for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

2025 QB Thread - Beck/Milroe Edition

jeffro1 : 9/28/2024 7:32 pm
After we got Ward last night, we get a treat tonight with Beck and Milroe in one game. Beck came into this season as the highest rated 2025 prospect. Milroe also highly thought of (with Sy mentioning him as someone he has his eye on in an Inside BBI episode). Personally, I was excited to see what Milroe could do in DeBoer’s offense after Penix thrived under him.

Beck started with a strong game against Clemson. Then lit up an over matched Tennessee Tech and then struggled against what looks like a tough Kentucky defense (who upset Ole Miss today).

Milroe has not been asked to do a ton yet this year throwing the ball but put up 5 TDs against Wisconsin.

This will be a nice test for both prospects. Get yer popcorn ready!

Yes, this will be a  
section125 : 9/28/2024 7:36 pm : link
good match up. Not a fan of Cam Ward, yet.
Is Schoen at  
Koffman : 9/28/2024 8:05 pm : link
the game?
-  
jeffro1 : 9/28/2024 8:18 pm : link
First two rounds to Milroe — using his legs, hitting open receivers and nice touch ball on a wheel route to the RB.

If there was a game for Schoen to go to, this would be it…
Wow Milroe  
giantstock : 9/28/2024 8:19 pm : link
Damn.
Awful possession for Beck  
jeffro1 : 9/28/2024 8:27 pm : link
Misread coverage and almost threw an INT and then for good measure threw a terrible ball on what looked like a poorly executed WR screen for an INT.

Wow just wow.
RE: Yes, this will be a  
Big Blue Hokie : 9/28/2024 8:36 pm : link
In comment 16629520 section125 said:
Quote:
good match up. Not a fan of Cam Ward, yet.


👆🏻 This. I was not impressed at all with Ward.

It is a hard no on Beck as of now.
I would be thrilled  
Jon In NYC : 9/28/2024 8:41 pm : link
with either Milroe or Ward. Way more excited about this upcoming class than I was before the year started. Always happens that way.
Milroe  
jeffro1 : 9/28/2024 8:42 pm : link
On the read option on 4th and 1 makes the correct read and outruns Georgia for a TD.

His legs are a legit weapon…
Good lord  
Giantophile : 9/28/2024 8:43 pm : link
Just give me Milroe. Beck doesn't do it for me. I know he's having a bad game but I've never been a fan
for me qb for giants in draft is  
jomanc : 9/28/2024 8:45 pm : link
milroe. love his speed to passing ability. becks stock is falling rapidly
One guy has Deboer  
BigBlueCane : 9/28/2024 8:50 pm : link
the other has Mike Bobo, a fossil from the 90s SEC.
Beck losing money  
Longtimelurker : 9/28/2024 9:11 pm : link
Reminds me of Matt Barkley going from top pick to 4th rounder.
Brutal half for Beck  
jeffro1 : 9/28/2024 9:11 pm : link
Another bad INT…

I don’t want to overreact to one half of football but yuck.
RE: RE: Yes, this will be a  
Maggot Brain : 9/28/2024 9:12 pm : link
In comment 16629601 Big Blue Hokie said:
Quote:
In comment 16629520 section125 said:


Quote:


good match up. Not a fan of Cam Ward, yet.

How can you watch Ward and not be a fan? Even with an average game last night, he made multiple throws Daniel Jones couldn't even dream of throwing. And with that average game he threw for 300 plus and brought his team back from 10 down with ten minutes to go.



👆🏻 This. I was not impressed at all with Ward.

It is a hard no on Beck as of now.
Beck has tunnel vision  
beatrixkiddo : 9/28/2024 9:17 pm : link
No even seeing defenders dropping into the passing lanes. Rough night for the kid.
Beck looks the real deal  
giantstock : 9/28/2024 9:18 pm : link
Of a Daniel Jones clone.

Dave Gettlemen where are you?
This is one of the worst halves of football  
Giantophile : 9/28/2024 9:19 pm : link
I've ever seen a QB play. Absolutely abysmal
Schoen not at the game  
Professor Falken : 9/28/2024 9:36 pm : link
but Giants have scouts there:

NFLPreme
@premefootball
Lions GM Brad Holmes and Bears GM Ryan Poles are set to attend tonight’s highly anticipated showdown between Alabama and Georgia. This matchup could significantly influence their draft plans as they assess potential franchise players.

Scouts from 16 other teams will also be watching, but surprisingly, Holmes and Poles are the only GMs confirmed to attend. Teams represented include the Bears, Browns, Colts, Chargers, Dolphins, Eagles, Giants, Lions, Raiders, Saints, Steelers, Seahawks, 49ers, and Vikings.
Let’s trade nabors  
armstead98 : 9/28/2024 9:42 pm : link
For Beck
RE: Let’s trade nabors  
giantstock : 9/28/2024 9:51 pm : link
In comment 16629738 armstead98 said:
Quote:
For Beck


Let's not.

But as A Gianst fan that you must be, let's be happy with no shot to ever win a title going forward.
RE: RE: RE: Yes, this will be a  
section125 : 9/28/2024 10:00 pm : link
In comment 16629686 Maggot Brain said:
Quote:
In comment 16629601 Big Blue Hokie said:


Quote:


In comment 16629520 section125 said:


Quote:


good match up. Not a fan of Cam Ward, yet.

How can you watch Ward and not be a fan? Even with an average game last night, he made multiple throws Daniel Jones couldn't even dream of throwing. And with that average game he threw for 300 plus and brought his team back from 10 down with ten minutes to go.



👆🏻 This. I was not impressed at all with Ward.

It is a hard no on Beck as of now.



Quote:
How can you watch Ward and not be a fan? Even with an average game last night, he made multiple throws Daniel Jones couldn't even dream of throwing. And with that average game he threw for 300 plus and brought his team back from 10 down with ten minutes to go.


Because I'm not a fan yet. He seems a bit dicey to me. I watch him and simply think, no.

This is not about what throws Jones cannot make. It is about can Ward make those throws in the NFL. I have not been impressed.
I was down on Milroe last year,  
Section331 : 9/28/2024 10:48 pm : link
I thought he was really inaccurate. But he certainly has all the tools, and I was intrigued to see how he would do playing for deBoer. It seems to be working.
RE: Schoen not at the game  
Giantsfan79 : 9/28/2024 11:12 pm : link
In comment 16629725 Professor Falken said:
Quote:
but Giants have scouts there:

NFLPreme
@premefootball
Lions GM Brad Holmes and Bears GM Ryan Poles are set to attend tonight’s highly anticipated showdown between Alabama and Georgia. This matchup could significantly influence their draft plans as they assess potential franchise players.

Scouts from 16 other teams will also be watching, but surprisingly, Holmes and Poles are the only GMs confirmed to attend. Teams represented include the Bears, Browns, Colts, Chargers, Dolphins, Eagles, Giants, Lions, Raiders, Saints, Steelers, Seahawks, 49ers, and Vikings.


makes you wonder how the hell every NFL team isn't represented at this one
I kept watching for some reason  
black aces : 9/28/2024 11:12 pm : link
glad I did
Holy Shit  
giantstock : 9/28/2024 11:15 pm : link
Holy SHit!!!!!!!!!!!!
WOW  
RomanWH : 9/28/2024 11:15 pm : link
This game is turning into an instant classic.
Holy shit  
dancing blue bear : 9/28/2024 11:15 pm : link
What a turn
MILROE ANSWERS  
bigbluewillrise : 9/28/2024 11:16 pm : link
wow
some shit  
black aces : 9/28/2024 11:17 pm : link
defense
This is  
jeffro1 : 9/28/2024 11:17 pm : link
Absolutely NUTS!!!
RE: Schoen not at the game  
JoeyBigBlue : 9/28/2024 11:22 pm : link
In comment 16629725 Professor Falken said:
Quote:
but Giants have scouts there:

NFLPreme
@premefootball
Lions GM Brad Holmes and Bears GM Ryan Poles are set to attend tonight’s highly anticipated showdown between Alabama and Georgia. This matchup could significantly influence their draft plans as they assess potential franchise players.

Scouts from 16 other teams will also be watching, but surprisingly, Holmes and Poles are the only GMs confirmed to attend. Teams represented include the Bears, Browns, Colts, Chargers, Dolphins, Eagles, Giants, Lions, Raiders, Saints, Steelers, Seahawks, 49ers, and Vikings.



Makes me think these guys aren’t as highly thought of by NFL teams as they are by fans.
Back to the Corner