Sy56 QB early draft assessment prior to college 2024 season

Gotta finish bottom 2

Have Ewers.

Beck & Ewers sound like Jones 2.0

milroe has 1 running td and 1 passing td. alabama up 14-0. Still early.

1-16, and a top ‘25 qb selection is within reach…..

not been impressed when I've seen him.

are a lot of top QB prospect. Ward, Ewers, and Milroe lead the pack for me. However Beck, Dart, Nussmeier are also good

just threw his 2nd interception at end of 2nd quarter. Sy's pre-season opinion was right on and milroe may end up being his choice for giants if they get the chance.

Not sure he does anything well.

I’d rank them

1. Milroe
2. Ward
3. Ewers
4. Sanders (undraftable personality)
5. Allar
6. Miller Moss
7. Beck
8. Dart

on any top ten list. Keeping LSU in games as the Tigers defense is trash.

i would keep daniel jones over beck

In comment 16629698 jomanc said:

Quote:

i would keep daniel jones over beck

Milroe is currently murdering Georgia while Beck looks like Daniel Jones 2.0.

In comment 16629685 Breeze_94 said:

Quote:

Not sure he does anything well. I’d rank them 1. Milroe 2. Ward 3. Ewers 4. Sanders (undraftable personality) 5. Allar 6. Miller Moss 7. Beck 8. Dart

I'd be shocked if Sanders is on the Giants board.

In comment 16629720 FStubbs said:

Quote:

In comment 16629685 Breeze_94 said: Quote: Not sure he does anything well. I’d rank them 1. Milroe 2. Ward 3. Ewers 4. Sanders (undraftable personality) 5. Allar 6. Miller Moss 7. Beck 8. Dart I'd be shocked if Sanders is on the Giants board.

Sanders would be eaten alive in NY. I don’t think he has “it”.

Unfortunately the Giants continue to suck at the wrong time, or make the wrong draft choices…Hope I’m wrong, but this smells like the 2013 draft class.

In comment 16629743 lax counsel said:

Quote:

Unfortunately the Giants continue to suck at the wrong time, or make the wrong draft choices…Hope I’m wrong, but this smells like the 2013 draft class.

You are nuts. Milroe and ward are STUDS.

Will be available next week. More than willing to discuss then.

In comment 16629757 crooza172 said:

Quote:

In comment 16629743 lax counsel said: Quote: Unfortunately the Giants continue to suck at the wrong time, or make the wrong draft choices…Hope I’m wrong, but this smells like the 2013 draft class. You are nuts. Milroe and ward are STUDS.

Face palm to the head….uhhhh

Is still early but none of these guys seem that impressive yet and i dont trust Alabama QBs

In comment 16629743 lax counsel said:

Quote:

Unfortunately the Giants continue to suck at the wrong time, or make the wrong draft choices…Hope I’m wrong, but this smells like the 2013 draft class.

I must say, I’m a bit disappointed. After huddlin up at the clubhouse, the best the DJFC came out of the meetings with are the predictable “everyone sucks in this draft” talking point? Boooo. Was hoping for something a little more creative but it’s certainly not surprising. When’s the next meeting? I look forward to the riveting discussions on why the Giants should just move forward with Jones for another year

Beck has now dropped to 4

Milroe 27/33 374 yds, 2 passing tds and 2 rushing tds. and 1 int. rushed for 117 yds with 2 tds. Beck did have a better 2nd half but had 3 int's and 1 fumble loss

In comment 16629848 BigBlueShock said:

Quote:

In comment 16629743 lax counsel said: Quote: Unfortunately the Giants continue to suck at the wrong time, or make the wrong draft choices…Hope I’m wrong, but this smells like the 2013 draft class. I must say, I’m a bit disappointed. After huddlin up at the clubhouse, the best the DJFC came out of the meetings with are the predictable “everyone sucks in this draft” talking point? Boooo. Was hoping for something a little more creative but it’s certainly not surprising. When’s the next meeting? I look forward to the riveting discussions on why the Giants should just move forward with Jones for another year

I may be wrong but I don't think Lax is known as a Jones defender.

Mil looked the part that’s for sure. I watched ward versus tech, he looked kinda shaky at times and absolutely dynamic others. He made some insane throws and a few head scratchers.

Overall though I think he has a ton of tools and Daboll would love a qb like him

He made big plays last night with his arm and legs against a top defense. Right now I'd love to see him in Giant Blue.

He's accurate but so many of his passes aren't tight spirals, they wobble. And his arm doesn't look good enough.
Best arm and tight spiral I've seen this year is Johnson from Kansas State. Unfortunately he's just a sophomore. More bad timing for Giants.

Sy was spot on once again in his early assessment here. Milroe's "superstar potential" was fulfilled last night in what can only be described as Milroe's signature moment in his quest for the Heisman Trophy this year. I saw a guy with a "sky's the limit" ceiling - a ceiling as good or better than any of the quarterbacks that were drafted in the first round of 2024.

2025 should be a much more interesting quarterback class than I had previously thought. Maybe there is reason to hope again in East Rutherford...

Not really a fan of Shedeur Sanders (I prefer Milroe or Ward) but I thought one of Sy's comments about Shedeur was a little odd. Sy said:

"One thing that I am concerned by is the fact that his dad has been his coach or OC since high school. Do we even know if this kid can manage on his own?"

I know that everyone wants to factor Deion into a Shedeur evaluation. But don't all QBs at every level have coaches that coach them up to help them get better? And once they're on the field, don't all QBs have to manage on their own?

Not to mention the fact that in all other cases I can remember, when an NFL player grew up as a football coach's son, it's almost always presented as a positive thing and an advantage for the player.

So why would being a coach's son now somehow be a disadvantage for Shedeur? And why would he have trouble managing on his own, just because his father has been his coach?

In comment 16629760 Sy'56 said:

Quote:

Will be available next week. More than willing to discuss then.

like rapid dogs going after a bone, I think this website will take you up on your offer

Keeps on winning and putting up numbers. Not a running QB but seems to see the field and hit open receivers. Impressed with what Cignetti has done with the Indiana program. Seeing them against Michigan and Ohio State will be fun.

He can crank it up vs. big competition.

He is a strong kid with a strong arm and can run enough to cause defenses fits.

with a legitimate Offensive mind coaching him and not Mike Bobo whose stuck in the 90s.

Has the best name.

Beck kinna sucks in the games I've watched.

.