan Williams, DB Oregon Chigozie Anusiem, CB Colorado St Cam Hart, CB Notre Dame Jayden Hicks, S Washington St Thanks very much for posting this … I was wondering the same but too lazy to do the work.

Happy to do it.

In comment 16494569 JonC said:

Quote:

and trade Slayton. Some good RB value to be had.

agree 💯

In comment 16494569 JonC said:

Quote:

and trade Slayton. Some good RB value to be had.

Interesting idea, but Schoen has already said he isn't trading Slayton. I'm also not sure what we could get for Slayton. Maybe a sixth. I assume most teams would rather draft a cheaper WR like Franklin today than trade for Slayton. Of course, a good argument can be made to take Franklin anyway, especially since Slayton is a FA after this year.

I would prefer an edge like Mohamed Kamara at #107. He's an undersized tweener, but had tremendous production as an edge. We also have nobody behind Burns and KT except Ojulari, who can't stay on the field, is also a FA in 2025, and like Slayton likely won't be here next year.

In comment 16494346 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

need a strong UDFA class after this draft.

Indeed

In comment 16494449 Y28 said:

Quote:

signed 5 vet free agents along the OL already, and currently have 14 on the roster. Since 25 OLs were already taken during the first 3 rounds, drafting an OL may not be in this year's plan. Should they decided to draft one today, keep an eye on Beaux Limmer of Arkansas. He has proven he can play both guard and center, and his Razorback Pro Day workout was done by Giants new OL coach Carmen Bricillo. Clearly there was interest.

Y28, do you have a preference for RB?

Brandon Dorlus, Kayvon Thibodeaux

Even if he doesn't become a star, he might be a fun name to see in the ***extremely unlikely event*** that Lock and Jones are not playing well or are injured.

:)

I'd hardly say we're set at receiver so if a guy like Franklin is there, so be it. Hyatt and Robinson could still go either way in their development.

In comment 16494399 ThomasG said:

Quote:

In comment 16494325 Jim in Tampa said: Quote: I like Estime and Wright at RB. Johnson or Wilson at TE. Exactly what I was going to post. Offense needs a boost early on today. Get a TE and RB for this roster. Still some nice talent on board at both positions. Wouldn't even mind a trade up to get both right here in Round 4...quality over quantity.

This... give me Wright and Johnson and i'll be ecstatic

.

In comment 16494316 Sean said:

Quote:

1. Jones is more broken down after another neck injury and ACL. 2. Assuming health (big assumption), Lock is a downgrade from Taylor. Unless the Giants like DeVito which I don't know, there needs to be something done here imo. They visited with Rattler, I'd take him if he was available in the 4th.

I actually like Lock better than Tyrod, I may like Lock better than DJ (at worst he is the same).

In comment 16494645 PatersonPlank said:

Quote:

In comment 16494316 Sean said: Quote: 1. Jones is more broken down after another neck injury and ACL. 2. Assuming health (big assumption), Lock is a downgrade from Taylor. Unless the Giants like DeVito which I don't know, there needs to be something done here imo. They visited with Rattler, I'd take him if he was available in the 4th. I actually like Lock better than Tyrod, I may like Lock better than DJ (at worst he is the same).

I think Lock is going to impress us in camp and preseason...

to get that gap penetrating DT, that would be my target. However, I do agree that we need to bolster TE and RB positions.

In comment 16494597 AcidTest said:

Quote:

In comment 16494569 JonC said: Quote: and trade Slayton. Some good RB value to be had. Interesting idea, but Schoen has already said he isn't trading Slayton. I'm also not sure what we could get for Slayton. Maybe a sixth. I assume most teams would rather draft a cheaper WR like Franklin today than trade for Slayton. Of course, a good argument can be made to take Franklin anyway, especially since Slayton is a FA after this year. I would prefer an edge like Mohamed Kamara at #107. He's an undersized tweener, but had tremendous production as an edge. We also have nobody behind Burns and KT except Ojulari, who can't stay on the field, is also a FA in 2025, and like Slayton likely won't be here next year.

It's less about Slayton and more about building a core. He'll be gone soon either way, or sitting on the bench, if the build goes to plan.

In fact, I’d like him to be extended because it’s an easy way to create some cap room.