for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Talkin' Giants - 2024 Giants Draft Recap

Klaatu : 4/29/2024 10:06 am
Quote:
00:00 Intro + Thoughts on the draft overall
3:40 Malik Nabers is awesome
6:00 Process of not taking a QB
15:25 Malik Nabers as a player
20:30 Safety Tyler Nubin
34:25 CB Andru Phillips
45:30 Giants did not draft any offensive lineman
49:10 TE Theo Johnson
57:30 RB Tyrone Tracy Jr
1:06:45 LB Darius Muasau
1:11:20 Wrap up + Thank you!


Link - ( New Window )
Their assertion that the 2020 draft was good  
Lambuth_Special : 4/29/2024 11:27 am : link
Was an interesting observation. Thomas and McKinney obviously hit, but it seems like they got all journeyman afterward. Apparently even getting journeyman on day 3 is an achievement but I feel like great teams hit on very good players a little bit more in those positions.
The killer is CB Andru Phillips ....  
Manny in CA : 4/29/2024 8:35 pm : link

Over guard Cooper Beebe (who went to the hated Cowpukes) in the 3rd round. He sends people airborne, landing on their asses and we get Andru Phillips with so many performance issues ???

I thought it was just me, but Bobby really justified my opinion.

Without this gigantic flubb, I would have given the Giants draft an "A+" score

Penik says they offered 6, 47, 107 & 2025 first for Maye  
Sean : 4/30/2024 7:50 am : link
.
RE: The killer is CB Andru Phillips ....  
section125 : 4/30/2024 7:56 am : link
In comment 16500016 Manny in CA said:
Quote:

Over guard Cooper Beebe (who went to the hated Cowpukes) in the 3rd round. He sends people airborne, landing on their asses and we get Andru Phillips with so many performance issues ???

I thought it was just me, but Bobby really justified my opinion.

Without this gigantic flubb, I would have given the Giants draft an "A+" score


My guess is they felt CB was a bigger concern. They needed CB, DT and you could throw in guard. My guess is they believe Bricillo will fix the players they have.
RE: The killer is CB Andru Phillips ....  
Mike in NY : 4/30/2024 7:57 am : link
In comment 16500016 Manny in CA said:
Quote:

Over guard Cooper Beebe (who went to the hated Cowpukes) in the 3rd round. He sends people airborne, landing on their asses and we get Andru Phillips with so many performance issues ???

I thought it was just me, but Bobby really justified my opinion.

Without this gigantic flubb, I would have given the Giants draft an "A+" score


There are some who absolutely rave about Dru Phillips pick. Beebe fell for a reason. Looks like a great run blocker, but there are glaring weaknesses in pass protection. Really short arms even by IOL standards and watching some clips he does not do a good job when asked to pull or be on the move.
RE: RE: The killer is CB Andru Phillips ....  
Fifty Six : 4/30/2024 8:33 am : link
In comment 16500375 Mike in NY said:
Quote:
In comment 16500016 Manny in CA said:


Quote:



Over guard Cooper Beebe (who went to the hated Cowpukes) in the 3rd round. He sends people airborne, landing on their asses and we get Andru Phillips with so many performance issues ???

I thought it was just me, but Bobby really justified my opinion.

Without this gigantic flubb, I would have given the Giants draft an "A+" score




There are some who absolutely rave about Dru Phillips pick. Beebe fell for a reason. Looks like a great run blocker, but there are glaring weaknesses in pass protection. Really short arms even by IOL standards and watching some clips he does not do a good job when asked to pull or be on the move.


Especially OL where scheme fit really matters. I love the Dru Phillips pick he's the type of player we need.
RE: Penik says they offered 6, 47, 107 & 2025 first for Maye  
Dr. D : 4/30/2024 9:37 am : link
In comment 16500366 Sean said:
Quote:
.

That's a lot. I'm personally glad it didn't happen.
RE: The killer is CB Andru Phillips ....  
CTGiants : 4/30/2024 9:38 am : link
In comment 16500016 Manny in CA said:
Quote:

Over guard Cooper Beebe (who went to the hated Cowpukes) in the 3rd round. He sends people airborne, landing on their asses and we get Andru Phillips with so many performance issues ???

I thought it was just me, but Bobby really justified my opinion.

It's like taking Darnay Holmes instead of Tyler Biadasz in 2020 when they didn't have a center, but to another level. Nothing against Holmes or Phillips, but when comparisons to the 2002 Texans flash across the screen every time you're on the clock maybe you should reconsider takin another DB
Without this gigantic flubb, I would have given the Giants draft an "A+" score
RE: The killer is CB Andru Phillips ....  
CTGiants : 4/30/2024 10:13 am : link
In comment 16500016 Manny in CA said:
Quote:

Over guard Cooper Beebe (who went to the hated Cowpukes) in the 3rd round. He sends people airborne, landing on their asses and we get Andru Phillips with so many performance issues ???

I thought it was just me, but Bobby really justified my opinion.

Without this gigantic flubb, I would have given the Giants draft an "A+" score


I screwed up the last post, these are my comments.

It's like taking Darnay Holmes instead of Tyler Biadasz in 2020 when they didn't have a center, but to another level. Nothing against Holmes or Phillips, but when comparisons to the 2002 Texans flash across the screen every time you're on the clock maybe you should reconsider takin another DB
Back to the Corner