Favorite College QBs

.

In comment 16649406 Jack Stroud said:

Quote:

.

"DJ is not the answer." It is stated in the OP above.

You are taking your obtuseness/trolling to a whole new level here. Are you proud of that?

But I’d be fine fine with Sanders, Ward or Nussmeier

In comment 16649439 Mike from Ohio said:

Quote:

In comment 16649406 Jack Stroud said: Quote: . "DJ is not the answer." It is stated in the OP above. You are taking your obtuseness/trolling to a whole new level here. Are you proud of that?

Shamrocks must have tapped out and now it is Jack's turn to troll.

In comment 16649442 ajr2456 said:

Quote:

But I’d be fine fine with Sanders, Ward or Nussmeier

Subject to change as there is a lot of football left, but I would have no problem with any of the first three you named. Non-committal on Nussmeier just because I have not seen him play yet and know little about him (other than bw's man crush).

Nussmeier, Milton, Rourke, Sanders, undecided

In comment 16649443 56goat said:

Quote:

In comment 16649439 Mike from Ohio said: Quote: In comment 16649406 Jack Stroud said: Quote: . "DJ is not the answer." It is stated in the OP above. You are taking your obtuseness/trolling to a whole new level here. Are you proud of that? Shamrocks must have tapped out and now it is Jack's turn to troll.

An underrated part of the DJ's tenure (hopefully) nearing its end is that Jack Stroud, Eightshamrocks, and whatever other Cowboys/Eagles fans that are here masquerading as DJ enthusiasts (is there any other explanation?) will finally go away.

In comment 16649447 bw in dc said:

Quote:

Nussmeier, Milton, Rourke, Sanders, undecided

Who is Milton?

In comment 16649452 KDavies said:

Quote:

In comment 16649447 bw in dc said: Quote: Nussmeier, Milton, Rourke, Sanders, undecided Who is Milton?

Milroe, sorry.

but that’s subject to change

Matt Slutka
Kurtis Rourke
Taylor Green
Will Howard

Ward, Milroe, Sanders, Ewers, or Beck

Ward #1, Milroe #2, Sanders a distant #3

A good one

Milroe, Sanders and Ward feel like the highest ceiling guys I have seen so far. Haven't seen enough of Nussmeier but trust BW when it comes to all things college football. And not only is Nussmeier following in the footsteps of Burrow and Daniels, but his father Doug played quarterback for the New Orleans Saints. That may be Nussmeier's greatest asset in the eyes of Mara!

he came from a small school, and really hasn't played anyone much yet. His games vs Michigan and Ohio St will have a huge role on his draft status.

Of note, so far there have been

1. Ward
2. Milroe
3. Beck
4. Sanders
5. Ewers
6. Sluka
7. Rourke
8. Green
9. Howard
10. Nussmeier

Pretty deep draft for QBs. Would be shocked if the Giants don't get one, even if they go elsewhere in the 1st

Never was onboard with this class.

In comment 16649459 Earl the goat said:

Quote:

Matt Slutka Kurtis Rourke Taylor Green Will Howard

Howard does nothing for me. His bone headed play in Oregon was a bad look.

Rourke is very underrated.

Green is an interesting idea, too...love the athleticism.

No Ward?

You were huge on him last year. Cooling off on him or an oversight?

For Dart. Think he can be an interesting round 2 guy.

He's my guy.

#GoCanes!

In comment 16649468 The_Boss said:

Quote:

Never was onboard with this class.

So just no QB at all, not even outside of the 1st? Strange.

Ward

In comment 16649442 ajr2456 said:

Quote:

But I’d be fine fine with Sanders, Ward or Nussmeier

And statistically 2 of those guys will be out of the league in 4 years, one of them will be DJ type of average QB and one will be a star...

but Dillon Gabriel is growing on me. All he does is put the ball on the money.

is off the board for me. Too much baggage and downside risk.

From Penn State. He’s got all of the tools.

In comment 16649467 KDavies said:

Quote:

he came from a small school, and really hasn't played anyone much yet. His games vs Michigan and Ohio St will have a huge role on his draft status. Of note, so far there have been 1. Ward 2. Milroe 3. Beck 4. Sanders 5. Ewers 6. Sluka 7. Rourke 8. Green 9. Howard 10. Nussmeier Pretty deep draft for QBs. Would be shocked if the Giants don't get one, even if they go elsewhere in the 1st

I like several on this list. Several more than others so far but really want to see a few more key conference matchups to see who holds up to the pressure.

But no reason whatsoever not to select a QB in this next draft. Stop looking for the perfect transformation guy in a college uniform and select someone with some + attributes and go from there.

The top QBs have had good games and not so good games. Sanders might be the most consistent so far. Anyway, my tope ones are

Sanders
Dart
Ward
Beck
Milroe
Ewers
Allar

Sanders.

Mara: I want a brand new QB for the holidays. Gimme a good one now now now.

Grinch Joe Schoen: laughing manically. Ho Ho No!!! because I built a team just good enough to not qualify for a QB in this years draft and no one wants to trade with us unless we massively overpay. And then no more gifts for several years.

Mara: Noooooo!!!!! this must be what hell feels like.

In comment 16649470 JT039 said:

Quote:

No Ward? You were huge on him last year. Cooling off on him or an oversight?

Cooling. A poster mentioned a few weeks ago that Ward's velocity didn't look great.

I made a mental note of that observation, and I think that poster might be right. So, I need to see more. I'm hoping ajr goes to a live game and gives his observations since he sees a lot of these guys live.

I'm curious to see how Dart bounces back from two subpar performances against LSU and SC.

In comment 16649496 bw in dc said:

Quote:

In comment 16649470 JT039 said: Quote: No Ward? You were huge on him last year. Cooling off on him or an oversight? Cooling. A poster mentioned a few weeks ago that Ward's velocity didn't look great. I made a mental note of that observation, and I think that poster might be right. So, I need to see more. I'm hoping ajr goes to a live game and gives his observations since he sees a lot of these guys live. I'm curious to see how Dart bounces back from two subpar performances against LSU and SC.

I thought Dart was decent against SC.

Be most comfortable with Sanders or Milroe.

Sleeper is a guy everyone says is too small and arm isn’t good enough… but Dillon Gabriel throws a sweet ball and looks to be a gamer. Might be a day three gem.

And Green or Gabriel day 3. We need two anyway.

In comment 16649501 gary_from_chester said:

Quote:

Be most comfortable with Sanders or Milroe. Sleeper is a guy everyone says is too small and arm isn’t good enough… but Dillon Gabriel throws a sweet ball and looks to be a gamer. Might be a day three gem.

I'm not a Grabiel guy, but he seems to me like a more athletic Tua.

Beck, Ewers. In that order right now. Willing to give Dart, Allar, and Gabriel the full season to assess afterwards. I'm hoping they all do the combine as well... though I doubt Ward and Becks will go. Those two are likely top ten material, and probably won't increase their stock in any way (aside from the measurements).

Don't really see greatness in him, though. Kind of a Kirk Cousins-type ceiling if I had to guess.

In comment 16649478 4xchamps said:

Quote:

In comment 16649442 ajr2456 said: Quote: But I’d be fine fine with Sanders, Ward or Nussmeier And statistically 2 of those guys will be out of the league in 4 years, one of them will be DJ type of average QB and one will be a star...

So you are in the camp of "Never try, because trying is the first step towards failure?"

In comment 16649484 Breeze_94 said:

Quote:

From Penn State. He’s got all of the tools.

When the dust settles going into the offseason, I believe Allar will be one of the most polarizing players in the draft.

But I'm leaning towards Ward and Milroe as of now

In comment 16649478 4xchamps said:

Quote:

In comment 16649442 ajr2456 said: Quote: But I’d be fine fine with Sanders, Ward or Nussmeier And statistically 2 of those guys will be out of the league in 4 years, one of them will be DJ type of average QB and one will be a star...

And factually, all of them will be on rookie contracts for those four years, which means that you actually can reinforce the rest of the roster, rather than being hamstrung by a $40M backup QB choking out your roster/cap composition.

In comment 16649478 4xchamps said:

Quote:

In comment 16649442 ajr2456 said: Quote: But I’d be fine fine with Sanders, Ward or Nussmeier And statistically 2 of those guys will be out of the league in 4 years, one of them will be DJ type of average QB and one will be a star...

That’s weird because two rookies are playing really well right now and two looked pretty solid in their debuts

“First round QBs bust”

“This guys WRs were always open”

Enough.

In comment 16649515 bw in dc said:

Quote:

In comment 16649484 Breeze_94 said: Quote: From Penn State. He’s got all of the tools. When the dust settles going into the offseason, I believe Allar will be one of the most polarizing players in the draft.

I agree with you. Size and arm strength alone is so appealing

Unlike robot Jones.

Milroe probably 2

Just a Junior, but his excellent season after the Georgia game is being largely overlooked. Former 5 star recruit from Texas.

D.J. Uiagalelei. One of the best pure passers in college football and has his team playing over their heads against some of the best competition in the nation.

In comment 16649604 Semipro Lineman said:

Quote:

D.J. Uiagalelei. One of the best pure passers in college football and has his team playing over their heads against some of the best competition in the nation.

Yeah, Heisman candidate..