The Jones topic has been beaten to death. This guy was drafted for his YAC and was straight up terrible last night. It seems like every week we see players our defense miss and extend drives.
And Robinson is flirting with it. He’s a fine player as your 4th option maybe but this offense will continue to be comically terrible if he’s going to be relied on to do anything of substance on a regular basis
Exactly. Small frame, small hands and a small target. A guy like this cannot have drops.
He's quick and gets open. However he never (rarely) beats the first tackler or breaks a tackle. He had a few plays last night that could have made a huge difference, th swing pass near the goalline and the drop on 4th and 6. Do you think Cooper Kupp would have not beaten one guy and got into the endzone on that swing pass? That play was drawn up exactly for that situation, and it was pretty much perfect.
Guys like him are a dime a dozen in the NFL
He's a solid player, ideally the 3rd or 4th best option
in an offense. A dozen plus targets and expecting him to break tackles every play and get YAC is too much to ask. He wasn't flawless last night but played a good game.
Blame the head coach for wasting 15-20 downs running into 8 man fronts and blame the QB for being unable to connect on any throws when WRs were wide open behind the defense before you blame Wandale for last night.
And Robinson is flirting with it. He’s a fine player as your 4th option maybe but this offense will continue to be comically terrible if he’s going to be relied on to do anything of substance on a regular basis
Field awareness is something some players don't have. He has to be better with it. And his size isn't an issue - his arm length is, however. It limits his catch radius. His ADOT is 4.7 yards. That makes reliance on the YAC. It forces yards after contact and if not, the drive can falter. Daboll's coaching it this way.
He got 1st downs twice on 3rd down with his YAC. 2nd half not as good.
I think he can be a very valuable NFL player in tbe right role. On the right team he's the opposing player who is picking up 3rd and 6 all the time and you're yelling at the TV - Damnit, how is he open? How did we miss that tackle? Why can't our D get off the field?
had a bad second half, it happens. He has limited room to operate since we can’t extend the field deep or run the ball. Dallas really swarmed him after half time, basically jumped on the underneath stuff since Jones couldn’t connect deep. Credit to them. Wandale is a good player.
RE: The major problem is he was taken ahead of Pickens
Wandale isn't Darren Sproles, and the pick was a fit rather than based on talent on the board. Since the ACL, he doesn't have the shiftiness he needs.
That headcase was throwing tantrums because he wasn't getting enough passes on a winning team. He doesn't have the mental fortitude to survive losing in NY. If the Giants drafted him they would have had to trade him for peanuts by now when he refused to play.
Wandale Robinson is much better at football than Daniel Jones
Wan'Dale Robinson is a jag, he took what was given to him last night. A few plays he made the player miss, but for the most part he ran short of the sticks and stayed short of the sticks. His drop on a contested catch was horrendous and he is not a slot receiver I would want on a team I am building for the future.
50% of his yards have been after the catch this year
Wan'Dale Robinson is a jag, he took what was given to him last night. A few plays he made the player miss, but for the most part he ran short of the sticks and stayed short of the sticks. His drop on a contested catch was horrendous and he is not a slot receiver I would want on a team I am building for the future.
The defense knows where the sticks are too, can’t just always be conveniently on or past them and expect to also be open. Especially when you have no run game and can’t connect on a deep pass.
Then Wan'dale has to win more of the battles than he did
for me to think of him as anything more than an average (jag) slot receiver. Last night, he did not win enough of those behind the sticks and getting a first down.
RE: RE: 50% of his yards have been after the catch this year
Wan'Dale but they needed him to break that tackle or at least avoid him in any way on that goal line play. Daboll drew it up expecting Dallas to double Nabers and they did, and Wan'Dale got one on one with a pass on the line and in space. That should be an easy TD.
RE: RE: RE: 50% of his yards have been after the catch this year
You know good teams have average players right? Who is Josh Allen throwing to this year?
I do know that, but let's face it we can pick up average players for cheap. This is his third year and soon a decision will have to be made on him and I have not seen anything that leads me to want to resign him to a second contract unless it is as cheap as i can get a JAG in FA
Have a habit of overrating certain players and more often than not, it feels like it's lineman on other teams (Will Hernandez for instance) or receivers. Richie James was one from a few seasons ago. He went to KC and couldn't crack their lineup or perform very much when he played with Mahomes.
Robinson's ADOT is and will be small because his arms are short. It makes most pass routes and situations limited.
he's a very small target with short arms so every throw has to be pinpoint.
Then he has inconsistent hands and he lacks awareness on the field.
I can't believe Schoen traded up into the 2nd round for this player....smh
63 of 124 yards after the catch. Robinsons YAC isn’t the problem.
Someone said it above, he's got some Barkley in him.
His awareness of where he is on the field is lacking...whether its cutting back when its unnecessary or not realizing where the sticks are.
It seems to be there are spots where its apparent just get the first down - and he's cutting and trying to do more than necessary. And this is third down I'm taking about.
he's a very small target with short arms so every throw has to be pinpoint.
Then he has inconsistent hands and he lacks awareness on the field.
I can't believe Schoen traded up into the 2nd round for this player....smh
Thought it was a reach at the time myself - esp for a player that size.
He's a useful player with some interesting skills, but the upside is limited by his size. He's got quicks and some speed, but it's not otherworldly by any means. That's not a second round player.
He's the kind of guy that would soak up a lot of yards on a team like KC, but as others have said Pickens would have been a better fit on profile alone. Wandale as the #2 receiver is not a good receiver corps and he overlaps a bit with Nabers.
Need to take him off the field in those scenarios.
Historically bad catch radius, and completing a pass to him beyond 5 yards of the LOS is low probability. No sense in having him out there. They should have Hyatt, Slayton, and Nabers working out of the slot on 3rd and long. Even Hodgins would be better.
I think he is being forced into a #2 receiver role, when in actuality he is a #3. He is being forced in a role higher than what he is capable of due to the struggles of Hyatt and to a lesser extent Slayton. The Giants need to improve the WR position outside of Nabers.
Put him in tge backfield on 3rd down as a recieving back. He played RB in college and his skillset is that of a Devon Achane, Darren Sproles type RB iWamda the passing game. Wandale vs a LB is a great mismatch. He doesnt do so well against DBs.
Put him in the backfield on 3rd down as a recieving back. He played RB in college and his skillset is that of a Devon Achane, Darren Sproles type RB in the passing game. Wandale vs a LB is a great mismatch. He doesnt do so well against DBs.
The Giants don't have any margin of error, so he's got to make those plays.
Hyatt and the TEs are doing nothing. The pass catchers are Nabers, Nabers, Nabers, Robinson, Robinson and Slayton. Everybody else maybe gets a target or two and an occasional catch. So Robinson has to catch the catchable balls. When he doesn't, it's a big problem.
But not all “YAC” is the same. Some “YAC” is by schematic design which is what a lot of what Robinson does comes from. Other “YAC” comes from making the first tackler miss, making a cut, and creating yards not through scheme but through your own playmaking ability.
One or two plays from him last night probably wins the game. Like I said, I’m a fan but that was disappointing.
This is a slot receiver who is able to get open just about any time he wants... AND he has good hands.
Fans should be glad he is on our team.
Mostly agree. I do think yesterday especially his drops were one thing, but consistently running routes just short of the sticks is another. He has to know where the sticks are. He usually shows the ability to wiggle for at least an extra couple of yards. Not on a number of plays yesterday. Some of that is ball placement, some the D, and some is just get past the sticks before breaking.
RE: RE: The football IQ of the average Giants' fan..
This is a slot receiver who is able to get open just about any time he wants... AND he has good hands.
Fans should be glad he is on our team.
Mostly agree. I do think yesterday especially his drops were one thing, but consistently running routes just short of the sticks is another. He has to know where the sticks are. He usually shows the ability to wiggle for at least an extra couple of yards. Not on a number of plays yesterday. Some of that is ball placement, some the D, and some is just get past the sticks before breaking.
I agree with running to the sticks. Cannot argue with that and it is something I criticized WRs for quite often.
There are other factors here though. Often times especially on 3rd down the defender plants his feet at the sticks. This means the WR may have no choice but to take something underneath just to get the ball. Not optimal but it is a reality.
We really need better route designs in these situations. Too often I saw two guys running routes short of the sticks and then one very deep. Makes no sense to me and there it seemed more like scheme vs a WR decision.
I watched the game with the sound off and phone/BBI down. I find the criticism of WR absurd. He was playing his guts out. Whether it was by play design or something else [cough DJ], the passes were short, the WRs weren’t thrown open, and the defense was bunched up pounding the WRs on every play. I wasn’t surprised MN was hurt, I didn’t know how long he could hold up on under that intentional physical abuse. Scapegoating WR and every other player without the initials MN is not borderline delusional it is flat out delusional.
The ball should have been thrown earlier. Can’t just stop on a dime, physics took him OOB and that was that.
Exactly. Small frame, small hands and a small target. A guy like this cannot have drops.
He is nifty at getting open on slants and flat routes under the linebackers and has a niche fit in that area.
Guys like him are a dime a dozen in the NFL
Blame the head coach for wasting 15-20 downs running into 8 man fronts and blame the QB for being unable to connect on any throws when WRs were wide open behind the defense before you blame Wandale for last night.
Field awareness is something some players don't have. He has to be better with it. And his size isn't an issue - his arm length is, however. It limits his catch radius. His ADOT is 4.7 yards. That makes reliance on the YAC. It forces yards after contact and if not, the drive can falter. Daboll's coaching it this way.
I think he can be a very valuable NFL player in tbe right role. On the right team he's the opposing player who is picking up 3rd and 6 all the time and you're yelling at the TV - Damnit, how is he open? How did we miss that tackle? Why can't our D get off the field?
That headcase was throwing tantrums because he wasn't getting enough passes on a winning team. He doesn't have the mental fortitude to survive losing in NY. If the Giants drafted him they would have had to trade him for peanuts by now when he refused to play.
Wan'Dale Robinson is a jag, he took what was given to him last night. A few plays he made the player miss, but for the most part he ran short of the sticks and stayed short of the sticks. His drop on a contested catch was horrendous and he is not a slot receiver I would want on a team I am building for the future.
He is an average slot receiver at best.
Quote:
Is. Robinson has a future on this team.
Wan'Dale Robinson is a jag, he took what was given to him last night. A few plays he made the player miss, but for the most part he ran short of the sticks and stayed short of the sticks. His drop on a contested catch was horrendous and he is not a slot receiver I would want on a team I am building for the future.
The defense knows where the sticks are too, can’t just always be conveniently on or past them and expect to also be open. Especially when you have no run game and can’t connect on a deep pass.
Quote:
He is not a JAG
He is an average slot receiver at best.
Let’s say for fun and games this is accurate.
You know good teams have average players right? Who is Josh Allen throwing to this year?
Quote:
In comment 16627373 ajr2456 said:
Quote:
He is not a JAG
He is an average slot receiver at best.
Let’s say for fun and games this is accurate.
You know good teams have average players right? Who is Josh Allen throwing to this year?
I do know that, but let's face it we can pick up average players for cheap. This is his third year and soon a decision will have to be made on him and I have not seen anything that leads me to want to resign him to a second contract unless it is as cheap as i can get a JAG in FA
Robinson's ADOT is and will be small because his arms are short. It makes most pass routes and situations limited.
Then he has inconsistent hands and he lacks awareness on the field.
I can't believe Schoen traded up into the 2nd round for this player....smh
Giants behind the curve yet again.
Someone said it above, he's got some Barkley in him.
His awareness of where he is on the field is lacking...whether its cutting back when its unnecessary or not realizing where the sticks are.
It seems to be there are spots where its apparent just get the first down - and he's cutting and trying to do more than necessary. And this is third down I'm taking about.
Guys are small int the NFL but physically strong where they can get tough yards.
Robinson isn't getting any tough yards. Zero.
I think there's a place for him but when he's the #2 option, it's going to be average at best.
Then he has inconsistent hands and he lacks awareness on the field.
I can't believe Schoen traded up into the 2nd round for this player....smh
Thought it was a reach at the time myself - esp for a player that size.
He's the kind of guy that would soak up a lot of yards on a team like KC, but as others have said Pickens would have been a better fit on profile alone. Wandale as the #2 receiver is not a good receiver corps and he overlaps a bit with Nabers.
Historically bad catch radius, and completing a pass to him beyond 5 yards of the LOS is low probability. No sense in having him out there. They should have Hyatt, Slayton, and Nabers working out of the slot on 3rd and long. Even Hodgins would be better.
His catches are in effect, carries.
I like his skill-set, it's useful to any modern day NFL team. But I was very disappointed in his 2nd half performance last night.
Has no get away capability. For being this small supposedly fast guy, he is not elusive.
He goes down easily, and is too small to break tackles.
While a good target and should be used, the lacking TE spot and focus is where Jones is going with Wandale
He needs less touches and TE's need more
Blew the game multiples times last night in the 2nd half.
The Giants don't have any margin of error, so he's got to make those plays.
Hyatt and the TEs are doing nothing. The pass catchers are Nabers, Nabers, Nabers, Robinson, Robinson and Slayton. Everybody else maybe gets a target or two and an occasional catch. So Robinson has to catch the catchable balls. When he doesn't, it's a big problem.
This is a slot receiver who is able to get open just about any time he wants... AND he has good hands.
Fans should be glad he is on our team.
I’ll settle for 1.
This is a slot receiver who is able to get open just about any time he wants... AND he has good hands.
Fans should be glad he is on our team.
Agreed. He had a bad game yesterday with some drops but he has converted a lot of 3rd downs for us and except for yesterday has gotten a lot of YAC.
I think people are overreacting to yesterday's game.
One or two plays from him last night probably wins the game. Like I said, I’m a fan but that was disappointing.
This is a slot receiver who is able to get open just about any time he wants... AND he has good hands.
Fans should be glad he is on our team.
Quote:
is on par with the team's record.
This is a slot receiver who is able to get open just about any time he wants... AND he has good hands.
Fans should be glad he is on our team.
Mostly agree. I do think yesterday especially his drops were one thing, but consistently running routes just short of the sticks is another. He has to know where the sticks are. He usually shows the ability to wiggle for at least an extra couple of yards. Not on a number of plays yesterday. Some of that is ball placement, some the D, and some is just get past the sticks before breaking.
I agree with running to the sticks. Cannot argue with that and it is something I criticized WRs for quite often.
There are other factors here though. Often times especially on 3rd down the defender plants his feet at the sticks. This means the WR may have no choice but to take something underneath just to get the ball. Not optimal but it is a reality.
We really need better route designs in these situations. Too often I saw two guys running routes short of the sticks and then one very deep. Makes no sense to me and there it seemed more like scheme vs a WR decision.