he's a body catcher when the play calls for him to run a curl or comeback right at the first down marker. But when they - rarely - manage to get him the ball in space he's way better.
he's a body catcher when the play calls for him to run a curl or comeback right at the first down marker. But when they - rarely - manage to get him the ball in space he's way better.
Even with a good QB he’s a 30-50 yard a game player at best. Too many limitations to his game, especially for a high 2nd round pick. He’s not a complete waste but you expect more from the asset used to acquire him.
It doesn't matter who the QB is who threw it. Wandale is one of these "elusive" guys who don't seem to get YAC yards to match the perception of his game. Certainly not at the level of a 2nd rounder.
that says he's part of a deadly WR corp. He'd prolly look better with a better QB, but I don't see top tier as part of the description. So-so is more apt.
He's very good when he catches the ball in stride.
Defenses aren't giving him space because defense play right at the stick because they know the dufus at QB can't make a 2nd read or hit much of anything past 10 yards. Robinson would be a weapon if there was space to operate that comes with even an average QB. Enough with looking anywhere else to blame but the QB position.
when your QB sucks. Stop making excuses for your Sucky QB. Was Wandale worth a 2nd round pick... not in my opinion. But he is a good gadget player and would thrive in the right system.
Lots of drops. Does not make guys miss. Can be ok on the move and in limited role. Overrated by many on this board. Poor value in the second round. Not a true difference maker, the definition of JAG.
On the positive side, was much better value than Hyatt… what a disappointment he has been. I’d rather see Hodgins than either of these guys - he gets open, catches the ball and his size is a plus.
He has a high drop rate. Historically tiny catch radius that is exacerbated with body catching. Is a non-threat 5 yards beyond the LOS.
The stats also agree, as they average hardly over 4 yards when targeting him. To give you an idea of how inefficient he is…it’s like your QB dropping back 67 times in one game and only having 303 yards passing.
Robinson i believe was top five in yards per separation per catch.. which means he has the ability to get open.. NOW he needs to improve his receptions.. and they need to find ways to get him the ball other than..
Agree. He is very good player. Don't underestimate certain players on this team. That's what the Giants organization did and look at them thriving on another team!
Agree. He is very good player. Don't underestimate certain players on this team. That's what the Giants organization did and look at them thriving on another team!
is what he is. He’s a short field, twitchy underneath guy who can catch screens, bubble screens, slot and underneath stuff and short routes. He’s really a guy who is a #3 WR outside your two main wideouts.
type player. On an offense that is a threat to get the ball downfield, he could catch a lot of short passes, make a guy miss and turn a short gain into decent gain. Move the chains. Bail the QB out when he's under pressure. Problem is no defense is worried about us getting the ball downfield.
On this site can’t see what the primary problem is.
Post after post complaining about ancillary pieces. Daniel Jones fucken sucks…………
I don't think people grasp how teams are able to defend this offense with Jones at QB. The underneath game is shot because everyone can sit back in their zone and drill down on the shallow routes as soon as the ball is in the air because Jones gives them zero to worry about the vertical game. Same thing happening to Nabers --as soon as the ball is there, he gets mugged by two defenders. Go watch --it is plain as day. It was the exact case last year. In 2022, things were slightly different because defenses keyed on Saquon. You can't judge the talent of the WRs on this team because the QB limits the field of play. The one area of the field that defense worry about most is not a concern when they play us. In today's game --you cannot operate an offense that doesn't challenge defense vertically unless you have a monster of a running game, which we don't.
Tiny guy with small hands and short arms. How many WR’s with his physical profile have been good NFL WR’s? Yes, playing with Jones doesn’t help, but I think many here overrate him.
To clarify --when I said It was the exact case last year
Robinson was a downfield playmaker at Kentucky. I respect his effort to be a tackle breaking, dump off guy, but he's too small to be that consistently on this level.
Unfortunately the Giants can't pass the ball with any consistency downfield so this is what you get.
With absolutely no WR#1 on the roster, we could’ve had Pickens instead of Wandale. Wandale is not bad but for me I don’t see him as a high impact player.
we just had to.
another joe shcoen special.
Even with a good QB he’s a 30-50 yard a game player at best. Too many limitations to his game, especially for a high 2nd round pick. He’s not a complete waste but you expect more from the asset used to acquire him.
Yup. He’s a guy who would be a stud with a stud like Mahomes at QB
He’s not good enough to make chicken salad out of the chicken shit that is our QB and offense
Mahomes would love him.
Mahomes would love him.
Put him with Reid and see how much better he is.
Mahomes would love him.
Why? What have you seen him do this year that screams ‘dangerous?’
He wasn’t much of a fan of Toney, who also had a problem catching the ball.
Mahomes would love him.
Mahomes loves guys w crappy hands and runs 3rd down route short? Sure
Mahomes would love him.
Mahomes has 6 TDs and 8 INTs on the season, yet KC is 6-0
This… Robinson will be a good slot with a good QB.
Quote:
Wan'Dale with a real QB.
Mahomes would love him.
Mahomes has 6 TDs and 8 INTs on the season, yet KC is 6-0
His numbers are HORRIBLE this year. Spags defense is the main reason they are undefeated.
On the positive side, was much better value than Hyatt… what a disappointment he has been. I’d rather see Hodgins than either of these guys - he gets open, catches the ball and his size is a plus.
He has a high drop rate. Historically tiny catch radius that is exacerbated with body catching. Is a non-threat 5 yards beyond the LOS.
The stats also agree, as they average hardly over 4 yards when targeting him. To give you an idea of how inefficient he is…it’s like your QB dropping back 67 times in one game and only having 303 yards passing.
He's quite elusive in the open field, but has too many drops and also has a small catch radius because of his height.
My recollection is that Kafka really wanted him in the draft.
Quote:
Wan'Dale with a real QB.
Mahomes would love him.
Mahomes loves guys w crappy hands and runs 3rd down route short? Sure
It's why they drafted Sky Moore and traded for Toney
I just don't see a 2nd round talent there.
run a curl
Mahomes would love him.
Agree. He is very good player. Don't underestimate certain players on this team. That's what the Giants organization did and look at them thriving on another team!
Quote:
Wan'Dale with a real QB.
Mahomes would love him.
Agree. He is very good player. Don't underestimate certain players on this team. That's what the Giants organization did and look at them thriving on another team!
Mahomes really loved Toney! Oh, wait....
Post after post complaining about ancillary pieces. Daniel Jones fucken sucks…………
Same thing'll happen with Robinson.
When he leaves Jones behind his game will improve exponentially.
Post after post complaining about ancillary pieces. Daniel Jones fucken sucks…………
Unfortunately the Giants can't pass the ball with any consistency downfield so this is what you get.
Pickens just brings more to the table.