for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

pff grades vs cowboys

Hilary : 9/28/2024 6:38 am
Author notes that right guard has not been a strength for the team. Giants have 10 days off. This would be a good time to try to get Neal ready for a few snaps at right guard. A major weakness of the JS tenure has been evaluating the talent on the roster. He went into 2023 thinking he could get by playing Ezeudu and Mckethan. This year he seems to have over- rated the support that Davidson, Nachos and Riley could give to Dex. He needs to see if Neal can help the run game as a guard.
pff gades - ( New Window )
Nabers vs Jones  
giantstock : 9/28/2024 11:34 am : link
So, the long passes Jones missed on with Nabers he gets covered by the short passes he made?

While the long passes that Nabers didn't receive from Jones misses he gets no credit for?
An important question about Schoen's talent evaluation is  
ConsistentGiantFan : 9/28/2024 12:11 pm : link
who is feeding him information on the talent of the candidates. Who are the influence peddlers.
Clearly the process is subpar and can and should be improved.
you put Eleumonor  
Dave on the UWS : 9/28/2024 1:12 pm : link
at RG (a position he HAS played before), and you put Neal back in at RT.
Neal has NEVER taken one snap at guard at the pro level, even in practice. That kind of change shouldn't be done during a season. Besides, Schoen has said "he's a tackle". They will live or die with that assessment.
RE: you put Eleumonor  
Ivan15 : 9/28/2024 2:12 pm : link
In comment 16629182 Dave on the UWS said:
Quote:
at RG (a position he HAS played before), and you put Neal back in at RT.
Neal has NEVER taken one snap at guard at the pro level, even in practice. That kind of change shouldn't be done during a season. Besides, Schoen has said "he's a tackle". They will live or die with that assessment.
________
Who is suggesting that, Dave? Hilary was the thread starter. I agree that the only way Neal should play at RG is if there are a couple of in-game injuries. He needs a training camp to make a permanent switch.
How does Hyatt have  
mullica : 9/28/2024 3:52 pm : link
a higher grade than Wandale?
Back to the Corner